This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read an Insurance Agency Agreement by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Agency Agreement
The forty questions in this chapter are the last pass before an agency agreement is signed, renewed or bought. They do not replace the chapters; they compress them. Each question takes one line, followed by one sentence on why it matters, and each group points back to the chapter that explains it.
The list is written for three readers at once. An agency principal uses it before signing or renewing. A carrier's agency manager uses it to see the agreement as the agency will. A buyer's deal team uses it across every carrier agreement in the stack, because one weak answer in one agreement can move the price. None of the questions has a right answer in the abstract, and none is a substitute for counsel under the governing law.
Calderbrook Insurance Group, LLC and Northmere Mutual Insurance Company appear only where the case shows why a question is worth asking.
Parties, licenses and the document stack (questions 1 to 6)
Chapter 1 explains the appointment, the licenses and the documents that sit around the agreement.
- Who exactly are the parties, and is the agency the licensed business entity that will place the business? A contract signed by an affiliate or an owner personally can leave the operating agency outside its own agreement.
- Does the agreement depend on the agency and its people holding current licenses and appointments? Many agreements end automatically on a license loss, so the licensing calendar becomes a contract calendar.
- Which documents are incorporated: commission schedule, profit-sharing addendum, manuals, bulletins, underwriting guidelines? The agreement is only as clear as the weakest document it brings in by reference.
- Can the carrier change incorporated documents by notice, and how much notice does it give? A schedule that can change on short notice is a different economic bargain from one fixed for a year.
- If the documents conflict, which one prevails? Without an order of priority, a manual bulletin can quietly rewrite a negotiated term.
- Which state's law governs, and which territories does the appointment cover? Insurance is regulated state by state, and the answer decides which rules sit on top of the contract.
Authority and underwriting (7 to 11)
Chapter 2 covers binding authority and the limits the carrier places on it.
- For which lines, limits and classes may the agency bind cover, and where is that written? Authority that lives only in a manual can shrink without an amendment to the agreement.
- What must the agency do after binding, and by when? Late reporting of a bound risk is a common source of disputes over who bears a loss.
- What is the agency forbidden to promise, such as coverage, rates or claim outcomes? The line between selling and committing the carrier is where most authority problems begin.
- Can the carrier suspend or narrow authority without terminating the agreement? A referral requirement can take away part of the agency's business while the agreement stays in force.
- Who decides whether a risk meets underwriting guidelines, and how are disagreements handled? A clear process protects the agency from being blamed for decisions the carrier reserved to itself.
Commissions and chargebacks (12 to 17)
Chapter 3 reads the commission schedule and the return of commission on cancelled business.
- What are the base commission rates by line, for new business and for renewals? In the case, commercial new business pays 16 percent and commercial renewals 14 percent, and the blend decides the agency's income.
- On what premium is commission calculated, and what is excluded? Fees, taxes and certain endorsements are often outside commissionable premium, the premium on which commission is paid.
- When is commission paid, and is it paid on written, billed or collected premium? Timing turns a commission rate into cash flow, and the basis decides who bears uncollected premium.
- How is commission returned when premium is refunded, and over what period? A chargeback, the commission returned on refunded premium, can reach back into months the agency thought were closed.
- May the carrier offset amounts it claims against commissions it owes? Offset rights let the carrier collect disputed sums without asking first.
- Does the agreement say anything about commissions owed to producers who leave the agency? Producer splits usually live in the agency's own producer agreements, and the carrier agreement may not help the agency at all.
Contingent and other compensation (18 to 21)
Chapter 4 explains contingent commissions and profit-sharing addenda.
- On what earned premium, loss ratio and growth measures is the contingent commission calculated? Every definition in the grid moves the payment, sometimes more than the losses themselves.
- Can the carrier change or withdraw the profit-sharing addendum during the year? A grid that can change mid-year is a promise that may not survive the year it rewards.
- Is a contingent commission paid, pro rated or forfeited in the year the agreement ends? The answer can remove a full year of contingent income at exactly the moment the agency loses a carrier.
- Will the carrier provide the terms and interim data the agency needs to describe its compensation to customers? Chapter 9 shows that some regimes ask for a description or estimate of compensation not yet known.
Premiums and trust money (22 to 26)
Chapter 5 covers agency bill, direct bill and the premium trust account.
