Free companion page

Companion page: The Medical Outpatient Building Investor

Free to print: Tool 2: Health care lease checklist ; Rent set in advance, at fair market value, without referral formulas, from The Medical Outpatient Building Investor.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from The Medical Outpatient Building Investor by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Tool 2: Health care lease checklist

This table sets the two sets of conditions side by side so you can read one lease against both. It lists conditions only, in plain words. It leaves out section numbers and thresholds on purpose: Chapter 5 explains the office space exception to the Stark Law condition by condition, and Chapter 6 explains the space rental safe harbor to the Anti-Kickback Statute. Take the exact wording and its limits from those chapters and from counsel.

Condition Stark office space exception Space rental safe harbor
Written lease, signed by both parties Check Check
Space described so it can be identified Check Check
Minimum term Check Check
Rent set in advance, not tied to referrals or to the volume or value of business Check Check
Rent consistent with fair market value Check Check
No per-unit or percentage rent that tracks the tenant's business Check Related check, see Chapter 6
Exclusive use by the tenant when the space is used Check Different test, see Chapter 6
Space no larger than the tenant reasonably needs Check Check
Arrangement makes sense commercially, even without referrals Check Related check, see Chapter 6
Holdover on the same terms; renewal signed in writing Check (Chapter 14) Check with counsel

After the table, three open items for every lease: who is a referral source in this building (Chapter 4), whether any physician owns an interest in the building or the landlord entity (Chapter 4) and whether the lease sits in the owner's central list of arrangements (Chapter 14). Remember that falling outside a safe harbor is not the same as being illegal; Chapter 6 explains why, and why the question still deserves counsel's attention.

Rent set in advance, at fair market value, without referral formulas

Three conditions govern the rent itself.

Set in advance means the rent, or a formula that fixes it, is written into the lease before the period it covers. Fixed annual increases meet that idea well because they are known at signing. In the case, the rent increases are fixed in the leases: 2.5 percent a year for the health system's department, 3 percent for the surgery center, 3 percent for the orthopedic group, 2 percent for the dialysis provider and 3 percent for the physical therapy practice. A reviewer would check that the increases in the rent roll match those written in the leases, and that no rent was changed during a term by an informal side letter.

Consistent with fair market value means the rent is what the space would bring in an arm's-length deal between parties that are not in a position to refer business to each other, without any premium for being close to a referral source. Chapter 7 deals with how that value is measured, why the comparison uses effective rent rather than face rent, and how improvements and free rent change the answer. A reviewer would look for a written fair market value opinion, or at least a documented comparison with market leases, dated near the signing of the lease.

No referral formulas is the third condition, and it has two parts. The rent may not take into account the volume or value of referrals or other business between the parties. And it may not be based on a percentage of the tenant's revenue, or on per-unit-of-service charges that reflect services to patients the landlord referred to the tenant. Percentage rents are common in retail real estate; in a medical lease between a referral source and a tenant that bills for designated health services, they are a red flag a reviewer would spot at once. So is rent per scan, per procedure or per patient visit.

Finally, the lease must be commercially reasonable even if no referrals were made. The test is a thought experiment: take referrals out of the picture entirely, and ask whether the deal still makes sense for both parties. A tenant that leases a suite it does not need, because the landlord is a source of patients, fails that test, whatever the rent.

Put together, the rent conditions describe something an investor already knows: a well-documented market lease. In the case, the surgery center pays $34.50 per square foot on 12,000 square feet, $414,000 a year, under a lease that ends in June 2031, and the orthopedic group pays $29.00 on 14,000 square feet, $406,000 a year, under a lease that ends in March 2029. A reviewer would not ask whether those rents are high or low in the abstract. The question would be whether they are supported, in writing, by evidence of market value at signing, and whether nothing in the lease ties them to referrals.