This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Loan Guaranty by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Loan Guaranty
These forty questions are the last thing to read before signing a guaranty or underwriting one. They follow the order of a typical document, from the parties to the release, and each one points back to the chapter that explains it. A sponsor's general counsel can use them to find exposure before the signature page. A lender's counsel or credit officer can use them to find gaps before the loan funds.
The questions do not tell anyone what to accept. They make sure nothing is accepted by accident. Each one comes with one sentence on why it matters, and the examples use the case: Aldermoor Office Holdings LLC as borrower, Aldermoor Partners Fund II LP as guarantor, the Halvern Building as the property, a CMBS conduit lender and, when trouble comes, the special servicer.
A practical way to use the list is to answer each question in a short written note, with the section number of the document where the answer sits. A question that cannot be answered from the guaranty alone is itself a finding: it usually means the answer sits in the loan agreement, the environmental indemnity or a side letter, and that document has to be read too. Where the answer is "the document is silent," record that as well, because silence is often where disputes start.
The list is also useful twice. Read it once at the term sheet stage, when most points can still be traded, and again on the final draft, when the reader is checking that the agreed points made it into the text.
Parties and scope (questions 1 to 8)
The first eight questions fix who promises what, to whom, for which loan. Chapters 1 and 2 cover this ground.
- Who exactly is the guarantor, and is it the entity that actually holds the sponsor's assets? A guaranty from a shell adds a signature but no credit (Chapter 2).
- Are there several guarantors, and is their liability joint and several? If so, the lender can collect the whole amount from any one of them (Chapter 2).
- Which loan, which documents and which amendments does the guaranty cover? A guaranty that covers future amendments without limit can grow beyond the deal its guarantor priced (Chapter 7).
- Is the guaranty one of payment or one of collection? A guaranty of payment lets the lender sue the guarantor without first pursuing the borrower (Chapter 7).
- Which other guaranties sit beside this one: payment, carry, interest, completion, environmental? Each is a separate exposure on the same balance sheet (Chapters 5 and 6).
- Does the guaranty incorporate definitions from the loan agreement by reference? If so, the reader has to read those definitions too, because the guaranty inherits every word (Chapter 8).
- Who counts as an affiliate or control person whose acts can trigger the guaranty? A broad definition can make the guarantor answer for acts it did not control (Chapter 10).
- Which law governs, and where can the guarantor be sued? The governing law shapes which defenses exist and how waivers are read (Chapter 7).
Loss carve-outs (9 to 16)
Loss carve-outs make the guarantor answer for the loss an event caused. In the case, the borrower's handling of cash in a difficult year is what turned the guaranty from a backstop into a claim. Chapter 3 covers this ground.
- What events are on the loss list, and is the list closed or open-ended? An open list with a catch-all can stretch to events no one discussed (Chapter 3).
- How is misapplication of rents, fees and deposits defined? This is the carve-out most likely to be triggered in a downturn, as the case shows (Chapters 3 and 11).
- Does the misapplication carve-out cover lease termination fees and security deposits expressly? These large, one-off sums are the ones a borrower under pressure is most tempted to use elsewhere (Chapters 3 and 11).
- Is waste defined, and does it include failing to pay operating costs when the property lacks income? A broad waste definition can make a market decline look like a carve-out event (Chapter 3).
- Does the unpaid tax carve-out apply only when the property produced enough cash to pay? Without that condition, the guarantor answers for taxes the building could never cover (Chapter 3).
- How is "loss" measured: actual loss, the amount misapplied, or something wider such as costs and fees? The measure decides the size of the claim (Chapter 3).
- Is any loss carve-out limited to knowing or intentional acts? A knowledge qualifier protects the guarantor against acts of third parties but rarely against the borrower's own decisions (Chapter 10).
- What is the scope of the environmental indemnity, and is it a separate document? It often survives every release, so its wording deserves its own reading (Chapters 3 and 9).
Full recourse triggers (17 to 24)
Full recourse triggers turn the whole loan into a recourse debt. They are the cliff the guarantor must stay away from. Chapter 4 covers this ground, and Chapter 8 shows how a trigger can reach further than expected.
- What events make the whole debt recourse, and is each one a deliberate act? A trigger that can fire without anyone choosing it is the most dangerous kind (Chapter 4).
- Does a voluntary or collusive bankruptcy filing trigger full recourse, and how is collusion defined? This is the core of the lender's protection and the term lenders least often concede (Chapter 4).
- Which transfers of the property or of ownership interests are prohibited, and which are permitted? A permitted transfer list that is too narrow can turn an ordinary investor change into a full recourse event (Chapter 4).
