Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Registration Rights Agreement

Free to print: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Registration Rights Agreement, from How to Read a Registration Rights Agreement.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Registration Rights Agreement by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Registration Rights Agreement

Forty questions are the last thing to read before signing registration rights, before exercising them and before underwriting an offering that depends on them. They follow the order of a typical agreement, from the definitions to the termination clause, and each one points to the chapter where the issue is read in full.

The questions are written to be asked of any agreement, not only the Halcyon Biosystems Inc. one. Where the case helps, it appears as a reminder: Larchmere Ventures Fund IV LP as the venture fund with a board seat and demand rights, the founders as the two founders who hold their shares together, Quarrybrook Growth Partners LP as the growth fund that buys in a PIPE in Year 2. The figures belong to earlier chapters; this chapter asks what to look for.

Each question is one line, followed by one sentence on why it matters. A reader on the company's side and a reader on a holder's side ask the same questions; they hope for different answers.

Parties, holders and registrable securities (questions 1 to 7)

The definitions decide everything that follows (Chapter 2). A right that looks generous in the operative sections can be empty if the definitions narrow it.

  1. Who signs, and who can join later by a joinder?
    Why: a holder that is not a party, and has no way to join, has no rights at all.

  2. How are "holders" defined, and by what share count are their votes measured?
    Why: thresholds for demands and amendments are counted in that measure.

  3. Which securities are registrable securities, and do they include shares issued on exercise, conversion or as dividends?
    Why: a registration that covers the original shares but not the shares received later leaves part of the position restricted.

  4. When does a security stop being a registrable security?
    Why: the moment it stops is the moment every right attached to it ends.

  5. Are affiliates of a holder treated as one holder?
    Why: aggregation decides whether a group of funds meets a demand threshold together.

  6. How does the agreement treat holders who are affiliates of the company, as Larchmere and the founders are in the case?
    Why: affiliates stay subject to the Rule 144 volume limit and may need their rights for longer.

  7. Does the agreement override or coordinate with earlier registration rights granted by the company?
    Why: an older agreement with a conflicting priority can take shares out of a later holder's allocation.

Demand rights (8 to 14)

Demand rights let a holder require the company to file (Chapter 3). They are the most valuable right and the most tightly limited.

  1. Who may make a demand, and what share of holders must join?
    Why: a high threshold can make the right unusable for any single fund.

  2. How many long-form demands and how many short-form demands are allowed?
    Why: the count is the holder's total budget of company-led registrations.

  3. Is there a minimum size per demand, in shares or in expected proceeds?
    Why: a minimum protects the company from small, costly registrations and limits a holder's flexibility.

  4. How often may demands be made, and over what period is that counted?
    Why: frequency limits decide whether two demands can follow each other closely.

  5. When does a demand count as used, and does a withdrawn demand count?
    Why: a demand lost to a withdrawn or cut-back offering is a right gone for nothing.

  6. May the company delay a demand, for how long and how often?
    Why: a deferral right is a timing risk the holder must price.

  7. Who selects the underwriters in a demand offering?
    Why: the selection shapes the offering's terms and the underwriter's cutback advice.

Piggyback rights and cutbacks (15 to 20)

Piggyback rights let holders join someone else's registration, subject to the underwriters' cutback (Chapter 4). The priority clause is where value moves.

  1. Which registrations trigger piggyback rights, and which are excluded?
    Why: exclusions for employee plans, mergers or exchange offers narrow the right.

  2. How much notice does the company give, and how long do holders have to respond?
    Why: a short window can make the right impractical for holders with internal approvals.

  3. In a company offering, what is the priority order when the underwriters cut back?
    Why: the company usually comes first, and the holders share what is left.

  4. In a demand offering, does the demanding holder come before the piggybacking holders?
    Why: in the case, the demander-first rule and a pro rata rule give very different allocations.

  5. Within a priority tier, is the cutback pro rata to shares requested or to shares held?
    Why: the base of the proration changes each holder's share.

  6. May the company abandon a registration after holders have joined, and who pays then?
    Why: a holder needs to know whether a dropped offering costs it anything.

Shelf, take-downs and blocks (21 to 25)

Shelf rights keep a registration statement continuously available for sales over time (Chapter 5).

