Free companion page

Companion page: The Mortgage REIT Investor

Free to print: Reading a Mortgage REIT 10-K: The Checklist, from The Mortgage REIT Investor.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from The Mortgage REIT Investor by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Reading a Mortgage REIT 10-K: The Checklist

The reading pile on the committee table at Ostrey Family Office LLC was not tall, but it was dense: two annual reports on Form 10-K, one from Wendlecote Agency Capital Inc. and one from Sallowford Commercial Lending Trust Inc., two sets of quarterly results, and a list of forty questions to answer before any purchase. The family office had $2,000,000 to allocate. The committee chair had set one rule: no member could argue for either company without having found, in the filings, the answer to every question on the list.

An annual report on Form 10-K is the main yearly filing a listed company makes with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The quarterly report on Form 10-Q updates it, and Form 8-K reports material events between the two. For a mortgage REIT, the 10-K holds nearly everything an investor needs to judge rate risk, funding, credit and fees, but it is long, and the important numbers are spread across several parts. This chapter shows where to look, what the market risk section must contain, how to read financing, credit and fee disclosures, and closes with the committee's forty questions.

Where the numbers live in a 10-K

A 10-K follows a set structure, and knowing it saves hours. The business description comes first: what the company invests in, how it is financed, whether it is internally or externally managed, and how it keeps its REIT status and its exemption under the Investment Company Act of 1940, which Chapter 2 explains. Then come the risk factors, a long list of what could go wrong. They are written broadly to protect the company, but a new risk factor, or one that has moved toward the top of the list, often marks a concern management takes seriously.

The management's discussion and analysis section, often shortened to MD&A, is where management explains the year in its own words. For mREITs, this is where book value per share, economic return, the non-GAAP earnings measure and its reconciliation, the portfolio by type, leverage and liquidity usually appear. Chapter 11 explains how to read the earnings measures.

The market risk section follows, with the company's rate and spread sensitivities. Then the financial statements and their notes. The notes are where the detail lives: the fair value of securities and hedges and how it is measured, the terms of repo and other borrowings, the loan list with risk ratings, the reserve for credit losses and its changes, the related party transactions with an external manager. A reader who goes straight to the notes on financing, credit and related parties will find most of what the committee's questions ask.

The 10-K also lists the documents filed with it as exhibits, including the management agreement for an externally managed company. These are worth opening directly rather than relying on the summary in the main text.

The market risk section and its methods

Regulation S-K Item 305 sets out what a registrant must disclose about market risk. The company gives quantitative information at the end of its fiscal year using one of three methods: a table of fair values and terms of its instruments by expected maturity over five years, a sensitivity analysis, or a value at risk measure at a confidence level of 95 percent or more unless it justifies a lower one. It presents trading instruments separately from other instruments. It explains the limits of the method it chose, changes from the prior year and any change of method. It also describes in words its main market risk exposures and how it manages them. Smaller reporting companies are not required to give this information.

Mortgage REITs commonly present a sensitivity analysis, and it is the most useful part of the 10-K for judging rate risk. It shows how the value of securities and hedges, and the change in equity, would respond to parallel shifts in rates. Wendlecote's table in the case, for example, reads as follows.

Rate shift Total change ($) Change in equity
Minus 100 basis points 115,000,000 11.5 percent
Minus 50 basis points 72,500,000 7.25 percent
Plus 50 basis points minus 102,500,000 minus 10.25 percent
Plus 100 basis points minus 235,000,000 minus 23.5 percent

The detail matters. At plus 100 basis points, the securities lose $460,000,000 and the swaps gain $225,000,000; at minus 100 basis points, the securities gain $340,000,000 and the swaps lose $225,000,000. Book value per share would move to $7.65 and to $11.15 respectively. The table is not symmetrical, because the securities lose more value when rates rise than they gain when rates fall. That pattern is the negative convexity explained in Chapter 5.

A reader should check what the table assumes. Most sensitivity analyses hold spreads constant, so they show rate risk but not spread risk, which Chapter 7 shows can be as large. They assume a parallel move of all rates, an instant shock and no rebalancing of hedges. Many companies also show a separate table for spread changes; where they do not, the investor has only half the picture. The method's limits, which the company must explain, are often where these assumptions are stated.

Financing, counterparties and liquidity

The financing notes and the liquidity section of MD&A answer the question that decides whether an mREIT survives a bad month: can it keep its funding? For an agency mREIT, funding is mostly repo, short-term borrowing secured by securities and rolled every one to three months. For a commercial mREIT, it is a mix of repo facilities, collateralized loan obligations (CLOs), term loans and notes, which Chapter 8 describes.

The investor wants several things from these pages. The amount borrowed under each type of financing, and its remaining term. The haircut on repo, meaning the share of a security's value the lender will not lend against, which sets how much equity each dollar of assets needs. The number of repo counterparties and how concentrated the borrowing is with the largest. Whether facilities are subject to margin calls based on market value, or only on credit events. Covenants, such as limits on leverage or minimum equity, and how close the company is to them.

Liquidity is the other half. Companies usually report unencumbered cash and securities, assets not pledged to any lender, that are available to meet margin calls. For an agency mREIT, the size of that cushion compared with the losses shown in the sensitivity table is the most direct test of resilience. For a commercial mREIT, the question is whether maturing financing can be refinanced and whether lenders can demand more collateral when a loan's value falls.

