Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Power Tolling Agreement

Free to print: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Tolling Agreement, from How to Read a Power Tolling Agreement.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Power Tolling Agreement by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Tolling Agreement

These forty questions are the last thing to read before you sign, finance or approve a toll. They are not a substitute for the contract or for counsel. They are the questions that, asked in order, would have caught every issue this book has walked through on Cedar Fork Energy Center, and that a reader should be able to answer from the document in front of them.

Each question names what to find and gives one sentence on why it matters. The chapter numbers point to where the book reads the clause in full. Apply them to the gas toll on a plant like Cedar Fork Energy Center, and to the storage toll on a battery like Cedar Fork Storage, where the questions on fuel and heat rate turn into questions on charging energy and round-trip efficiency.

A word on how to use the list. Do not read it as forty boxes to tick. Read it as forty places where an owner and a toller can quietly disagree about who carries a risk. When a question has no clear answer in the contract, that silence is itself the finding. In the case, Cedar Fork Power LLC and Halcott Electric Company each had counsel asking these questions from the other side of the table; your job is to ask all of them, for both sides.

Parties, facility and term (questions 1 to 6)

  1. Who exactly are the owner and the toller, and is either a special purpose company with no assets beyond the contract?
    Why: a project company like Cedar Fork Power LLC owns one plant, so its credit is the plant, and the toller's credit may rest on a parent (Chapters 2 and 9).

  2. How is the facility described: site, nameplate, contracted capacity and any later changes?
    Why: the contracted capacity is the base of every payment, and a loose description invites disputes about what the toller is paying for (Chapter 2).

  3. What are the conditions to commercial operation, and who certifies that they are met?
    Why: the delivery term and the capacity payment start on that date, so a vague test moves money from day one (Chapter 2).

  4. What happens if commercial operation is late: delay damages, cap and long-stop date?
    Why: delay is the owner's main construction risk under the toll, and the long-stop date is where the toller can walk away (Chapter 2).

  5. How long is the delivery term, and can either party extend it?
    Why: the term sets how much debt the capacity payment can carry and what happens to the plant afterward (Chapters 2 and 10).

  6. Does the toll need a state commission approval or any federal filing to take effect?
    Why: a toll with a regulated utility may not bind until approved, and conditions on the approval can change the bargain (Chapters 1 and 10).

Price and payments (questions 7 to 12)

  1. What is the capacity payment, in what unit, and on what capacity is it paid?
    Why: it is the owner's revenue and the toller's fixed cost, and it is usually expressed in dollars per kW-month on tested capacity (Chapter 3).

  2. How does the capacity payment escalate: fixed rate, index, or none?
    Why: escalation that lags the owner's fixed costs squeezes the margin over the term (Chapters 3 and 11).

  3. Which costs does the capacity payment cover, and which are billed separately?
    Why: double counting or gaps between the capacity payment and the variable charges are a common source of invoice disputes (Chapters 3 and 7).

  4. When are payments due, what interest runs on late payment, and is there a right of set-off?
    Why: set-off lets one party net amounts across the contract, which changes who carries the credit risk in a dispute (Chapter 3).

  5. Is any part of the capacity payment at risk beyond availability and capacity tests?
    Why: performance adjustments layered on the capacity payment can reduce the revenue that lenders assumed was fixed (Chapters 3 and 4).

  6. Does the contract cap the total adjustments the owner can suffer in a year?
    Why: an annual cap on discounts protects the debt and is one of the first things a lender looks for (Chapters 4 and 11).

Availability and capacity (questions 13 to 18)

  1. How is availability defined and measured, hour by hour or otherwise?
    Why: the definition decides whether a derate, a partial outage or a start failure counts against the owner (Chapter 4).

  2. What is the availability guarantee, and is it set by season or by year?
    Why: a single annual figure treats a summer outage like a spring one, while seasonal targets weigh the hours the toller values most (Chapter 4).

  3. How is the availability discount calculated, and is there a bonus for exceeding the guarantee?
    Why: a multiplier on the shortfall makes outages cost more than the revenue lost, and symmetry is a negotiated term, not a given (Chapter 4).

  4. Which outages are excluded: planned maintenance, force majeure, toller-caused, grid-caused?
    Why: every exclusion shifts risk from owner to toller, and the list is where most availability disputes start (Chapters 4 and 10).

  5. How and when are capacity tests run, corrected and repeated?
    Why: a test resets the capacity on which the toller pays, so ambient corrections and the right to retest move money (Chapter 4).

  6. What happens if capacity falls below a floor, and is there a termination right?
    Why: a persistent shortfall can turn a payment issue into a default (Chapters 4 and 10).

