This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read an Other Transaction Agreement by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist
Use these questions on a signed agreement, its attachments and every modification, not on a draft or a summary. Each question ends with the chapter that explains the point. A company can use the list before it signs a Project Award. An investor or a lender can use it in diligence: questions 11, 14 to 17, 21, 31 and 38 to 39 bear most directly on cash and risk. An Agreements Officer can use it to test whether a package is complete. Nothing here is legal, accounting or investment advice, and a "no" or a blank is a reason to read further, not a verdict.
Authority and eligibility
- Which authority does the agreement say it rests on, and does that match a prototype project rather than a research agreement or a construction agreement? (Chapter 1)
- Do you have the signed text, every attachment and every modification, so that you read the negotiated terms and do not assume that procurement-contract clauses apply? (Chapter 1)
- Which eligibility condition does the project rely on: a nontraditional defense contractor or nonprofit research institution participating to a significant extent, participants that are all small or nontraditional, a required cost share, or a written determination by a senior procurement executive? (Chapter 2)
- Who certified nontraditional or small business status, under which size standard, and does the agreement record that the company's contribution is significant? (Chapter 2)
The consortium and its manager
- Who are the parties: does the company sign with the consortium management firm, and does the Government sign only with the consortium? (Chapter 3)
- How was the project competed inside the consortium, and does the file show how many members sent white papers and how many were invited to go further? (Chapter 3)
- What does the Base Agreement require of a member before any Project Award: membership, dues, assessments, and project-level eligibility rules? (Chapters 3 and 4)
- What charges sit on top of the work: a consortium manager fee shown as a separate line, any assessment taken from each payment, any annual fee, and what share of the Government's spend do they add up to? (Chapter 4)
The project award and approvals
- Does the statement of work describe a prototype that fits the definition of a prototype project, with technical objectives that someone can test? (Chapter 5)
- What is the total value, counting options and the consortium manager fee, and which approval path does it fall under: the component's own rules, or the approval levels at $100,000,000 and $500,000,000? (Chapter 5)
- Does the document state the total value and the obligated amount separately, and does each number carry its own label? (Chapters 5 and 6)
- How can scope and value change, who must approve each kind of change, and does the agreement say where a change above an approval level would go? (Chapters 5 and 11)
Milestones and payment
- Is each payable milestone a defined event with a fixed payment, a due month and an acceptance step, and does the agreement name who accepts it? (Chapter 6)
- How much is obligated at award, which milestones does it cover, and what happens when the milestones add up to more than the obligated amount? (Chapter 6)
- Is there a duty to give notice when billings approach the obligated amount, and does the agreement say who sends it and to whom? (Chapter 6)
- How long does cash take to reach the company after a milestone is met, through which invoicing steps and which pass-through steps, and what is deducted on the way? (Chapter 6)
- What does the agreement say about a missed or late milestone, and what would a delay do to the later milestones and to a lender's minimum cash test? (Chapter 6)
Cost share and records
- Does the project need a cost share, and if so, what part of total project cost must come from sources other than the Federal Government? (Chapter 7)
- Which contributions count and at what value, and which are left out, such as earlier research spending, fee given up on another contract, or assets valued above a reasonable usage charge? (Chapter 7)
- Can costs incurred before the effective date count, and is the Agreements Officer's written determination in the file? (Chapter 7)
- Do payments pass $5,000,000, and if so does the agreement carry a Comptroller General access clause, or does it record an exception? (Chapter 7)
- What records must the company keep, for how long, which audits does the agreement allow, and does it ask for accounting changes the company would have to make? (Chapter 7)
Intellectual property and data
- Is each deliverable sorted into a category of data by who paid for its development, and does the sorting match the true development history? (Chapter 8)
- For technology paid for with private money, what does the company keep, and what does it grant as its proposal assertions list? (Chapter 8)
- For work with mixed funding, what rights does the agreement give, whether by a fixed rule or by negotiation, when do government purpose rights start, and is any delay written down with its length and its starting point? (Chapter 8)
- What do the patent terms say about title to inventions, the Government's license, march-in rights and any preference for domestic manufacturing, and what happens to Government-furnished equipment and prototypes at the end? (Chapter 8)
Security and foreign participation
- Which security requirements pass down to the company: facility clearance, classified work specifications, controlled information, cyber assessments? (Chapter 9)
- Which export control markings and rules apply to project data, and are controls in place before work is shared with any new performer? (Chapter 9)
- Does the agreement or the Base Agreement address participation by foreign persons, and does it require notice before access is given? (Chapter 9)
- Are there restrictions on prohibited equipment or on supplier risk that reach the company's own suppliers? (Chapter 9)
Follow-on production
- Does the agreement say that a follow-on production award may come, and is that award provided for in the agreement, to be made separately, or both? (Chapter 10)
- Were competitive procedures used to select the prototype, so that a follow-on without a new competition remains possible? (Chapter 10)
- What are the successful completion criteria, which of them are key, and how many of the others must be met? (Chapter 10)
- Who determines successful completion, in what form, and is the determination in writing? (Chapter 10)
- If production could pass $100,000,000 with every option counted, does the agreement expect a covered official's written determination and notice to the congressional defense committees? (Chapter 10)
Changes, disputes and termination
- How are changes made, who has authority to sign them, and what can a stop-work order do to milestone dates and payments? (Chapter 11)
- What steps does the agreement set for a disagreement, such as escalation or alternative dispute resolution, and does it name a forum? (Chapter 11)
- Who may end the agreement, for what reasons and on what notice, and which term covers a termination for lack of funding? (Chapter 11)
- What is paid on termination: milestones already earned, incurred costs of a milestone in progress, wind-down costs, and is a cap stated and profit on unperformed work excluded? (Chapter 11)
- What close-out steps, final reports, final payments and record retention does the agreement require, and who confirms completion? (Chapter 11)
Using the list
Mark each question as answered by the text, answered only by a side document, or open. An answer that sits in a Base Agreement, a Project Award or a modification should be tied to the exact document and page, so that a second reader can find it. Open questions go to the Agreements Officer, to the consortium management firm or to the company's counsel, depending on whose document is silent. A short list of open items, with an owner for each, is usually a better product of this review than a long list of answered ones.