Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Ground Lease

Free to print: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Ground Lease, from How to Read a Ground Lease.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Ground Lease by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Ground Lease

Forty questions are the last thing to read before signing, lending on or buying either side of a ground lease. They do not replace reading the document. They are what a careful reader asks after the reading, to make sure nothing that matters has been missed: the term, the rent and its reset, the tenant's freedom to build and transfer, the leasehold lender's protections, the fee side, and the end of the lease.

Each question below is one line, followed by one sentence on why it matters and the chapter where the point is explained. The questions are written to work from any seat. A landowner like Calder Trust, a tenant like Marlowe Street Partners, a leasehold lender like the life insurance company in the case, or a fee lender like the regional bank will weigh the answers differently, but all of them need the answers. None of this is legal, investment or appraisal advice; it is a reading discipline.

Parties, term and reversion (questions 1 to 7)

  1. Who exactly are the landowner and the tenant, and does the lease bind their successors?
    Why: a ground lease outlives the people who sign it, so the obligations must run with the land and the leasehold (Chapter 1).

  2. What land is leased, and is the legal description consistent with the title and the survey?
    Why: the leased premises define both the tenant's collateral and the landowner's reversion (Chapter 1).

  3. When does the term start, and when exactly does it end?
    Why: every financing and valuation test counts years from a precise expiry date (Chapter 2).

  4. Are there extension options, and who controls each one?
    Why: options the landowner controls usually do not count for a leasehold lender's term test (Chapters 2 and 7).

  5. Can the lease end before its stated expiry, and on what events?
    Why: every early termination right is a threat to the tenant's investment and the lender's collateral (Chapters 2 and 8).

  6. What happens to the improvements at expiry: do they revert, with or without payment?
    Why: the reversion is the landowner's long-term prize and the reason the leasehold is a wasting asset (Chapters 2 and 11).

  7. What condition must the improvements be in when they revert, and is there a removal or demolition obligation?
    Why: the end-of-term condition decides what the landowner actually receives and what the tenant must spend in the last years (Chapter 2).

Rent and the reset (8 to 15)

  1. What is the starting ground rent, and how was it set?
    Why: the opening rent fixes the landowner's return and the tenant's base cost for the first period (Chapter 3).

  2. How does rent change before any reset: fixed steps, an index, or a percentage of income?
    Why: each method shifts inflation and performance risk differently between landowner and tenant (Chapter 3).

  3. Is there a reset from land value, and in which years?
    Why: a reset can move the rent by a large amount at a single date, which lenders and buyers must underwrite (Chapter 4).

  4. On what premise is the land valued at the reset: vacant and unencumbered, or encumbered by the lease?
    Why: the valuation premise is often the largest single driver of the reset rent (Chapter 4).

  5. What rate is applied to the land value, and is it fixed in the lease or left to the appraisers?
    Why: a rate left open adds a second variable to an already contested number (Chapter 5).

  6. Is there a floor and a cap on the reset rent, and how are they measured?
    Why: the floor protects the landowner, the cap protects the tenant and gives the lender a worst case to underwrite (Chapter 5).

  7. How are disputes over the reset resolved: appraisers, baseball arbitration or another method?
    Why: the procedure shapes the numbers each side puts forward and how far apart they end up (Chapter 5).

  8. Does the lease say what counts as rent, including additional rent, and when it is due?
    Why: a missed payment of anything called rent can be a default that threatens the lease (Chapters 7 and 8).

Construction, use and transfer (16 to 21)

  1. What must the tenant build, by when, and with what landowner approval?
    Why: construction obligations and deadlines can become early default risks before the building produces income (Chapter 6).

  2. Does the landowner contribute anything to construction?
    Why: in most ground leases the tenant carries the full construction cost and risk, and the lease should say so (Chapter 6).

  3. Who owns the improvements during the term?
    Why: ownership decides who insures, maintains, mortgages and restores the building (Chapter 6).

  4. What uses are permitted, and can the use clause block a future change of use?
    Why: a narrow use clause can cut the leasehold's value decades later when the market moves (Chapter 6).

  5. Can the tenant assign the lease or sublease without the landowner's consent?
    Why: free transfer is central to the leasehold's value and to the lender's exit on foreclosure (Chapters 6 and 8).

  6. Is the tenant released from its obligations after a permitted assignment?
    Why: a tenant that stays liable after selling carries a risk it no longer controls (Chapter 6).

