This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Section 404 Permit by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist
Use these forty questions with any Corps authorization, whether it is a nationwide permit verification or an individual permit. Each question ends with the chapter that explains the answer. Work through the groups in order the first time; later, jump to the group that matches the decision in front of you.
The permit family and the file
- Which authorization is in the file: a section 404 permit, a section 10 permit or both, and is it an individual permit, a nationwide permit verification or another kind of general permit? (Chapter 1)
- Who signed the document, and does the signature block belong to the district engineer of the district that holds the project? (Chapter 1)
- Does the file list the state and local approvals the project also needs, remembering that a Corps permit sits beside them and does not replace them? (Chapter 1)
- Is the file complete: application, drawings, jurisdiction document, public notice or verification letter, permit form, certifications and correspondence? (Chapter 12)
Jurisdiction
- Does the file contain a jurisdictional determination, and is it an approved one or a preliminary one? A preliminary one is advisory and cannot be appealed. (Chapter 2)
- If the determination is approved, does it say which waters are covered, and does its basis summarize the field indicators the district relied on? (Chapter 2)
- For each wetland treated as covered, does the file show how the wetland meets the current connection test described in Chapter 2? (Chapter 2)
- Do the limits of wetlands and streams on the jurisdiction document match the limits drawn on the permit drawings? (Chapters 2 and 7)
Nationwide permits and verifications
- Does the verification letter name the nationwide permit it relies on, and is that permit still in effect for the period of the work? (Chapters 3 and 4)
- Which general conditions and which regional conditions apply to this activity, and were they read along with the special conditions, not skipped? (Chapter 3)
- Was a pre-construction notification required for this activity, and does the file show that it was sent and answered by the district? (Chapter 4)
- Were the losses of the whole single and complete project added up before any limit of the nationwide permit was tested? (Chapter 3)
Individual permits and the decision
- Was the permit decided after a public notice, or issued in letter form after an abbreviated procedure? (Chapter 5)
- Does the decision document show a public interest review, with the benefits of the project weighed against its detriments? (Chapter 5)
- Which agencies and members of the public commented, and does the decision answer each concern that later became a condition? (Chapter 5)
- Does the description of the authorized work in the permit match the project the applicant actually described and drew? (Chapters 5 and 7)
Alternatives
- Does the file hold an alternatives analysis that compares practicable alternatives, rather than a list of options with no comparison? (Chapter 6)
- Does the file say whether the project is water dependent and, if it is not, why an alternative outside the aquatic site was not practicable? (Chapter 6)
- Does the file show how the footprint in waters was avoided or reduced before any mitigation was offered? (Chapter 6)
The permit form and special conditions
- Which general conditions are printed on the permit form, and which of them matter most for this project and this site? (Chapter 7)
- Is each special condition numbered, and does it say who must act, what is required and by what point in the work? (Chapter 7)
- Does each special condition tie to a drawing, a date or a trigger that a contractor can follow without guessing? (Chapter 7)
- Does the permit say how long it lasts, and what must be done if the schedule runs past that point? (Chapter 10)
Mitigation lines
- Does the permit require compensatory mitigation, and in what form: credits from a mitigation bank, credits from an in-lieu fee program or another form? (Chapter 7)
- Are the credit quantities stated separately for wetlands and for streams, and do they follow from the stated ratios and the impact figures? (Chapter 7)
- What proof of purchase or performance must reach the district, and before which stage of the work must it arrive? (Chapter 7)
- Does the permit require a recorded restriction or other long-term protection, and is the recorded document in the file? (Chapters 7 and 12)
Site conditions
- Do the limits of disturbance on the drawings match the fencing and silt fence on the ground, and who inspects them and when? (Chapter 8)
- Do the conditions on fill, culverts and work windows agree with the contractor's schedule, equipment plan and material sources? (Chapter 8)
- Which records must be kept, and can the site superintendent put a hand on the permit and its drawings on the job site? (Chapter 8)
Other approvals
- Is the state's section 401 certification in the file, and does the permit make its conditions conditions of the permit? (Chapter 9)
- Does the permit carry conditions from consultation under the Endangered Species Act or review under the National Historic Preservation Act, such as a clearing window or a discovery condition? (Chapter 9)
- Where the Coastal Zone Management Act applies, does the file show the state's coastal consistency decision? (Chapter 9)
Changes, transfers and appeals
- If the project changed after the permit issued, is there a written modification, and does it match what is being built? (Chapter 10)
- Is the permit's term long enough for the construction schedule, and if an extension is needed, where is the request and the district's answer? (Chapter 10)
- If the property was sold, was the permit transferred by the buyer's signature on the transfer block and sent to the district? (Chapter 10)
- Was any appeal filed against a jurisdictional determination, a denial or a declined permit, and did the request meet its deadline? (Chapters 2 and 10)
Enforcement and transactions
- Does the file hold any letter from the district about unauthorized work or noncompliance, such as a cease-and-desist letter, and is there a closing letter? (Chapter 11)
- Was any work done before it was authorized, and if so is there an after-the-fact permit application or permit in the file? (Chapter 11)
- For a buyer or lender: do the covenant, the credit purchase record, the compliance certification and the transfer record all appear in the closing file? (Chapter 12)