Free companion page
Free to print: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Schedule 13D, from How to Read a Schedule 13D.
This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Schedule 13D by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
Before anyone relies on a Schedule 13D or an amendment, whether a board preparing its response, a lawyer advising a holder, an analyst sizing a position or a journalist writing the evening story, there is a last pass. The forty questions below are that pass. They follow the order of the statement and then step outside it, to the thresholds read alongside it and to the filings that come after.
Each question is one line, followed by one sentence on why it matters. Each points to the chapter that holds the rule or the method. The case of Tarrowby Capital Management, LP and Penrallt Foods, Inc. shows every question at work, and a reader can test the list on it before using it on a real filing.
Is this an initial statement or an amendment, and if an amendment, which number? The amendment number places the document in a sequence, and a gap in the sequence is the first thing to explain (Chapter 3).
Which form is it, Schedule 13D or Schedule 13G, and does the choice fit what the filer says about its purpose? The two schedules carry different obligations, and a filer with plans to influence control reads very differently from a passive one (Chapter 1).
On what day did the filer cross the reporting threshold? Every deadline runs from that day, and the trade table is where a reader rebuilds it (Chapters 3 and 6).
Counting business days and any holiday, on what day was the initial statement due? A filing on the last permitted day and a filing well before it tell the reader different things about timing (Chapter 3).
At what time was it filed on EDGAR, and does the filing date shown match the business day on which it was submitted? The acceptance time decides which business day the statement belongs to (Chapter 3).
For an amendment, what event triggered it, and was it filed within the period the rules give? Each amendment answers to a material change, and a reader matches the change to the date (Chapter 3).
Who are the reporting persons, and does the list cover every entity in the chain of ownership? A statement that stops at the fund and leaves out the general partner, the adviser or the controlling person raises an immediate question (Chapter 4).
For each reporting person, what type of reporting person code does the cover page give, and what entity form does it show? The codes show the role each entity plays and help a reader rebuild the structure chart (Chapter 4).
How are voting and dispositive power split, sole or shared, for each reporting person? Shared power across the chain is common practice; sole power in one entity points to where decisions sit (Chapter 4).
What is the beneficial ownership figure, and does it include any right to acquire shares? Options and similar rights can move a holder across the threshold on their own (Chapter 2).
What denominator does the percentage use, and where does it come from? A reader checks the issuer's latest reported share count and any adjustment for the filer's own rights to acquire (Chapters 2 and 6).
Is there a group, and if so, which members, since when, and on what basis? A group's members are counted together, and the agreement or understanding that formed it is the key document (Chapter 2).
Does any reporting person disclaim beneficial ownership, and of what? A disclaimer is a statement of position, and the reader sets it beside the facts that Items 5 and 6 give (Chapters 2 and 7).
Does Item 3 give the total amount paid, with commissions, and does it reconcile with the shares and their prices? The reconciliation is a quick test of the whole statement's arithmetic (Chapter 4).
What part of the money is borrowed, from whom, and on what terms? Margin loans and other borrowing link Item 3 to Item 6 and to the exhibits (Chapter 4).
Do the source of funds codes on the cover page match the Item 3 narrative for each reporting person? A mismatch between the cover page and the Item is a drafting point that a reader raises (Chapter 4).
What does Item 4 say the filer intends, and which actions does it list? Item 4 is where plans for the board, the business or a transaction are disclosed (Chapter 5).
Which options does Item 4 keep open beyond the stated plans? A broad reservation is common practice, and a reader notes it so that later amendments can be read against it (Chapter 5).
Does the letter or presentation attached to the statement match Item 4? A demand in an exhibit that Item 4 does not mention is the first inconsistency to raise (Chapters 5 and 8).
Has Item 4 changed from the last statement, and what changed? A comparison of successive Item 4s is the quickest way to follow a campaign (Chapters 5 and 10).
Does the trade table cover every transaction within the period Item 5 requires? A reader counts back from the filing date and checks that no day is missing (Chapter 6).
For each trade, are the date, quantity and price given, and is it clear which reporting person made it? Each line is a fact a reader may need later, for the crossing, the cost and other thresholds (Chapter 6).
Do the trades add up to the beneficial ownership figure, together with earlier holdings? A reader rebuilds the stake from the table and any earlier block (Chapters 6 and 11).
Which derivatives does Item 6 describe, and against which reference security? Since the 2023 amendments, Item 6 reaches derivatives of every kind that use the class as a reference (Chapter 7).
For each option, what are the strike, the expiry, the settlement method and the exercise terms? These terms decide whether the option belongs in the beneficial ownership count (Chapters 2 and 7).
For each cash-settled swap, who is the counterparty, what is the notional, and are any voting, disposition or delivery rights stated? The facts are what a reader applies the guidance on cash-settled derivatives to (Chapter 7).
What is the filer's economic exposure, shares plus options plus swap notional, as a share of the class? Exposure can differ widely from the cover page figure, and other rules may count it (Chapters 7 and 9).
Has any derivative described earlier been closed, extended or replaced? Unwinds and new contracts are events that later amendments must report (Chapters 3 and 7).
Does every written agreement behind Items 3, 4 and 6 appear in the exhibit list? Item 7 mirrors those Items, and a missing document is a question to raise (Chapter 8).
Is there a joint filing agreement covering every reporting person, including any added by amendment? Joint filing rests on that agreement, and each filer answers for its own information (Chapter 8).
If there is a group agreement, what does it say about purpose, trading, public statements, any ownership cap and termination? The group agreement shows how the members will act together (Chapter 8).
If there is a cooperation agreement, what are the board changes, the standstill, the voting commitment, the expense terms and the end date? Each term has a date, and later readings depend on it (Chapters 8 and 10).
Is every incorporation by reference clearly identified, and is the Item still clear without the exhibit? An Item that only points to an exhibit can hide more than it shows (Chapter 8).
Is any filer, or the group, close to the section 16 line, measured on the section 13(d) concept? Crossing it brings ownership reports and exposure to short-swing profit rules (Chapter 9).
If a filer is above that line, do any purchases and sales in the trade tables fall within six months of each other? A matched purchase and sale can produce a profit that belongs to the issuer (Chapter 9).
What is the stake worth at current prices against the HSR threshold in force, and does Item 4 bear on the investment-only exemption? Value and intention are the two HSR questions a Schedule 13D helps a reader frame (Chapter 9).
Does the issuer have a rights plan, and what is each filer's percentage under the plan's own definition of ownership? A plan may count derivatives and groups differently from Rule 13d-3 (Chapter 9).
Does the amendment update every Item affected by the change, not only the one it headlines? A settlement, for example, touches Items 4, 5, 6 and 7 at once (Chapters 3 and 10).
For a nomination, how does the notice fit the issuer's bylaw window and the universal proxy rule? The two deadlines are separate, and a reader checks both (Chapter 10).
For an exit, does the amendment give the Item 5(e) date, and does the cover page match the trade that took the filer below the threshold? The exit amendment closes the record, and its date must agree with the trade table (Chapter 10).
Key Takeaway: Forty questions in seven groups take a reader through a Schedule 13D in order: timing, filers and stake, funds and purpose, trades and derivatives, exhibits, the thresholds around the filing, and the amendments to the exit. Each question points to the chapter that holds its rule. Run on Tarrowby's five filings, the list rebuilds the whole case; run on any real statement, it shows where the record is complete and where a reader still has a question.