The leasehold lender (22 to 29)

  1. May the tenant mortgage the leasehold without the landowner's consent?
    Why: a leasehold that cannot be mortgaged freely is hard to finance and hard to sell (Chapter 7).

  2. How many years will be left on the lease when a new loan would mature?
    Why: leasehold lenders apply a remaining term test, and that test narrows the tenant's borrowing as the lease runs down (Chapter 7).

  3. Is the ground lease subordinated or unsubordinated, and if subordinated, to which loans and for how long?
    Why: subordination changes the lender's collateral, the size of the loan and the landowner's risk (Chapter 7).

  4. Must every default notice go to the leasehold lender as well as the tenant?
    Why: a lender cannot cure a default it never hears about (Chapter 8).

  5. How long is the lender's cure period for monetary and non-monetary defaults, and what happens to defaults it cannot cure?
    Why: cure rights are what turn a tenant default into an event the lender can manage (Chapter 8).

  6. If the lease ends early for any reason, including rejection in the tenant's bankruptcy, must the landowner grant the lender a new lease on the same terms and with the same priority?
    Why: the new lease clause keeps the collateral alive when everything else has failed (Chapter 8).

  7. Does the lease say that the fee and the leasehold do not merge, and that the lease cannot be changed or cancelled without the lender's consent?
    Why: merger or a quiet amendment could destroy or shrink the lender's collateral (Chapter 8).

  8. Can the lender foreclose, take a deed in lieu, and transfer the leasehold without the landowner's consent, and must the landowner give estoppels on request?
    Why: the lender's exit depends on transfer without consent and on statements it can rely on (Chapter 8).

The fee side (30 to 34)

  1. Is there any existing mortgage on the fee, and does it rank behind the ground lease?
    Why: a fee mortgage ahead of the lease could, on foreclosure, threaten the lease itself (Chapter 9).

  2. Does the lease prohibit future fee mortgages unless they are expressly junior to the lease, the leasehold lender and any new lease?
    Why: the ranking must hold for the whole term, not only on the day the lease is signed (Chapter 9).

  3. Must any fee lender sign a recognition and non-disturbance agreement in favor of the tenant and its lenders?
    Why: a signed agreement removes doubt about priority and binds a foreclosing fee lender to the lease (Chapter 9).

  4. In the landowner's bankruptcy, can the tenant choose to stay for the rest of the term, and can it make that choice without the lender's consent?
    Why: the tenant's right to remain protects the building, and the lender wants a say in the choice (Chapter 9).

  5. Who may buy the fee, and is a buyer bound by every landowner obligation to the tenant and its lenders?
    Why: a fee sale changes the landowner, and the protections must survive the change (Chapter 9).

Casualty, condemnation and the end of the lease (35 to 40)

  1. After a casualty, must the tenant restore, and is that duty the same in every year of the term?
    Why: restoration late in the term may make no economic sense, and the lease should say what happens then (Chapter 10).

  2. Can either party end the lease after a casualty while a leasehold loan is outstanding?
    Why: a termination right after a fire is a direct threat to the lender's collateral (Chapter 10).

  3. Who holds insurance proceeds, and when, if ever, does the landowner receive any of them?
    Why: proceeds held by the lender or a trustee keep the money tied to restoration or repayment (Chapter 10).

  4. Does the lease contain a condemnation allocation formula, and on what basis is the land taken valued?
    Why: valuing the land taken as unimproved but subject to the lease, rather than as vacant, changes who gets most of the award (Chapter 10).

  5. Does rent fall after a partial taking, by what measure, and does the change need the lender's consent?
    Why: a silent lease invites a dispute, and a rent change agreed without the lender can hurt its position (Chapter 10).

  6. What must happen in the last years of the term: maintenance standards, financing limits, surrender and handover?
    Why: the leasehold's value falls fastest near expiry, and the end-of-term clauses decide what the landowner gets back (Chapters 2 and 11).

On the reading desk

Key Takeaway: Forty questions cover what only a ground lease has: the long term and the reversion, the rent and its reset, the financing of the leasehold and its lender's protections, the fee side and its ranking, and the end of the lease. Every party in the case, Calder Trust, Marlowe Street Partners, the leasehold lender and the fee lender, needs the same answers. A question the lease leaves unanswered is a risk someone carries.