Credit, reserves and the loan list

For a commercial mREIT, the credit notes are the heart of the 10-K. They usually include a loan list or a summary of the portfolio by property type, region and risk rating, the reserve for credit losses and how it changed during the year, and the loans on nonaccrual, meaning those whose interest the company no longer records as income.

Sallowford's office loan shows what to look for. In the case, a $400,000,000 loan was rated 5, the worst grade on its scale, in June 2026. Its collateral was valued at $300,000,000, with costs to sell of 5 percent. The company set an asset-specific reserve of $115,000,000, or $1.53 per share, and kept a general reserve of 1 percent on the other $4,600,000,000 of loans, or $46,000,000. Book value per share after the specific reserve was $18.47. Once the loan stops paying, the company loses $29,000,000 of interest each year.

Those numbers point to the questions an investor should ask of any commercial mREIT. How is a specific reserve measured, and on what collateral value? When was that value set, and by whom? How large is the general reserve, built under the current expected credit loss (CECL) standard, compared with the loans in the weaker grades? How much interest income comes from loans rated in the two weakest grades? Chapter 9 explains the rating scale and the reserve in full.

Agency mREITs carry little credit risk on their securities, because Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac or Ginnie Mae guarantees principal and interest. Their credit notes matter only if they also own credit risk transfer securities, mortgage servicing rights or non-agency loans; where they do, the same questions apply.

Management, fees and conflicts

Many mortgage REITs, especially commercial ones, are externally managed: they have no employees of their own and pay an outside manager to run them under a management agreement. In the case, Sallowford pays a management fee of 1.5 percent of equity. Common practice is a base fee on equity plus an incentive fee above a hurdle, and the terms differ widely.

The 10-K and the proxy statement describe the agreement, the fees paid during the year, and any other payments to the manager or its affiliates. The investor should read how equity is defined for the fee, since some definitions exclude losses or reserves and so keep the fee base higher than book value. The incentive fee formula decides whether the manager gains from earnings that are not realized. The termination terms often require a large payment if shareholders want to end the agreement, which makes a change of manager costly.

Conflicts are the other subject of this section. A manager that runs several vehicles may allocate loans among them; the 10-K should say how. A manager paid on equity benefits from issuing shares, even below book value. Related party transactions, such as loans bought from or sold to affiliates, must be disclosed in the notes. None of these is wrong in itself. Each is a question to answer before buying.

Forty questions, grouped

The committee's list, written for this book, follows the structure of the filing.

Business and structure

  1. What share of assets is agency securities, commercial loans, or other?
  2. Is the company internally or externally managed?
  3. How does it keep its exemption under the Investment Company Act of 1940?
  4. Which risk factors are new this year, or have moved up the list?
  5. Has the strategy changed in the past three years?
  6. How many shares are outstanding, and how has the number changed?

Earnings, dividend and book value

  1. What is book value per share, and how did it change over the year?
  2. What was the economic return for the year and for the past five years?
  3. Which non-GAAP earnings measure does the company use, and how is it defined?
  4. What are the largest items in the reconciliation to GAAP net income?
  5. How well did that measure cover the dividend in each of the last eight quarters?
  6. Did the company issue shares or buy them back, and at what price relative to book?

Market risk

  1. Which method does the market risk section use?
  2. How would equity change for rate shifts of 50 and 100 basis points in each direction?
  3. Is the sensitivity table symmetrical, and if not, why?
  4. Is spread sensitivity shown, and how large is it?
  5. What does the company say about the limits of its method?
  6. What is the hedge ratio, and which instruments make it up?
  7. How have hedges changed during the year?

Financing and liquidity

  1. What is total leverage, and how did it change?
  2. What share of financing is repo, and what is its remaining term?
  3. What are the haircuts by asset type?
  4. How many counterparties provide financing, and how concentrated is it?
  5. Which facilities allow margin calls on market value?
  6. What covenants apply, and how close is the company to them?
  7. How large are unencumbered cash and securities?
  8. How does that cushion compare with the losses in the sensitivity table?
  9. Which financing matures in the next twelve months?

Credit and reserves

  1. How are loans distributed by risk rating, property type and region?
  2. Which loans are on nonaccrual, and how much interest do they no longer pay?
  3. How large is the reserve, and what share is asset-specific?
  4. On what collateral values are specific reserves based, and how recent are they?
  5. How much income comes from loans in the two weakest grades?
  6. Which loans were modified or extended during the year?
  7. What foreclosed property does the company hold, and at what value?

Management, fees and conflicts

  1. What base and incentive fees were paid, and how is equity defined for them?
  2. What would it cost to terminate the management agreement?
  3. How does the manager allocate investments among the vehicles it runs?
  4. Which transactions with related parties appear in the notes?
  5. How much stock do the directors and the manager own?

Before You Buy the Shares

Key Takeaway: A 10-K holds almost every answer an mREIT investor needs, but the answers sit in the market risk section, the financing and credit notes and the exhibits rather than in the opening pages. In the case, Wendlecote's sensitivity table shows equity falling 23.5 percent at plus 100 basis points, and Sallowford's notes show a $400,000,000 office loan with a reserve of $115,000,000. Forty questions, answered from the filings, turn a reading pile into a judgment.