Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Planning Permission

Free to print: Appendix A: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Planning Permission, from How to Read a Planning Permission.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Planning Permission by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Appendix A: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Planning Permission

Use these questions with any planning permission granted in England. Each item gives the question, a sentence on why it matters, and the chapter that explains the point. The list is a reading aid, not legal, planning, valuation or investment advice.

The Grant and Its Documents (Questions 1 to 6)

  1. Which authority granted the permission, to whom, and is the document a grant or only a resolution to grant? A committee resolution is a step towards a permission, and only the issued decision notice carries the grant. (Chapter 1)
  2. Is the land described precisely, and does the site plan match the land you are buying or lending against? A permission binds the land, so a mismatch at the site edge can leave part of a scheme without cover. (Chapter 1)
  3. Does the description of development say what is authorised in words that can be tested against what is built? The description marks the outer limit of the permission, and loose wording invites argument later. (Chapter 2)
  4. Is there a condition listing the approved plans and documents, with drawing references and revisions? Without that list you cannot tell which version of the scheme was approved. (Chapter 2)
  5. Which parts of the notice are conditions and which are informatives? Informatives only advise, and treating one as binding, or a condition as advice, distorts the programme. (Chapter 2)
  6. Does the officer's report support the reasons in the notice and recommend what was actually granted? The report explains why each condition exists and helps with any wording that is unclear. (Chapter 2)

Conditions and Their Tests (Questions 7 to 13)

  1. Does every condition carry a stated reason? The reason shows what the condition is for, which is the first step in testing it. (Chapter 3)
  2. Is each condition necessary, so that the permission would be unacceptable without it? A condition that does no necessary work is a candidate for challenge. (Chapter 3)
  3. Is each condition relevant to planning and relevant to the development permitted? A requirement about something outside the development, or outside planning, does not meet the tests. (Chapter 3)
  4. Is each condition enforceable, and by what means could the council police it? A condition that cannot be policed gives little protection to the council, the buyer or the lender. (Chapter 3)
  5. Is each condition precise enough for a site manager to know what to do and when? Vague wording leads to disputes about whether the condition has been met. (Chapter 3)
  6. Is each condition reasonable in what it asks, in cost and in timing? A demanding requirement is the first place to look for a condition that is open to question. (Chapter 3)
  7. Does any condition depend on land or action the developer does not control, such as a negatively worded condition? Such a condition can hold up a scheme until a third party acts. (Chapter 3)

Pre-Commencement Conditions and Discharge (Questions 14 to 18)

  1. Which conditions must be met before any work begins? This list is the starting point of the programme and of the conditions tracker. (Chapter 4)
  2. For each one, what must be submitted, to whom, and what counts as approval? A route that is unclear at the start becomes a delay once the contractor is ready to mobilise. (Chapter 4)
  3. Has an application to discharge each condition been made, and on what date did the council receive it? The decision period runs from receipt, so the date of receipt is the date that matters. (Chapter 4)
  4. Has the council decided in time, and if not, is deemed discharge available and has the proper notice been given? Deemed discharge can lift a condition, but only if its steps are followed and the condition is not of an excluded kind. (Chapter 4)
  5. Is written evidence of each discharge on the file? Later buyers and lenders ask for it, and a recollection is not evidence. (Chapter 4)

Outline, Reserved Matters and Time Limits (Questions 19 to 24)

  1. Is this an outline permission or a full one? The answer shows whether anything remains to be approved before building can begin. (Chapter 5)
  2. Which matters were reserved, and which were settled at the outline stage? The reserved list shows what still needs approval, and the rest shows what the outline already fixed. (Chapter 5)
  3. What is the time limit to apply for approval of the reserved matters, and from what event does it run? Missing this limit puts the whole permission at risk. (Chapter 5)
  4. What is the time limit to begin development, and from what event does it run? The second clock starts from a different event, so the two dates must be worked out separately. (Chapter 5)
  5. Has a reserved matters approval been given, and have its own conditions been read? An approval is a decision with conditions of its own, to be read together with the outline. (Chapter 5)
  6. Do the conditions of the outline and of the reserved matters approval fit together? Mismatches can arise where plans develop between the two stages, so each condition should be traced to the approval it belongs to. (Chapter 5)

Beginning and Completing Development (Questions 25 to 28)

  1. What act on site counts as beginning development, and has it happened? Beginning keeps a permission alive and is also the point at which the pre-commencement conditions bite. (Chapter 6)
  2. Is there dated evidence of the start, such as photographs and site records? Proof of the start date may be needed long after the groundworker has left the site. (Chapter 6)
  3. Were the pre-commencement conditions dealt with before the work started? Work begun before they were met raises a question about whether the start keeps the permission alive. (Chapter 6)
  4. Does any condition or phasing arrangement say when parts of the scheme must be finished, and can the programme meet it? A requirement about completion can bite long after the start, so it belongs in the programme from day one. (Chapter 6)

Changes to the Permission (Questions 29 to 32)

  1. Is the proposed change small enough to be treated as a non-material amendment? A lighter route exists, but only where the council is satisfied that the change is not material. (Chapter 7)
  2. Is there an approved plans condition that a section 73 application can vary? Without that condition the section 73 route cannot be used. (Chapter 7)
  3. If a section 73 permission has been granted, which conditions and time limits does the new permission carry? It is a new permission, so the new notice must be read in full and not only the varied condition. (Chapter 7)
  4. Is anyone relying on the section 73B route? A route created by the Levelling-up and Regeneration Act 2023 that is not yet in force cannot support a plan today. (Chapter 7)

Uses, Permitted Development and the Levy (Questions 33 to 37)

  1. Which use class does each part of the scheme fall into, and does a condition narrow it? A condition can limit a unit to less than its use class would otherwise allow. (Chapter 8)
  2. Have permitted development rights been withdrawn for any plots or buildings, by condition or by direction? Where they have, an extension or outbuilding may need its own permission. (Chapter 8)
  3. Would a planned change of use, extension or outbuilding need a separate permission? The permission does not say everything that is allowed on the land, so the wider rules must be checked. (Chapter 8)
  4. Has the council issued a liability notice, and who has taken on liability by an assumption of liability notice? The notices fix who is asked to pay the levy and how much. (Chapter 9)
  5. Was any relief claimed before work started, and was a commencement notice given before the start? A missed notice or a late claim can change what is payable and when. (Chapter 9)

Enforcement, Appeals and the File (Questions 38 to 40)

  1. Is there any sign of breach, and is any enforcement notice, breach of condition notice or lawful development certificate on the file? These documents show the position the council has taken and what remains open. (Chapter 10)
  2. Has any decision been appealed or challenged, and are the time limits for doing so still open? Rights to appeal and to challenge are time-limited, and a buyer or lender needs to know what is still open. (Chapter 11)
  3. Is the file complete, with the notice, the plans, the report, the discharges, the levy papers and dated evidence of the start? A complete file lets the next reader answer every question above without chasing papers. (Chapter 11)