Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read an Investment Management Agreement

Free to print: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Management Agreement, from How to Read an Investment Management Agreement.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read an Investment Management Agreement by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Management Agreement

These forty questions are the last thing to read before signing or renewing a management agreement. They are not a substitute for the chapters, and they are not legal advice. They are the questions that a board of trustees, an investment committee or a new associate on the manager's side can put to any draft, in order, with a pen in hand.

Each question is one line, followed by one sentence on why it matters. The chapter numbers point to where the clause is read in full. The case of Pelham Retirement Trust and Larkspur Capital runs through the book as an illustration; the questions apply to any separately managed account agreement between an institutional client and an SEC-registered investment adviser.

A reader who cannot answer a question from the document has found something worth raising. A reader who can answer it, but does not like the answer, has found something worth negotiating.

Parties, authority and scope (questions 1 to 7)

  1. Who exactly are the parties, and does the client entity that signs own the assets? An agreement signed by the wrong entity can leave the real owner without rights, as Chapter 2 explains.

  2. Who at the client has authority to sign, amend and give instructions, and is that authority evidenced? The manager needs to know whose instructions it may act on, and the client needs to know no one else can bind it.

  3. Is the manager's authority discretionary or non-discretionary, and is that stated in words? Discretion decides who makes each investment decision, and every later clause depends on it (Chapter 2).

  4. Which account, and which assets, does the authority cover? A clear definition of the account stops the manager's authority from reaching assets the client did not hand over.

  5. What may the manager do beyond buying and selling: vote, sign documents, open trading accounts, enter derivatives? Each additional power is a source of risk the client should accept deliberately.

  6. What may the manager never do, whatever the guidelines say? A short list of outright prohibitions is easier to monitor than a long list of conditions.

  7. Does the manager represent that it is registered with the SEC and will remain so, and what happens if it is not? Registration status underpins the regulatory protections the client relies on (Chapter 2).

Guidelines and breaches (8 to 13)

  1. Are the investment guidelines attached as a schedule, and can they be amended only in writing? Guidelines that live outside the agreement, or change by email, are hard to enforce (Chapter 3).

  2. Is each guideline testable: a number, a measurement point and a universe? A limit that cannot be measured cannot be breached, and so protects no one.

  3. Is each limit measured at purchase or at all times, and does the agreement say which? The difference decides whether market movements alone can create a breach.

  4. How soon must a breach be reported, from what moment, to whom and with what content? A reporting deadline is only useful if it starts at a defined event and the report carries the facts needed to act.

  5. Who pays for curing a breach, and how is the loss measured? A clause that names the manager and the method avoids an argument at the worst moment (Chapters 3 and 6).

  6. May the manager hold a position that breaches the guidelines while it waits for a better price, and on whose instruction? A cure period without limits can turn a small breach into a larger loss.

Fees and valuation (14 to 21)

  1. Is the fee asset-based, performance-based or a mix, and is every rate and breakpoint written out? A fee schedule should allow anyone with the inputs to recompute the invoice (Chapter 4).

  2. On what base is the fee charged: average assets, period-end assets or something else, and how is the base computed? The base can change the fee as much as the rate does.

  3. Whose valuation is the billing base, and what happens when a holding is halted or hard to price? The party that earns the fee should not set the value the fee is charged on (Chapter 4).

  4. How often is the fee computed, billed and paid, and in advance or in arrears? Timing affects how much is owed at termination and how a refund works.

  5. If there is a performance fee, is the client eligible for one, and is that confirmed in the agreement? Performance fees are permitted only for certain clients, as Chapter 5 explains.

  6. How is outperformance measured: against which benchmark, on which value, over which period? Each choice moves money between client and manager, and none should be left to interpretation.

  7. Is there a high-water mark, a hurdle or a cap, and how does each work across years? A carry-forward of underperformance and a cap on the total fee are the main protections against paying twice for the same result (Chapter 5).

