Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read an NPDES Permit

Free to print: Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist, from How to Read an NPDES Permit.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read an NPDES Permit by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist

Keep this list beside the permit, the fact sheet and the last year of discharge monitoring reports. Each question points to the chapter that explains how to answer it. The questions are about reading, not about legal conclusions: they show a reader where to look and what to write down.

The permit and its record

  1. Is the document in front of you the issued permit, a draft permit, or the fact sheet that explains a draft? Check the cover page and the date of issuance before reading any limit. (Chapter 1)

  2. Which agency issued the permit, and does the cover page show that it acts under a state program approved by EPA or directly under the federal program? In the case, Permit No. ST0048213 comes from a state environmental agency. (Chapter 1)

  3. Is the permit an individual permit written for one facility, or does the facility only hold coverage under a general permit? Look for a notice of intent, an authorization letter or a permit number that belongs to the general permit. (Chapter 1)

  4. Does the fact sheet or statement of basis explain each limit and each special condition, and is the version you hold the one that matches the final permit? Note every place where the permit changed after the draft. (Chapter 1)

Term and renewal

  1. What are the effective date and the expiration date, and what has the facility done about renewal? A reader of the case would look for the date by which Carrowdale must file its renewal application. (Chapter 2)

  2. If the permit has expired, was a timely and complete renewal application filed, and does the state program allow an expired permit to stay in force? Administrative continuance is a program rule, not a promise printed on the cover page. (Chapter 2)

  3. Who signed the application and who signs the reports? In the case, Carrowdale's vice-president of operations signs as the responsible corporate officer, so ask whether the signer still holds that role. (Chapter 2)

Outfalls and receiving water

  1. How many outfalls does the permit list, and what does each one carry: process wastewater, cooling water, stormwater or a mix? Match every outfall in the permit to the site map and to the wastewater flow diagram. (Chapter 3)

  2. Which outfalls are covered by this permit and which are covered by a general permit? In the case, Outfall 001 is under the individual permit, while Outfalls 002 and 003 sit under the state's stormwater general permit. (Chapter 3)

  3. Is there an internal monitoring point before the effluent mixes with other flows, and why did the permit writer place it there? The fact sheet should explain the reason. (Chapter 3)

  4. Which receiving water takes each discharge, which critical low flow was used, and does the permit allow a mixing zone? Ullen Creek and the state's mixing zone rule in the case show how dilution enters a limit. (Chapter 3)

Technology-based limits

  1. Which pollutants carry technology-based limits, and does the fact sheet name the effluent guideline that produced them? Look for the category of industry and the production or flow basis. (Chapter 4)

  2. Where no guideline applies to a pollutant, did the permit writer use best professional judgment, and does the fact sheet show the reasoning? Oil and grease in the case is the example. (Chapter 4)

  3. Was each technology-based limit set at the flow or production basis that the fact sheet describes, and is the basis stated in the permit? A mass limit built on one flow cannot be read against a different flow. (Chapter 4)

Water quality-based limits

  1. For each pollutant with a water quality-based limit, which criterion did the permit writer start from, and what upstream concentration and critical flow went into the calculation? Copper and ammonia in the case show the steps. (Chapter 5)

  2. Did the fact sheet show a reasonable potential analysis, with the number of samples, the highest value, the variability and the projection method? Treat a projection method as a state choice to read, not a universal rule. (Chapter 5)

  3. If the receiving water has a total maximum daily load, does the limit follow the wasteload allocation set for this facility? Compare the allocation with the limit in the table. (Chapter 5)

  4. Does any provision tie compliance to the condition of the receiving water instead of to a stated effluent limit, and has the permit writer explained it? Read the fact sheet with the Supreme Court decision described in Chapter 5 in mind. (Chapter 5)

The limits table

  1. For every pollutant, which form does each limit take: average monthly, maximum daily, or a range such as the one for pH? Write down the form before comparing it to any result. (Chapter 6)

