Free companion page
Free to print: Tool 1: Registration and rent history diligence check-list, from The Rent-Regulated Housing Investor.
This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from The Rent-Regulated Housing Investor by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
Purpose: to rebuild the legal regulated rent of each unit from the paper, before any price is set. The rules come from DHCR's Fact Sheet 40 on preferential rents (May 2024), the agency's rent registration page and the Rent Stabilization Law, section 26-517(e) of the New York City Administrative Code, all read on 22 October 2026. The 2019 rent law did not amend that section.
What the rules say, in plain words:
The check-list works with one row per unit and year. Start with the years in the data room (in the case, DHCR registrations for 2016 to 2026) and fill the grid.
| Item to pull | Where it comes from | Red flag |
|---|---|---|
| Registered rent and status | Annual registration | A year with no filing, or a status that changes without a reason |
| Rent actually charged | Lease and rent ledger | Charged rent above the last registered legal rent |
| Preferential rent flag | Registration and lease | A preferential rent registered, then dropped to nothing |
| Tenant's copy of registration | Property manager files | No proof that the tenant received it |
| Lease renewals | Lease file | An increase that does not match the order for its start date |
| Improvements claimed | Registration notes and invoices | An increase with no invoice behind it |
Add one more column to your own grid: "Open question for counsel". A red flag is not a conclusion. It is a question, and whether a rent is legal depends on the facts, the rent history and current law.
Worked on the case: the data room shows a rent roll with 168 occupied units paying a preferential rent, an average of $1,720 a month against a registered legal rent of $2,240, a gap of $520 a month. The check-list does not decide whether that legal rent is right. It decides what must be proven. For each of those 168 units, the analyst asks whether the registered legal rent is supported by the filings and whether the preferential flag appears in each year. Then the analyst asks, for a tenancy in place on or after 14 June 2019, whether the tenant keeps the preferential rent, which affects how much of the $1,048,320 annual gap can ever be collected.
Your own use: write the number of units, the number of years, and the number of rows with a red flag, and report the third number as a share of the first two multiplied together.