  8. Is there a most-favored-nation clause, and what does it cover and exclude? A promise of the best fee terms is worth only as much as its definition of comparable accounts (Chapter 4).

Liability and indemnity (22 to 27)

  1. What standard of care does the manager accept: negligence, gross negligence or something else? The standard decides who bears losses from ordinary mistakes (Chapter 6).

  2. Does the agreement deal expressly with trade errors, and at whose cost are they corrected? An express trade error clause removes the need to argue about the standard for the most common mistake.

  3. Does any hedge clause or limitation of liability purport to waive rights the client cannot waive? Language that appears to remove the client's protections should be read with counsel (Chapter 6).

  4. Does the client indemnify the manager, and for what? An indemnity from the client can quietly shift back losses the liability clause seemed to leave with the manager.

  5. Are consequential and indirect losses excluded, and how are those terms defined? A broad exclusion can swallow the main types of loss a client would claim.

  6. Does the manager carry insurance, and must it tell the client of a material change? Insurance does not change liability, but it affects whether a claim can be paid.

Custody, brokerage, voting and reporting (28 to 33)

  1. Does the client appoint and pay its own custodian, and may the manager only instruct settlement against payment? A manager that can steer the assets but not move them out is the basic institutional protection (Chapter 7).

  2. Does the agreement state the duty of best execution and require a periodic report on brokers and commissions? Best execution is hard to monitor without a report behind it.

  3. Does the agreement allow, limit or prohibit using client commissions to pay for research? The statutory safe harbor applies unless the contract expressly provides otherwise, so silence is a choice (Chapter 7).

  4. Are cross trades, principal trades and trades through affiliated brokers prohibited or allowed only under conditions? Each puts the manager on both sides of a price.

  5. Who votes the shares, and may the client override the manager or give its own voting guidelines? Voting is delegated by default in many mandates, and the client should decide that deliberately (Chapter 8).

  6. Which reports must the manager deliver, how often, and does the fee report show every input? Reporting is how a board sees a mandate it does not run (Chapter 8).

Assignment, termination and transition (34 to 40)

  1. Does the agreement contain the manager's promise not to assign it without the client's consent, and must consent be written? The law requires the promise in substance; the drafting decides whether silence can count as consent (Chapter 9).

  2. How does the agreement define assignment, and does it cover a sale of a controlling block of the manager's voting shares? A change of control at the manager can be an assignment even when the manager's name does not change.

  3. Is there a key person clause, who is named, what triggers it, and what may the client then do? A right to terminate at once on a key person event ties the mandate to the people the client hired (Chapter 9).

  4. On what notice may each party terminate, with and without cause, and is termination without penalty? The notice period sets how quickly the client can act and how long the manager keeps managing (Chapter 10).

  5. How are fees settled at termination: base fee prorated, performance fee measured or forgone, prepaid fees refunded? A short final period is where fee drafting is tested hardest.

  6. What must the manager do after notice: keep trading, follow the client's instructions, cooperate with a transition manager and the new manager? A clear transition duty limits the cost and risk of moving the account (Chapter 10).

  7. Which clauses survive termination: liability, indemnity, confidentiality, records and accrued fees? Without a survival clause, the promise the client most needs may lapse with the mandate.

The worked case of Pelham Retirement Trust and Larkspur Capital in Chapter 11 shows several of these questions tested by real events in the life of a mandate, from the guidelines to the fees, the liability clauses, the consent to a change of control and the final transition. Reading it next to this list shows which answers held up.

On the reading desk

Key Takeaway: Forty questions, in six groups, cover the whole management agreement: parties and authority (1 to 7), guidelines (8 to 13), fees and valuation (14 to 21), liability (22 to 27), custody, brokerage, voting and reporting (28 to 33), and assignment, termination and transition (34 to 40). Each can be answered from the document or it cannot. A question the agreement does not answer is the one to raise before signing or renewing.