Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Hotel Management Agreement

Free to print: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Hotel Management Agreement, from How to Read a Hotel Management Agreement.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Hotel Management Agreement by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Hotel Management Agreement

Before an owner signs a management agreement, before a buyer bids on a managed hotel, and before a lender commits to a loan secured by one, someone has to read the whole document with a single list in hand. This chapter is that list: forty questions, the last thing to read before the pen comes out.

The questions follow the order of the book. Each one names what to find, then says in one sentence why it matters, with the chapter that explains it. They work whether the reader sits on the owner's side, the operator's side or across the table as buyer or lender. In the case, Harborview Hotel Partners, Larkspan Hospitality, the mortgage lender and a private equity buyer would each have read the same agreement through this list, and each would have stopped at different questions.

The list does not replace counsel. It tells the reader where to look and what to ask; what a clause means under the governing law is a question for counsel.

Parties, term and authority (questions 1 to 7)

The first seven questions establish who is bound, for how long, and with what power. Get them wrong and every later number rests on sand.

  1. Who are the parties, and is the operator the brand itself or a third-party manager under a separate franchise? This decides who answers for brand standards and who answers for operations (Chapter 1).
  2. Does the agreement say the operator acts as the owner's agent, and for which acts? The scope of agency decides what the operator can commit the owner to without asking (Chapter 1).
  3. Who employs the hotel staff, and who bears their cost and liabilities? Staff are the largest operating cost, and employment claims follow the employer (Chapter 1).
  4. How long is the initial term, and how many renewals are there? The term sets how long the owner lives with the operator before any exit (Chapter 2).
  5. Who holds each renewal option, and on what conditions? A renewal at the operator's sole option extends the owner's commitment without the owner's vote (Chapter 2).
  6. What decisions need owner approval, and which can the operator take alone? The approval list is the real division of power (Chapter 4).
  7. What spending limits, contract limits and affiliate limits apply to the operator's authority? Limits on authority protect the owner's cash between budgets (Chapters 4 and 6).

Fees and the owner's priority (8 to 15)

Fees are where the agreement turns into cash. These questions follow each fee from its base to its payment date.

  1. What is the base fee, and on what measure of revenue? A small change in the definition of total revenue moves the fee every year (Chapter 3).
  2. Which revenues are excluded from that measure? Exclusions such as insurance proceeds, sales taxes or sale proceeds lower the base fee legitimately (Chapter 3).
  3. How is the incentive fee calculated, and on what measure of profit or cash flow? The incentive fee is only an incentive if it rewards results the operator can influence (Chapter 3).
  4. Is there an owner's priority, and how is it measured? A priority set on invested capital decides when the operator starts sharing in upside (Chapter 3).
  5. Does the priority include later capital spending, and does it carry forward unpaid amounts? A priority that grows with new capital and carries forward shortfalls protects the owner across bad years (Chapter 3).
  6. Is the incentive fee calculated annually, cumulatively or with a true-up at year end? The timing decides whether the operator is paid on interim results that later reverse (Chapter 3).
  7. When are fees paid, and who controls the bank account they are paid from? An operator that pays itself from hotel accounts holds the owner's cash first (Chapters 1 and 3).
  8. Can any fee be deferred or subordinated, and does deferral carry interest? Subordination shifts the risk of a weak year from owner to operator (Chapter 9).

Budgets, reserves and capital (16 to 22)

Budgets fix the year's plan, reserves fund its wear and tear, and capital spending keeps the hotel to brand standard. All three are owner money.

