Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Local Authority Statement of Accounts

Free to print: Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist, from How to Read a Local Authority Statement of Accounts.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Local Authority Statement of Accounts by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist

This list follows the order in which a draft statement of accounts is usually read, from the cover to the auditor's report. Each question says where in the statement to look and which chapter explains the point.

The pack and the calendar (questions 1 to 5)

  1. Which documents are in the published pack? Look at the contents page and the council's website, and check that the draft statement, the narrative report and the annual governance statement are all there. Chapter 1 explains.

  2. Who signed the draft, and in which role? Look at the statement of responsibilities near the front. Chapters 1 and 2 cover the signing duty of the responsible financial officer.

  3. Is the period for public rights set out, and can you see when it starts and ends? Look for the public notice on the website and in the front pages. Chapter 1 explains how the period is counted in working days.

  4. Is the audit of this year on course for the backstop date, and what happened to the opinions on the two years before? Look at the auditor's annual report and committee papers. Chapters 1 and 11 explain the backstop dates and the disclaimers.

  5. Do the accounts say which framework they follow, and is there anything the notes call a departure from it? Look at the accounting policies note, usually the first of the notes. Chapter 1 explains proper practices and the Code.

The narrative report and governance statement (questions 6 to 9)

  1. Does the narrative report give the council's financial position in a way that matches the primary statements? Compare each headline in the narrative report with the figure in the statements. Chapter 2 shows how to do this line by line.

  2. Does the narrative report say what went wrong as well as what went right? Look for overspends, reserves used above plan and risks named for next year. Chapter 2 explains the balance.

  3. What significant governance issues does the annual governance statement list, and is each one tied to an action? Look for a named owner for each. Chapter 2 explains.

  4. What opinion does the head of internal audit give, and do the issues in the governance statement match the matters in the narrative report and the notes? Chapters 2 and 11 explain.

The CIES and the EFA (questions 10 to 14)

  1. Is the Comprehensive Income and Expenditure Statement laid out by service, and do the service lines add to the cost of services? Look at the first primary statement. Chapter 3 explains each block of the statement.

  2. What is the deficit or surplus on the provision of services, and how does it differ from the movement in the General Fund? Look at the bottom of the CIES, then at the Movement in Reserves Statement. Chapters 3 and 4 explain the gap.

  3. Does the Expenditure and Funding Analysis start from the funding-basis figure for each service and end at the net cost in the CIES? Look at the note that sits beside the CIES. Chapter 3 shows the three columns and how they connect.

  4. What are the largest service adjustments in the Expenditure and Funding Analysis, and what do they consist of? Look for depreciation, revaluation and impairment losses, pension costs and any adjustment for the schools grant. Chapters 3 and 5 explain each adjustment.

  5. Do other operating costs, financing costs and tax income sit below the cost of services as they should? Look at the lower half of the CIES. Chapter 3 explains.

Reserves (questions 15 to 20)

  1. Does the Movement in Reserves Statement open at the figures the previous statement closed at? Look at the opening balances in each column. Chapter 4 explains why a mismatch matters.

  2. Which reserves are usable and which are unusable, and does the statement keep the two groups apart? Look at the column headings of the Movement in Reserves Statement. Chapter 4 explains the difference in plain words.

  3. How large is the General Fund balance compared with the weekly net revenue budget? Divide the balance by one week of net budget. Chapter 4 shows this test.

  4. How much of the earmarked reserves is ring-fenced or already committed, and how much could be used freely? Look at the earmarked reserves note and its purposes. Chapter 4 explains why the two figures differ.

  5. Which usable reserves moved in the year, and is every movement explained by a receipt, a use or a transfer you can see in the note? Look at the capital receipts reserve, the major repairs reserve and capital grants unapplied. Chapter 4 explains.

  6. What do the unusable reserves hold, and which of them are negative? Look at the unusable reserves note. Chapters 4, 5 and 8 explain these balances.

The adjustments and overrides (questions 21 to 24)

  1. Does the note on adjustments between accounting basis and funding basis separate the General Fund from the Housing Revenue Account? Look at the note after the Movement in Reserves Statement. Chapter 5 shows the layout.