Dispatch, fuel and heat rate (questions 19 to 26)

  1. How does the toller schedule the plant: notice periods, day-ahead and real-time?
    Why: the toller's dispatch right is what it pays for, and notice periods define how flexible that right really is (Chapter 5).

  2. What are the operating limits: minimum load, ramp rates, minimum run and down times, start limits?
    Why: limits protect the plant but cap the toller's value, so each one is a negotiated trade (Chapter 5).

  3. How does the toll interact with the grid operator's market rules and instructions?
    Why: in an organized wholesale market, the plant must follow the operator, and the toll must say who bears the cost when the two conflict (Chapter 5).

  4. Who supplies the fuel, where is it delivered, and who holds title?
    Why: under a toll the toller delivers the gas and keeps title, which is what makes the contract a fuel conversion deal rather than a power sale (Chapters 1 and 6).

  5. Who holds gas transport capacity and pays for imbalances?
    Why: transport and imbalance costs can be large and fall on whoever the contract names (Chapter 6).

  6. What is the heat rate guarantee, by load level and corrected for ambient conditions?
    Why: a single-point guarantee ignores the load at which the toller actually runs the plant (Chapter 6).

  7. Does the heat rate settlement run both ways, and how often is it settled?
    Why: a symmetric settlement rewards an efficient owner and compensates the toller for excess gas, as the case shows (Chapters 6 and 11).

  8. What happens if the toller fails to deliver fuel when it has scheduled the plant?
    Why: a plant that is available but has no fuel should not lose its capacity payment through no fault of its own (Chapters 5 and 6).

Variable charges, emissions and storage (questions 27 to 31)

  1. What is the variable O&M rate, how is it escalated, and on what volume is it billed?
    Why: the rate is a price, not a reimbursement, so the owner keeps the margin and carries the risk of cost overruns (Chapter 7).

  2. How many starts are included, what does an extra start cost, and what counts as a start?
    Why: starts drive maintenance, and the allowance and definition decide who pays for cycling (Chapter 7).

  3. Are emissions costs expressly for the toller's account, and how are allowances transferred?
    Why: the toller controls dispatch and therefore emissions, but only the contract allocates the cost (Chapter 7).

  4. For a storage toll, what are the round-trip efficiency guarantee, the cycle limits and the state-of-charge range?
    Why: these replace the heat rate and the operating limits of a gas toll and are where a battery's value and wear are traded (Chapter 8).

  5. For a storage toll, how is degradation measured, and must the owner augment or accept a reduced payment?
    Why: capacity fades every year, and the augmentation rule decides whether the toller keeps the energy it pays for (Chapter 8).

Credit, termination and law (questions 32 to 40)

  1. What credit support does the toller post, and what triggers more?
    Why: a ratings trigger can require a large letter of credit within days of a downgrade (Chapter 9).

  2. What credit support does the owner post before and after commercial operation?
    Why: the owner's support is usually smaller than the toller's replacement cost, and the gap should be known (Chapter 9).

  3. Can either party call for more support as exposure grows, and how long does the other have to post?
    Why: a short posting deadline backed by an event of default turns a liquidity issue into a termination risk (Chapter 9).

  4. Do the owner's lenders have a direct agreement with the toller, with cure and step-in rights?
    Why: the direct agreement is what keeps the plant and the contract alive if the owner fails (Chapter 9).

  5. What does force majeure excuse, what does it exclude, and when does it become a termination right?
    Why: payment is usually never excused, and a long event can end the contract (Chapter 10).

  6. How is change in law defined and allocated, and is a public interest standard of review adopted?
    Why: change in law decides who pays for new rules, and the standard of review decides how hard the price is to reopen (Chapter 10).

  7. What are the events of default, with their cure periods, and how is the early termination date set?
    Why: cure periods and notice mechanics decide how quickly a dispute turns into a termination (Chapter 10).

  8. How is the termination payment calculated in each direction, and how does it compare with the loan balance?
    Why: the payment is the value lost by the non-defaulting party, which may fall short of the debt, as the case shows at the end of Year 5 (Chapters 10 and 11).

  9. Which law governs, how are disputes resolved, and what survives the end of the term?
    Why: the governing law, the forum and the surviving obligations decide how every other answer on this list is enforced (Chapter 10).

On the operator's desk

Key Takeaway: Forty questions, in six groups, cover a tolling agreement from parties to governing law. Read on Cedar Fork Energy Center, a 480 MW plant tolled to Halcott Electric Company, they lead back to every risk this book has priced: availability, heat rate, starts, emissions, credit and termination. The questions the contract cannot answer are the most important ones to bring to the table.