Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a PBM Agreement

Free to print: Appendix A: The Forty-Question Checklist for Any PBM Agreement, from How to Read a PBM Agreement.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a PBM Agreement by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Appendix A: The Forty-Question Checklist for Any PBM Agreement

Use this checklist with the pharmacy benefit management agreement open next to it. Each question has a short reason and the chapter that treats it. The list asks what to look for; it never says what a contract should contain, and it is not legal, benefits or tax advice.

A practical way to use it: read the contract once through, then go group by group. Mark each question as answered by the text, answered by another document, or not answered at all. The third mark is the most useful, because a contract that is silent on a point leaves the answer to the manager's practice. Keep the list beside the offer comparison grid in Appendix B and the terms in Appendix C. When two offers are compared, run the same list on each and set the answers side by side, since a question that one contract answers and the other leaves open is often where the price difference hides.

Parties and documents (questions 1 to 6)

  1. Which legal entity signs as the manager, and is it the one that owns the pharmacies and the rebate relationships? The entity that signs may not be the entity that earns the money. (Chapter 1)

  2. Who signs for the plan sponsor, and does the signer have authority over the group health plan? A contract signed by the wrong party can leave the plan without the rights the sponsor thinks it bought. (Chapter 1)

  3. Which documents make up the contract, and which one wins in a conflict? Pricing exhibits, schedules and proposal responses often sit outside the main body. (Chapter 1)

  4. Are the manager's affiliates, rebate aggregators and group purchasing organizations named, and do the plan's rights reach them? Money often moves through affiliates before it reaches the plan. (Chapter 1)

  5. Does the contract say whether the manager acts as a fiduciary, an agent or a vendor, and does that match how the sponsor describes it? The label shapes duties and disputes. (Chapters 1 and 11)

  6. Does the plan's own consultant or broker disclose what it is paid, and by whom? Unseen compensation on the plan side changes how much weight advice deserves. (Chapter 9)

Definitions (questions 7 to 13)

  1. Which source sets average wholesale price, and what happens if that source changes or disappears? Every discount is a percentage of this number. (Chapter 2)

  2. How does the contract classify a drug as brand or generic, and who decides when the classification is unclear? The class decides which discount and which guarantee apply. (Chapter 2)

  3. Who writes the maximum allowable cost list, how often can it change, and can the plan see it? A list the manager controls can move the price of a generic without any change to the contract. (Chapter 2)

  4. How is a specialty drug defined, and can the manager add drugs to the definition during the term? A wider definition moves claims from one pricing set to another. (Chapter 6)

  5. Is lesser-of logic written into the contract, and does it include the usual and customary price? Without it, the plan may pay more than the pharmacy's own cash price. (Chapter 2)

  6. How is a paid claim defined for guarantees and fees, and are reversals and adjustments netted out? A fee charged per claim is only as clear as the claim count behind it. (Chapter 3)

  7. How are rebates defined, and does the definition stop at formulary rebates? Whatever falls outside the definition can be kept by the manager. (Chapter 5)

Pricing and fees (questions 14 to 21)

  1. Are discount guarantees measured claim by claim or in the aggregate? Aggregate measurement lets strong results on some claims cover weak results on others. (Chapter 3)

  2. Are guarantees set separately for brand, generic and specialty, and by channel? Blending categories can hide a weak spot. (Chapter 3)

  3. Is the generic guarantee stated as an effective rate, and over which claims is it measured? An effective rate is only meaningful if the claim set is clear. (Chapter 3)

  4. What dispensing fee applies to each type of claim, and is it a cap, a fixed fee or a pass-through? A small fee per claim becomes a large number across a year. (Chapter 3)

  5. Is there an administrative fee, a claims administration fee or both, and which claims carry them? A low rate with a fee on every claim can cost more than it first appears. (Chapter 4)

  6. Does the plan pay exactly what the pharmacy is paid, or can the manager keep a difference? That difference is the spread, and the contract either allows it or does not. (Chapter 4)

  7. How and when is the year closed and trued up, and who pays when a guarantee is missed? A guarantee without a true-up date and a payment path is a promise with no remedy. (Chapter 3)

  8. Can the manager change prices, lists or fees during the term, and with what notice? A fixed price can be undone by a right to adjust the inputs. (Chapter 3)

Rebates (questions 22 to 28)

  1. Does the contract pass through all manufacturer revenue or only a share, and which payments are in scope? Price protection and administrative fees are payments that a narrow definition can leave out. (Chapter 5)

  2. Is the rebate guarantee a minimum, an actual amount or the greater of the two? The structure decides who bears the risk when real rebates differ from the guarantee. (Chapter 5)

  3. Is the guarantee stated per claim, and does it cover brand claims only? Claims outside the guarantee still earn the manager money. (Chapter 5)

  4. What conditions must the plan meet for the guarantee to apply, such as formulary adoption or exclusion lists? A guarantee tied to conditions is only as firm as the conditions. (Chapter 7)

  5. When are rebates paid, how often, and how long after the period closes? Timing shifts the cost of holding the money. (Chapter 5)

  6. Does the manager keep any fee for managing rebates, and does an aggregator keep a further share? Each layer between the manufacturer and the plan can take a cut. (Chapter 5)

  7. Can the plan see the manufacturer contracts or an audited summary of them? Without a view of the source, the plan relies on the manager's statement. (Chapter 9)

Specialty, formulary and network (questions 29 to 34)

  1. Must specialty drugs be filled at the manager's own specialty pharmacy, and what happens to the price if they are not? Exclusivity limits where the plan can look for a better price. (Chapter 6)

  2. Which claims are excluded from guarantees, and who can add to the exclusion list? Every exclusion removes a group of claims from protection. (Chapter 6)

  3. Who controls the formulary, and can the manager change it during the year? A change in the middle of the year can move cost and rebates at the same time. (Chapter 7)

  4. How do prior authorization and step therapy work, and who bears the cost of the program? Clinical programs affect both spending and member experience. (Chapter 7)

  5. Does the contract require mail-order or affiliated pharmacies for maintenance drugs? Steering changes where members fill and what the plan pays. (Chapter 8)

  6. Is the network built for access, and what does the contract promise about retail reach? A network can look broad on paper and still leave members far from a pharmacy. (Chapter 8)

Audit, reporting, guarantees and exit (questions 35 to 40)

  1. Who may audit, how often, over what look-back and at whose cost? Audit limits decide whether a problem can be found and recovered. (Chapter 9)

  2. Can the auditor see the pharmacy payments and the manufacturer revenue, or only the plan's bills? The plan side of a claim shows less than the pharmacy side. (Chapter 9)

  3. What reports does the manager owe, in what form and how often, and do they match the federal reports? A report that arrives late or in a locked format limits use. (Chapter 9)

  4. What performance guarantees exist, how much fee is at risk, and who measures them? A guarantee measured only by the manager's own data is hard to test. (Chapter 10)

  5. Can the plan terminate without cause, on what notice, and with what penalty? A contract the plan cannot leave without cost is hard to renegotiate. (Chapter 10)

  6. At the end, must the manager hand over claims history, open refills and prior authorizations, and does the contract reflect the federal rules? A smooth transition and a clean legal footing protect members and the plan. (Chapters 10 and 11)

A contract that answers all forty questions in plain words is rare. Most readers find a handful of questions that the text leaves open. Those are the points to raise with the manager before signature, in writing, so that the answer becomes part of the agreement and not a verbal comfort.