- Which business is direct bill, billed by the carrier, and which is agency bill, billed and collected by the agency? The split decides how much fiduciary money the agency holds and for how long.
- When is net premium due on agency billed business, and is it due whether or not collected? A collected-or-not clause makes the agency the carrier's credit risk on every slow-paying customer.
- What must the premium trust account look like, and what may the agency do with it? Premium the agency holds is fiduciary money, and the agreement often adds rules beyond the law.
- How is the account current, the periodic statement of premium and commission between the parties, prepared and disputed? A clear dispute process keeps a disagreement over one item from turning into a default.
- What counts as a default on the premium account, and what follows from it? Chapter 6 shows that a default can decide who owns the expirations.
Expirations and records (27 to 31)
Chapter 6 covers expirations, and Chapter 8 covers records and data.
- Who owns the expirations, the customer records and the right to solicit renewals, during and after the agreement? This clause is often the most valuable sentence in the document for an agency or its buyer.
- Does ownership depend on the account being paid, and how is a dispute over the amount handled? A condition tied to payment turns accounting discipline into ownership of the book.
- May the carrier use or share the agency's customer data during or after the relationship? Records the carrier may use are not the same as records it owns, and the difference matters at termination.
- How long must records be kept, and who may audit them? Retention periods and audit rights differ widely, and a multi-carrier agency lives with the longest of them.
- What errors and omissions cover, data security program and incident notice does the agreement require? These clauses are cheap to satisfy in advance and expensive to breach later.
Termination and survival (32 to 36)
Chapter 7 reads termination, rehabilitation and run-off.
- On how much notice may each side terminate without cause? In the case, Northmere's 90 days of notice set the clock for everything that followed.
- What are the causes for immediate termination, and is there a cure period? A list that ends in a catch-all turns specific causes into examples.
- Does the agreement provide for suspension or a rehabilitation plan, with what targets and what end? A middle step can protect both sides, or simply delay a termination already decided.
- After termination, who services in-force policies, and must the carrier renew them on request? In the case, renewals at schedule rates for 12 months gave the agency time to move its customers.
- Which duties survive termination, and do the matching rights survive with them? Indemnities and audit duties that outlive the agreement should not outlive the agency's right to be paid.
Sale, assignment and regulation (37 to 40)
Chapters 9 and 10 cover the regulator's lines and agency M&A.
- Does a sale of the agency end the agreement, require consent, require notice, or none of these? The answer for each carrier decides how much of the agency's revenue a buyer can count on.
- Does the change of control clause reach a sale of equity as well as a sale of assets, and is there a right of first refusal? A deal can trigger a clause it was meant to avoid, or open a window for someone else to match the price.
- What does the agreement say about rebating, fees and compensation disclosure? State rules differ, and the agreement can make them easier or harder to follow.
- How would the agency's earnings and price change if this carrier left on notice tomorrow? Every clause above feeds that one number, which is the one a buyer will calculate first.
The groups are not equal in weight. For an agency that depends heavily on one carrier, questions 26 to 28 and 32 to 35 decide most of the value at risk, because they govern what is left after a termination. For a buyer, questions 37, 38 and 40 sit alongside them. For a carrier, questions 7 to 11 and 22 to 26 are where losses and fiduciary risk start.
The case shows how the groups connect. When Northmere terminated without cause, the notice period (question 32) set the clock, the renewal obligation (question 35) carried the policies, and the paid account kept the expirations with the agency (questions 26 to 28). No single answer told the story; the combination did.
On the reading desk
- Answer every question in writing for each carrier agreement, with the clause number beside each answer, and mark any question the agreement does not answer.
- Sort the unanswered and unfavorable answers by the share of revenue each carrier pays, so the largest exposure gets read first.
- Take the marked questions to counsel and to the other party as questions, not as conclusions about what the clause means or whether it holds.
Key Takeaway: Forty questions cover the whole agreement, from parties and authority to commissions, trust money, expirations, termination and sale. In the case, a 90 day without cause notice and 12 months of renewals at schedule rates showed why questions 26 to 28 and 32 to 35 decide most of the value at risk. The list is a reading tool, not advice, and every unclear answer is a question for counsel or for the negotiating table.