  1. When must the company file a resale shelf, and on which form?
    Why: the obligation often starts only once the company is eligible for Form S-3.

  2. How long must the shelf stay effective?
    Why: a shelf that lapses before the rights end leaves the holder without a route.

  3. How many underwritten take-downs may a holder request, and with what minimum size?
    Why: take-downs are the shelf counterpart of demands and carry their own limits.

  4. Does the agreement allow block trades and overnight offerings, and with what notice to other holders?
    Why: short-notice sales limit other holders' piggyback participation.

  5. Does the agreement address the company's status as a well-known seasoned issuer under Rule 405?
    Why: that status changes how quickly a shelf can be filed and used.

Lock-ups, holdbacks and suspensions (26 to 31)

These clauses decide when a holder may not sell even though its rights exist (Chapter 6 and Chapter 7).

  1. How long is any lock-up, and from what event does it run?
    Why: the start date decides the first day a holder may sell.

  2. Is there an early release, on what price test and for what share of the locked shares?
    Why: in the case, a price-based early release opened part of the locked shares on day 90.

  3. What holdback do holders give around an underwritten offering, and does it bind only holders who sell?
    Why: a holdback that binds non-selling holders restricts them without any benefit.

  4. Do releases granted to one holder extend to the others (a most favored nation release)?
    Why: without one, a release negotiated by a large holder may leave smaller ones locked.

  5. For how long and how often may the company suspend use of the prospectus?
    Why: both limits together cap the time a holder can be frozen.

  6. What must the company tell holders when it suspends, and when must the suspension end?
    Why: a holder may not want inside information, and a suspension without an end point is open-ended.

Deadlines, damages, expenses and indemnity (32 to 37)

These clauses set the price of failure and the allocation of cost and risk (Chapter 7, Chapter 8 and Chapter 9).

  1. What are the filing and effectiveness deadlines, and how are they extended for an SEC review?
    Why: the deadlines are the dates against which delay is measured.

  2. What are the rate, base, proration and cap of any liquidated damages?
    Why: each word changes the amount; recompute it on a sample delay.

  3. Are liquidated damages the exclusive monetary remedy, and what stops the clock?
    Why: the answer decides the company's worst case and the holder's fallback.

  4. Which costs are registration expenses paid by the company, and which are selling expenses paid by each seller?
    Why: the split decides what a registration actually costs each side.

  5. Does the company's indemnity cover all offering materials, with a carve-out limited to information the holder supplied?
    Why: a broad carve-out shifts disclosure risk onto the holder.

  6. Is the holder's indemnity and contribution capped at net proceeds, several and not joint?
    Why: in the case, Larchmere's exposure stops at the net proceeds of its own sale.

Transfer, amendment and termination (38 to 40)

The last three questions decide whether the rights survive a sale, a vote or the passage of time (Chapter 2, Chapter 9 and Chapter 10).

  1. May the rights be assigned, to whom, and with what minimum block?
    Why: rights that cannot follow the shares lower their value to a buyer.

  2. Who may amend or waive the agreement, and may an amendment treat one holder worse than others without its consent?
    Why: a majority vote can otherwise strip a minority holder's rights.

  3. When do the rights end for each holder?
    Why: in the case, Quarrybrook's rights end on the first anniversary of its PIPE closing while the affiliates keep theirs.

Two patterns run through the list. First, most questions have a company answer and a holder answer, and an agreement that a reader finds one-sided usually reflects the bargaining position at signing rather than a drafting error. Second, many questions cannot be answered from one clause: question 18 needs the definitions, question 34 needs the suspension clause, and question 40 needs the status of each holder. Reading the agreement once from start to finish, then again with the forty questions, catches what a single pass misses.

On the reading desk

Key Takeaway: Forty questions, in the order of the agreement, cover the parties and registrable securities (1 to 7), demands (8 to 14), piggybacks and cutbacks (15 to 20), shelves (21 to 25), lock-ups and suspensions (26 to 31), deadlines, damages, expenses and indemnity (32 to 37), and transfer, amendment and termination (38 to 40). Each points to a chapter where the issue is read in full. In the case, the answers to questions 18, 37 and 40 alone decide how many shares Larchmere sells, how much it could owe back and when Quarrybrook's rights end.