  1. Who prepares the operating budget, by when, and what form must it take? A late or thin budget leaves the owner approving numbers it cannot test (Chapter 4).
  2. What happens if the owner does not approve the budget? The default rule decides what the hotel runs on during a dispute (Chapter 4).
  3. Can the operator depart from the approved budget, and by how much? Variance limits keep the approved budget meaningful (Chapter 4).
  4. What is the FF&E reserve, how is it funded, and does the percentage step up over time? Each point of reserve moves cash away from the owner and the incentive fee (Chapter 5).
  5. Who controls the reserve account, and what can it be spent on? A reserve the operator can spend freely is a capital budget without owner approval (Chapter 5).
  6. Who decides on capital spending beyond the reserve, and must the owner fund it? An open-ended funding duty is the largest hidden cost in an agreement (Chapter 5).
  7. What happens if the owner refuses to fund required spending? Refusal can give the operator termination rights or remove its liability for brand standards (Chapter 5).

Brand, system fees and affiliates (23 to 28)

Brand charges are often larger than the base fee, and they sit inside operating expenses where readers overlook them.

  1. Which brand standards bind the hotel, and can the brand change them? A change in standards can create capital spending the owner never budgeted (Chapter 6).
  2. What system fees and chain services charges apply, and on what base? These charges are billed whether or not the hotel earns a profit (Chapter 6).
  3. Are those charges capped, or can the operator raise them across its system? An uncapped charge is a fee the operator can increase without amending the agreement (Chapter 6).
  4. How are loyalty program costs and reimbursements handled? Loyalty economics can move cash between the hotel and the brand in either direction (Chapter 6).
  5. Can the operator buy goods or services from its affiliates for the hotel, and on what terms? Affiliate purchases are a quiet second channel of fees (Chapter 6).
  6. Does the operator commit to area protection, and what does it cover? An area restriction protects the hotel from the same brand opening next door (Chapter 6).

Performance, termination and sale (29 to 35)

These questions decide whether the owner has an exit, and what it costs.

  1. Is there a performance test, and does the operator fail only if every limb fails? A test with several limbs that must all fail is much harder to trigger (Chapter 7).
  2. When does the test start, and which years or events are excluded? Exclusions and a late start can leave few measurable years in the term (Chapter 7).
  3. Who chooses the competitive set, and how can it change? The RevPAR index means nothing without a fair comparison set (Chapter 7).
  4. Can the operator cure a failure, how often, and by paying what? A cheap cure turns a termination right into a bargaining chip (Chapter 7).
  5. What are the owner's and the operator's termination rights for default, insolvency and licenses? These rights decide how a breakdown ends, and on what notice (Chapter 7).
  6. Can the owner terminate on a sale, and does a sale of an interest count? Without this right the buyer inherits the operator, and the price reflects it (Chapter 8).
  7. What termination fee applies on sale or other termination, and on what years is it measured? A fee measured on a weak year costs less than one measured on a strong year (Chapter 8 and Chapter 11).

Financing, inducements and disputes (36 to 40)

The last five questions look beyond the hotel to its lenders, the operator's inducements and the routes for settling disputes.

  1. Must the operator subordinate its agreement and sign a non-disturbance agreement, and on what conditions? Lenders read this clause first and price the loan by it (Chapter 8).
  2. Can the owner and the operator each transfer their interest, and what counts as a change of control? Transfer limits decide who can buy the hotel and who can end up running it (Chapter 8).
  3. Did the operator pay key money or give a guarantee, and how is it repaid on early termination? Repayment is part of the cost of every exit (Chapter 9).
  4. Who insures what, who indemnifies whom, and what happens after a casualty or condemnation? A loss tests insurance, indemnity and termination clauses all at once (Chapter 10).
  5. Which disputes go to an expert, which to arbitration or court, and are damages limited? The route decides how fast and how fully a disagreement is settled (Chapter 10).

On the reading desk

Key Takeaway: Forty questions, in seven, eight, seven, six, seven and five, cover parties and term, fees, budgets and reserves, brand charges, performance and termination, and financing and disputes. In the case, Harborview Hotel Partners, Larkspan Hospitality, the mortgage lender and a private equity buyer would each have answered them differently from the same document. Read the list before the pen comes out, and send the open points to counsel.