Free companion page
Free to print: Appendix A: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions, from How to Read a Medicare Cost Report.
This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Medicare Cost Report by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
Keep this checklist beside a filed cost report while you read. Each question is a prompt for the reading, not an instruction for preparing a report, and none of them tells a hospital what to claim. Every question points to the chapter that explains the worksheet behind it. The first time through, work the eight groups in order. Afterward, return to the groups that matter most for the decision you are supporting.
Which cost reporting period does the report cover, and do its start and end dates match the fiscal year of the audited financial statements you are comparing it with, with no gap and no overlap between periods?
Where to look: Chapter 1.
Is the report you hold as originally filed, as accepted after review, as settled in a notice of program reimbursement, or as reopened, and does the file itself tell you which of these it is?
Where to look: Chapter 10.
Which Medicare administrative contractor received the report, and does the CMS certification number on the front match the hospital whose operations you are actually evaluating, not a sister facility or a predecessor?
Where to look: Chapter 2.
Which version of the form and which set of CMS instructions were in force for the period, and have any transmittals been issued since then that would change how a line should be read today?
Where to look: Chapter 1.
Do the certification and the filing date fit the normal cost reporting cycle, or are there signs of late filing, resubmission or an amended report that deserve a direct question to the reimbursement team?
Where to look: Chapter 1.
Do the hospital name, address, type of control and certification details on the identification worksheets agree with the legal entity that is being bought, financed or analyzed, and with the entity named in the audited statements?
Where to look: Chapter 2.
Do the bed counts by unit and the bed days available follow from each other, with no unit counted twice, no unit left out and no change of beds during the period that the totals ignore?
Where to look: Chapter 2.
Do total inpatient days, Medicare days and Medicaid days add up consistently across the units, and does the occupancy rate that results agree with the days and the beds the hospital reported?
Where to look: Chapter 2.
Do discharges and the average length of stay agree with the days, and is the Medicare share of discharges consistent with the Medicare share of days once you allow for stays that run longer or shorter?
Where to look: Chapter 2.
Do the full-time equivalents for employees and for interns and residents fit the size of the hospital and its residency program, and are they counted on the same basis as the payroll behind the trial balance?
Where to look: Chapter 2.
Which cost-to-charge ratio does the uncompensated care worksheet start from, and does it equal the hospital-wide ratio that comes out of the charges and costs on Worksheet C, so that the two worksheets tell one story?
Where to look: Chapter 3.
Are the unreimbursed cost of Medicaid and other indigent programs and the charity care charges supported by records and policies that the hospital could place in front of the contractor's auditor without delay?
Where to look: Chapter 3.
Is charity care separated between uninsured and insured patients, and does the split fit the financial assistance practice that the hospital describes in its own published policy and in its audited notes?
Where to look: Chapter 3.
Are bad debts of patients not covered by Medicare kept apart from Medicare bad debts, and is each kind converted from charges to cost with the right ratio, with the Medicare portion treated on its own terms?
Where to look: Chapter 3.
Does the final line of unreimbursed and uncompensated care tie back to the parts that feed it, and how large is the cost of uncompensated care when set against the net expenses used for cost allocation?
Where to look: Chapter 3.
Does the trial balance of expenses reconcile to the general ledger and to the operating expenses in the audited financial statements, apart from items that the hospital can explain in a sentence and support with a schedule?
Where to look: Chapter 4.
Which reclassifications moved cost from one center to another, and does each one rest on a clear reason, such as salaries or interest that were booked in a center other than the one that incurred them?
Where to look: Chapter 4.
Which adjustments increased or reduced cost between the trial balance and the net expenses used for cost allocation, and are the usual candidates, such as lobbying and other unallowable items, visibly dealt with?
Where to look: Chapter 4.
Does the hospital belong to a system with a home office or other related organizations, and does the home office cost statement support the amount of home office cost that the hospital has taken into its own expenses?
Where to look: Chapter 4.
Where a related organization sold goods or services to the hospital, does the cost the report recognizes equal that organization's own cost, rather than the price it charged the hospital for the same goods or services?
Where to look: Chapter 4.
In what order were the general service cost centers closed in the step-down, and does that order let each closed center allocate only to the centers that come after it, never back to one already closed?
Where to look: Chapter 5.
Is the statistical basis chosen for each general service cost center sensible for the service the center provides, such as space for plant costs or meals served for dietary costs, and is it used in the same way as in prior years?
Where to look: Chapter 5.
After the step-down is complete, does the cost left in the final cost centers add up to the total net expenses for cost allocation, so that nothing has been lost or counted twice along the way?
Where to look: Chapter 5.
Are the charges on Worksheet C gross charges for the same period and the same services as the costs they are divided into, and do they agree with the hospital's own billing records and with the charges on the income statement?
Where to look: Chapter 6.
Does any cost-to-charge ratio look unusually high or low against the others, or against the same center in earlier years, and has the hospital offered an explanation that you can check against its records?
Where to look: Chapter 6.
How were the costs of the routine and ancillary centers divided between Medicare and other patients, and are the Medicare days and charges used for that purpose the same ones reported elsewhere in the report and in the hospital's billing data?
Where to look: Chapter 7.
Which pass-through costs does the hospital apportion on Worksheet D, Parts I to IV, and does the Medicare share of each one tie to the cost centers and statistics behind it?
Where to look: Chapter 7.
Does the Medicare cost of inpatient care, built up from cost-to-charge ratios applied to Medicare charges, hang together with the Medicare share of days and discharges reported on Worksheet S-3?
Where to look: Chapter 7.
Which payment components appear on the settlement worksheet, including outliers, indirect medical education, disproportionate share and uncompensated care payments, and does each component have a statistic or a calculation behind it that you can trace?
Where to look: Chapter 8.
Is the balance due to or from the provider consistent with the interim payments the contractor recorded for the year, and do you know on which worksheet that balance is carried and how it was or will be paid?
Where to look: Chapter 8.
Does the balance sheet in the cost report balance, and does it agree with the audited balance sheet at the same date, apart from presentation differences that the hospital can explain?
Where to look: Chapter 9.
Do patient revenue, allowances and discounts, and net patient revenue in the revenue statement agree with the audited financial statements, or with a reconciliation that the hospital filed together with the report?
Where to look: Chapter 9.
Are total operating expenses in the revenue and expense statement equal to the trial balance, and where they differ from the audited operating expenses, does a reconciliation explain each item, such as interest that the audit reports elsewhere?
Where to look: Chapter 9.
Is net income the same in the cost report and in the audited statements, and does the reconciliation show how the differences in classification net out so that the bottom line is unchanged?
Where to look: Chapter 9.
Does the hospital use the same fund columns on Worksheet G as in the prior year, and do the balances it reports agree with the audited balance sheet and with the prior year's report?
Where to look: Chapter 9.
Has the contractor issued a notice of program reimbursement for the period, and what adjustments separate the report as filed from the report as settled, in amount and in subject?
Where to look: Chapter 10.
Are there reopenings, appeals or group appeals pending or recently resolved for this period or earlier ones, and which amounts do they put in question for the hospital or for the program?
Where to look: Chapter 10.
How do the main ratios and statistics move across several years for this hospital, and does each large movement have an explanation that you can document from the reports and the audited statements?
Where to look: Chapter 11.
How do the hospital's ratios compare with those of other hospitals in the public data, and have you checked that the periods, the definitions and the types of hospital line up before drawing any conclusion?
Where to look: Chapter 11.
Which findings from your reading should change the questions you put to management or to the seller, and which of your open points can be closed from documents alone, without a meeting?
Where to look: Chapter 12.