This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read the NHS Standard Contract by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
Appendix B: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any NHS Standard Contract
Use these questions in order on any NHS Standard Contract, whether it is a first read before bidding, a review before signature or due diligence on a provider you are thinking of buying. Each question has one line of why it matters and points to the chapter that explains it. The questions are about reading the document and are not advice on what to sign. A good way to work is to copy the list into a spreadsheet, answer each question from the contract with the clause or schedule number beside it, and mark the answers you cannot find. The gaps are usually where the risk sits. Two readers, one from finance and one from contracts or legal, will often answer the same question differently, and the difference is worth discussing before anything is agreed.
Form, parties and term
These first questions fix what kind of document you hold and who stands behind it. Answer them before reading any schedule, and write the answers down, because a wrong answer here changes the meaning of everything after it.
- Is this the full-length contract or the shorter-form contract? The two have different clauses, so every later answer depends on this one (Chapter 1).
- Which annual edition does the contract run on? The national terms are revised each year, and you need to know how a multi-year term deals with later editions (Chapters 1 and 2).
- Who are the parties, and is there a co-ordinating commissioner? One commissioner acts for all the others, so you must know who gives notices and receives yours (Chapters 1 and 2).
- How was the contract awarded, and is the route recorded on the Particulars? The award route affects what can later be changed without a new selection process (Chapters 2 and 11).
- What is the Contract Term, and does Schedule 1C hold an extension option? The option may belong to the commissioner alone, and its notice date is easy to miss (Chapter 2).
- What notice periods apply to the commissioner and to the provider? They set how quickly either side can leave and how much warning the other gets (Chapters 2 and 10).
Particulars and schedules
The Particulars are the part the parties complete, so this is where the real commercial choices sit. Read each schedule against the service you actually deliver or buy.
- Which parts of the Particulars were completed locally and which are national text? Only the locally completed parts are open to negotiation (Chapters 1 and 2).
- Do the conditions precedent in Schedule 1 still need to be met before services start? An unmet condition can delay the start or give a party a reason to act (Chapter 2).
- Does Schedule 2 describe each service clearly, with the service categories that decide which clauses apply? Many Service Conditions apply only to some categories (Chapters 1 and 2).
- Where are other local agreements recorded? An arrangement outside the schedules can still bind you if the contract refers to it (Chapter 2).
- Which documents does Schedule 5A list as relied upon, and are they current? They record what a party relied on in deciding to sign, and the contract prevails over them if they conflict (Chapter 2).
- Does Schedule 7 on pensions apply to your staff? It records the pension duties that follow the people who deliver the service (Chapters 2 and 8).
Payment and invoicing
Payment is where most finance teams spend their time. These questions follow the money from the mechanism to the invoice and on to the reconciliation, and each case figure in Chapters 3 and 4 can be checked against them.
- Which payment mechanism applies to each service? The mechanism decides how risk on activity and cost is shared (Chapter 3).
- For services paid by unit price, which prices apply, and is any local adjustment recorded in the contract? An adjustment that is not written down may not be effective (Chapter 3).
- Is a market forces factor applied, and whose factor is it? The factor changes every unit price it touches (Chapter 3).
- Does any service have a Local Price in Schedule 3C, and how does it change each year? A price with no stated mechanism invites a dispute at each anniversary (Chapter 3).
- Is there an Expected Annual Contract Value, and how is the monthly value invoiced and paid? This sets cash flow and the base for several later calculations (Chapter 4).
- How and when is activity reconciled, and who settles a difference? A reconciliation that is never closed leaves money in doubt (Chapter 4).
- What are the rules on disputed invoices, late payment and set-off? These rules decide who holds the cash while a disagreement is open (Chapter 4).
Activity
Activity is the quantity that drives payment under unit pricing. The three questions below test whether the plan, the monitoring and the remedies fit together.
- Does the Indicative Activity Plan cover each service, and when is it set? An unset plan leaves nothing to measure activity against (Chapter 4).
- What happens when activity runs above or below plan? Check whether an Activity Management Plan route exists and what financial consequences it allows (Chapter 4).
- Who may withhold or reduce payment because of activity, and after what process? A reduction applied without the right steps can be challenged (Chapters 4 and 7).
Quality and information
Quality and data are written into the contract as obligations with consequences. Read these requirements as carefully as the price schedule, and ask the clinical and information teams to confirm that each can be measured, because a missed standard can start a formal process.
- Which National Quality Requirements apply to your services? They are fixed nationally and your performance is judged against them (Chapter 5).
- Which Local Quality Requirements are in Schedule 4, and how is each measured? A requirement with no clear measure cannot be shown to be met or missed (Chapter 5).
- Is the incentive scheme active this year, and what does the schedule for it say? A paused scheme should leave its schedule unused, and you should confirm that it does (Chapter 5).
- What information must be reported, to whom and how often? Reporting duties are easy to underestimate, and a missed report can start a performance process (Chapter 6).
- Is there a data quality standard, and what follows if it is missed? Data quality affects payment, so the consequence of a miss matters (Chapter 6).
Contract management
This group covers how the parties talk, escalate and put things right. A reader who knows these steps can tell early whether a problem is routine or serious.
- How often do review meetings take place, and who attends? Regular meetings are where problems should surface before they become notices (Chapter 7).
- Who may issue a Contract Performance Notice, and what must it say? A notice that is incomplete or sent by the wrong party may not start the process (Chapter 7).
- What follows a notice: a meeting, a Remedial Action Plan or a joint investigation? The next steps decide how much time you have to put things right (Chapter 7).
- What limits and repayment rules apply to money withheld? The caps and the repayment route protect a provider that fixes the problem (Chapter 7).
Safety, staff and insurance
These duties sit beside the commercial terms and do not depend on them. A buyer, a lender and a commissioner will each want to see them confirmed.
- What duties exist on patient safety, incident reporting and dealings with regulators? These duties apply whatever the commercial terms say (Chapter 8).
- Which staff, pension and insurance obligations apply, and does the provider hold the required cover? A gap in cover or in a staff duty can be a ground for action (Chapter 8).
Sub-contracting, variations and change in control
These four questions deal with change: who does the work, how the terms can move, and what happens when ownership moves. They matter most during a sale or a service redesign, when the buyer's deal team and the commissioner will both read them closely.
- Which sub-contracts are Material Sub-Contracts, and is each listed in Schedule 5B? An unlisted material sub-contract is a breach waiting to be found (Chapter 9).
- How are sub-contractors paid, and who answers for their performance? The provider remains responsible to the commissioner for work it passes on (Chapter 9).
- How can the contract be varied, who may propose a change and on what timetable? Variations that are too large may meet the selection rules (Chapters 9 and 11).
- What must happen on a change in control: notification, information and a decision? A buyer's plans for the services should be declared where the contract asks for them (Chapter 9).
Suspension, termination and disputes
The last group asks how the contract behaves when things go wrong. Read it before you need it, because the time limits in these provisions are short. Note each period and each trigger on one page, so that nobody has to search the document under pressure.
- What is a Suspension Event, and what happens to payment during suspension? Suspension can remove income while costs continue (Chapter 10).
- On what grounds may each party end the contract or a service, and what happens to services that must keep running? Termination rights are not symmetrical, and continuity duties can outlast your wish to leave (Chapter 10).
- Which dispute steps come first, who is named to mediate and decide, and how does this link to the selection rules? Knowing the ladder in advance saves time and cost when a disagreement starts (Chapter 11).