  2. Which adjustments remove a cost that law does not let the council charge to council tax payers, and which add back a charge that law requires? Look for depreciation, minimum revenue provision and capital items. Chapter 5 sorts them into groups.

  3. Which statutory overrides does the council use, and where does each one appear? Look for pooled investment funds and for the schools grant deficit. Chapter 5 explains the overrides.

  4. Does the cumulative schools grant deficit appear in the accounts, and where is it held? Look at the unusable reserves note and the narrative report. Chapters 4, 5 and 11 explain why the deficit is a warning sign.

The balance sheet and cash flow (questions 25 to 27)

  1. How do the main asset groups on the balance sheet break down, and which ones are revalued by a rolling programme? Look at the property, plant and equipment note. Chapter 6 explains each class of asset.

  2. Does the net worth on the balance sheet equal the total of the usable and unusable reserves? Add the two totals and compare with the net assets line. Chapter 6 shows this tie-out.

  3. Does the cash flow statement explain the movement in cash and short-term investments, and is the operating section consistent with the CIES? Look at the three sections of the statement. Chapter 6 explains how to read them.

Borrowing, the CFR and MRP (questions 28 to 32)

  1. What is the capital financing requirement, and how did it move in the year? Look at the capital financing note and its reconciliation. Chapter 7 explains the opening balance, new borrowing and repayment through provision.

  2. How does external debt compare with the capital financing requirement, and what is the difference called? Look at the borrowing note and the treasury management paragraphs. Chapter 7 explains internal borrowing and the cash that supports it.

  3. Which lenders hold the debt, and does the note show any loan with an option that lets the lender change terms? Look at the analysis of borrowing by type. Chapter 7 explains the main debt types.

  4. How was minimum revenue provision calculated, and what changed from the previous policy? Look at the minimum revenue provision statement and the note. Chapter 7 explains the methods and the guidance.

  5. Are there assets or loans on which the council makes no provision, and is the reason given? Look at the policy statement and the investment property and loans notes. Chapters 7 and 10 explain the questions to ask.

Pensions (questions 33 to 34)

  1. What are the obligations, the assets and the net liability in the pensions note, and how did the net liability move in the year? Look at the reconciliation in the note. Chapter 8 explains each line.

  2. Which assumptions did the actuary use, and how sensitive is the obligation to a change in the discount rate? Look at the assumptions and sensitivity tables. Chapter 8 explains why the discount rate matters so much.

The HRA and the Collection Fund (questions 35 to 36)

  1. Does the Housing Revenue Account stay within its own ring-fence, and what does its balance do in the year? Look at the income and expenditure statement of the account and the statement of its movement. Chapter 9 explains the ring-fence.

  2. Does the Collection Fund separate council tax from business rates, and what share goes to the preceptors? Look at the Collection Fund statement and its notes. Chapter 9 explains the shares and the adjustment account.

Companies and the group (questions 37 to 38)

  1. Does the council own any company, and does it prepare group accounts? Look for a group section after the single-entity statements, or for a note that explains why none is prepared. Chapter 10 explains when the group view matters.

  2. What loans, interest and guarantees pass between the council and its company, and what happens to them when the accounts are consolidated? Look at the related parties note and the group notes. Chapter 10 explains the eliminations.

The auditor and the warning signs (questions 39 to 40)

  1. What does the auditor's report say about the opinion, and if there is a disclaimer, what is the reason given? Look at the opinion paragraphs and the basis for the opinion. Chapter 11 explains each kind of opinion.

  2. Which of the warning signs for a council in financial difficulty can you find in the statement: repeated use of reserves, a growing grant deficit, a thin General Fund, a large gap between debt and cash, a loss-making company? Chapters 11 and 12 show how the signs add up in one worked case.

How to use the list

Work through the list in order the first time, because each group builds on the one before. On later readings, start with the questions about the largest numbers. Write a short answer and a page reference beside each question, and mark any you cannot answer as an item to raise with the finance team, the external auditor or the audit and governance committee. The list is a reading aid, not advice and not a test of any council.