  2. Does the table give both a concentration limit and a mass limit, and do you know which flow the mass limit assumes? Compute the mass from the concentration and the flow to confirm that the table is consistent. (Chapter 6)

  3. Are the units clear for each row (milligrams per liter, micrograms per liter, pounds per day, standard units), and did you convert nothing without checking? A unit slip is the cheapest error to avoid. (Chapter 6)

  4. Which limits are in force now, and which take effect later under a schedule? Mark the effective date of each row so that you never test a result against a limit that is not yet binding. (Chapter 6)

Monitoring and DMRs

  1. For each parameter, what are the sample type and the frequency, and does the pattern fit the limit it supports? A twice-weekly composite and a daily grab sample answer different questions. (Chapter 7)

  2. Which analytical method is required, and is it sensitive enough to measure at the limit? Ask the laboratory for the reporting level of each method on the permit. (Chapter 7)

  3. Do the discharge monitoring reports show every required parameter for every period, with the correct statistic in each box? Look for blanks, estimated values and no-discharge codes. (Chapter 7)

  4. Who files the reports, through which electronic system, and by what day of the following month? In the case, the state's electronic system takes monthly reports, and a late filing is itself a finding. (Chapter 7)

Toxicity, BMPs and schedules

  1. Does the permit require whole effluent toxicity testing, which test species and endpoint does it name, and what result triggers follow-up? Convert the result to chronic toxic units to compare it with the trigger. (Chapter 8)

  2. If a test fails the trigger, what steps follow, and by what dates? Write down accelerated testing and any toxicity reduction plan with the date each one is due. (Chapter 8)

  3. Where the permit uses best management practices or a compliance schedule, are the practices written as enforceable duties, and does every interim date have its own notice requirement? Check that the dates fit the final deadline. (Chapter 8)

Stormwater

  1. Which stormwater outfalls fall under a general permit, and was a notice of intent filed and acknowledged for the facility? Keep the coverage letter with the permit. (Chapter 9)

  2. Does the facility keep a current stormwater pollution prevention plan, and does it match the site as it exists now, including the tank farm and loading yard in the case? Walk the plan against the site. (Chapter 9)

  3. Which benchmarks apply, and how many quarters has the facility been above each one in the same calendar year? Match the count to the corrective action level the general permit assigns. (Chapter 9)

Standard conditions and changes

  1. Which standard conditions does the permit incorporate by reference, and where are they printed? A reader who has never seen the incorporated text has not read the permit. (Chapter 10)

  2. What do the permit and the standard conditions say about bypass and about upset, and does the upset defense even reach the limit that was exceeded? In the case, the ammonia limit is water quality-based. (Chapter 10)

  3. Which events must be reported orally or in writing within a short period, and who inside the company has the duty to make the call? Name a person by role and test whether the plant could meet the deadline at night. (Chapter 10)

  4. Has anything changed that the permit treats as a transfer, a modification or a reason to reopen, such as a sale, new information or a new rule? In the case, a sale to Ardlow Process Partners, LP triggers a transfer notice. (Chapter 10)

Violations, enforcement and transactions

  1. Count the violations in the last year: how many limits were exceeded, by which statistic and on which dates? Separate monthly average violations from maximum daily ones and list what caused each. (Chapter 11)

  2. Do any parameters reach the Category I test in the federal rule, by magnitude or by frequency, and has the agency sent a notice of violation or opened an enforcement action? Read the file, not the summary. (Chapter 11)

  3. Has any citizen group sent a notice of intent to sue, and has the state or EPA started its own court action on the same violations? In the case, the notice date starts a waiting period. (Chapter 11)

  4. If the facility is being bought or financed, have you read twelve months of reports, the compliance schedule, the toxicity results, the inspection and enforcement record, and the renewal deadline? The case follows Ardlow Process Partners, LP and Hensmere Bank, N.A. through exactly this review. (Chapter 12)