- Does an unpermitted lien or new debt trigger full recourse, and is there a right to bond or remove it? Without a cure, a contractor's lien can become a cliff (Chapter 4).
- Which single-purpose-entity covenants trigger full recourse, and does any of them include solvency? Chapter 8 shows how a solvency requirement can turn a market failure into full recourse.
- Do the documents say that insolvency or lack of cash flow from the property is not by itself a breach? That sentence closes the side door Chapter 8 describes.
- Are separateness breaches split between full recourse and loss, with materiality and cure language? Lesser breaches usually belong with the loss carve-outs (Chapters 4 and 10).
- What does full recourse include: principal only, or also interest, default interest, costs and fees? The difference can be large over months of unpaid interest (Chapters 4 and 11).
Guarantor covenants and reporting (25 to 30)
Guarantor covenants make sure the guarantor stays worth suing. In the case, the fund passed one test and failed the other in the same year. Chapters 2 and 10 cover this ground.
- What net worth and liquidity levels must the guarantor keep? These levels decide how much room the guarantor has when markets fall (Chapter 2).
- How is liquidity defined, and do capital commitments or credit lines count? The definition can decide whether a guarantor passes or fails a test (Chapter 10).
- How is net worth measured, at book or fair value, and which assets count? A guarantor can look strong on one basis and weak on another (Chapter 2).
- How often are the covenants tested, and on what date? An annual test can miss a dip or catch a temporary one (Chapter 10).
- What does a failed test trigger, and is there a cure right? The consequence may be a loan default, a demand for a replacement guarantor or more credit support (Chapter 10).
- What financial reports must the guarantor deliver, how often, and certified by whom? Reporting duties are easy to miss and can themselves be covenants (Chapter 2).
Waivers and enforcement (31 to 35)
The waiver page decides whether the guaranty can be enforced without a fight. Chapter 7 covers this ground.
- Which suretyship defenses are waived, and are they itemized as well as covered by a catch-all? Specific waivers leave less room for argument than general ones (Chapter 7).
- Can amendments that raise the principal, the rate or the carve-outs bind the guarantor without its signature? A guarantor should know which changes can raise its exposure silently (Chapter 7).
- Are one-action, anti-deficiency and fair value defenses waived, and to what extent does the governing law allow it? These state rules can change the size of a deficiency claim (Chapter 7).
- Are subrogation and reimbursement rights waived outright or only deferred until the loan is paid in full? Deferral keeps a route back to the borrower once the lender is whole (Chapter 7).
- Are jury trial, set-off and counterclaim waived, and is intercompany debt subordinated? Each is a separate right that deserves its own look (Chapter 7).
Workout, release and survival (36 to 40)
The last five questions look ahead to the end of the loan, whether it ends well or badly. Chapter 9 covers this ground, and Chapter 11 shows the case's own release.
- Can the guarantor be replaced, and on what criteria? A clean replacement path matters for a fund with a limited life (Chapter 10).
- Is the guarantor released automatically on a permitted sale and assumption of the loan? Without automatic release, the old guarantor may stay exposed for the life of the loan (Chapter 10).
- Can the guaranty be assigned separately from the loan? A guaranty that travels without the loan lets a stranger pursue the guarantor (Chapter 9).
- In a deed in lieu or other workout, what does the release cover: known and unknown claims, before and after the transfer? A release of known claims alone leaves the guarantor exposed to what the lender discovers later (Chapter 9).
- Which obligations survive any release, and for how long? The environmental indemnity is the usual survivor, and its scope decides how much of the release is real (Chapters 9 and 11).
Taken together, the last group decides how the guarantor leaves the deal. A sponsor that has negotiated hard on carve-outs and covenants can still give much of that back in a narrow release or an open-ended survival clause. The environmental indemnity is the usual survivor, which is why questions 16 and 40 point to the same document from two directions.
On the reading desk
- Answer all forty questions in writing, citing the section of the guaranty or loan agreement for each answer.
- Mark every answer that refers to another document and confirm that document has also been read.
- Rank the full recourse triggers by how easily each could be set off without a deliberate act.
- Test the liquidity and net worth definitions against the guarantor's actual figures at its weakest point in recent years.
- List every obligation that would survive a release and read each one again.
Key Takeaway: Forty questions in six groups cover a guaranty from the parties to the release: 8 on parties and scope, 8 on loss carve-outs, 8 on full recourse triggers, 6 on guarantor covenants, 5 on waivers and 5 on workout and survival. The case shows where the answers matter most: misapplied cash creates loss claims, full recourse triggers set the cliff, and the liquidity definition decides whether a guarantor passes its tests in a bad year. Read them last, after the document, so nothing is accepted by accident.