Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read an Investment Banking Engagement Letter

Free to print: The forty-question checklist, from How to Read an Investment Banking Engagement Letter.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read an Investment Banking Engagement Letter by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

The forty-question checklist

The questions below follow the order of this book. Each can be answered from the engagement letter, its annexes or the relationship letter. A question without a clear answer is itself a finding.

Scope and role

  1. Which transactions does the letter cover, and which does it leave out?
  2. Is the bank exclusive, and for what kind of transaction?
  3. Does the letter say the bank is an independent contractor with contractual duties only?
  4. Who at the company instructs the bank: the board, a committee or management?
  5. Is the lead banker named, and is there a key person clause?
  6. Is a fairness opinion part of the mandate, or a separate letter?
  7. Does the bank have any claim on future mandates, and is it binding?
  8. Who may rely on the bank's advice, and is reliance limited to the board?

Fee and value

  1. What is the retainer, and is it credited against the success fee?
  2. What is the success fee grid, slice by slice?
  3. Is there a minimum fee, and at what transaction value does it stop applying?
  4. How is transaction value defined: equity or enterprise value?
  5. Is assumed debt included, and on what measure?
  6. Is escrow counted at closing or when released?
  7. Is the earn-out counted at its maximum, at an estimate, or when paid?
  8. How is non-cash consideration valued?

Term and tail

  1. How long is the term, and what happens when it ends?
  2. On how many days' notice can each side terminate?
  3. How long is the tail?
  4. Does the tail cover any buyer, or only parties the bank contacted or introduced?
  5. Does the bank have to list the parties it contacted when the letter ends?
  6. Is any buyer excluded, and at what reduced fee?
  7. Does termination for cause, or for a key person leaving, cut the tail?
  8. Does the tail apply to a deal signed during the tail but closed after it?

Expenses, indemnity, conflicts

  1. Is there a cap on expenses, and whose prior written consent lifts it?
  2. Are legal fees of the bank's counsel included in expenses or separate?
  3. Who is indemnified: the bank only, or also its officers, directors, employees and affiliates?
  4. What are the carve-outs, and do they need a final judgment?
  5. Are defense costs advanced, and on what undertaking to repay?
  6. Who controls the defense and who must consent to a settlement?
  7. Is the bank's contribution capped, and on fees received or payable?
  8. Has the bank given a relationship letter, and must it update it?

Fairness opinion and special mandates

  1. Is the fairness opinion fee payable on delivery or on closing?
  2. Is it payable whatever the conclusion?
  3. Is it credited against the success fee?
  4. Which disclosures will the opinion make about contingent pay and relationships?
  5. If a fairness committee is used, will people outside the deal team review and approve it?
  6. Will any affiliate offer financing to bidders, and does it need the board's consent?
  7. If the bank is conflicted, what would a second opinion cost, and on what terms?
  8. In a restructuring, what triggers the completion fee, and does the letter provide for court approval?

Key Takeaway: In the case, Strathmore's success fee was $3,250,000 at closing on a transaction value of $225,000,000, of which $2,450,000 was paid in cash after $800,000 of credits, plus $540,000 in Year 3 on the $18,000,000 earn-out: $3,790,000 in all, against $4,150,000 at closing under Strathmore's draft. The definition of transaction value did most of the work, while the indemnity still cost Pennant a $900,000 advance in Year 2. The forty questions turn the case into a reading routine for any engagement letter.