This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Form W-8BEN-E by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
Appendix B: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Form W-8BEN-E
Use these questions in order on any Form W-8BEN-E, whether you receive the form or sign it. Each question is followed by one sentence on what a good answer looks like and the chapter that explains it. The list is a reading aid for a documentation file, not advice on what to enter, check or sign.
The payee and the form
- Who is the payee, and is the name on the form the legal entity that actually receives the payment? A good answer matches the name on the form to the account and payment records without a gap (Chapter 1).
- Is Form W-8BEN-E the right certificate for this payee, or does the payee belong on another form? A good answer names the reason the entity fits this form and none of the others (Chapter 9).
- Is the signer the beneficial owner of the income, or an intermediary passing it along? A good answer says who is treated as owning the income for US tax purposes, and the answer is consistent across the form (Chapter 1).
- Is the form on the revision the book reads, the October 2021 revision? A good answer shows a form on the revision in force when the file was opened, with every part complete (Chapter 1).
- Does the form cover the payments the account will actually receive? A good answer links the form to the kind of income, dividends or interest, that the custodian will pay (Chapter 1).
Part I and Part II
- Do the name and the country of organization on the form agree with each other and with the account file? A good answer finds the same entity and the same country everywhere in the file (Chapter 2).
- Is the permanent residence address an address in the country the form claims? A good answer shows a residence address that matches the country of organization or explains the difference in plain words (Chapter 2).
- Does the mailing address differ from the residence address, and if so, is there a reason on file? A good answer records the reason and any supporting document (Chapter 8).
- Are the tax identifying numbers present, or is their absence explained? A good answer shows a foreign tax number where one is expected, or a stated reason for none (Chapter 2).
- If a disregarded entity or branch is involved, does Part II name it and its status? A good answer identifies the legal entity that is the payee and the entity that receives the payment, and the two readings agree (Chapter 2).
Chapter 3 status
- Is the status on line 4 consistent with how the entity is treated under US tax principles? A good answer ties the box checked to the legal form and to the facts in the file (Chapter 3).
- Is the hybrid entity question answered, and does the answer fit the rest of the page? A good answer shows that the entity's treatment in the United States and in its home country has been thought through (Chapter 3).
- If the entity is a partnership or a trust, does the income belong to the entity or to its owners? A good answer explains who derives the income and whether a different form is needed (Chapter 3).
- Does the chapter 3 status match what the form later claims about treaty benefits? A good answer finds one status running through line 4 and Part III without a conflict (Chapter 6).
Chapter 4 status of financial institutions
- What chapter 4 status does line 5 give the entity, and is it a financial institution? A good answer states the status in a few words and points to the part of the form that supports it (Chapter 4).
- If a Model 1 or Model 2 box is checked, does the rest of the form fit it? A good answer relies on what the form says, without a guess about which countries have agreements (Chapter 4).
- Is a GIIN written down, and was it checked on the IRS FFI list? A good answer shows the number, the name that matches it and a note that it was found on the list (Chapter 4).
- If the GIIN is written as applied for, is a diary set for the 90 days? A good answer shows the deadline date on the file and a named person who follows it up (Chapter 2).
- Was the correct part of the form completed for the status claimed? A good answer shows the part for that status filled in and the other status parts left alone (Chapter 4).
NFFEs and their owners
- If the entity is not a financial institution, is it claimed as active or passive? A good answer says which and finds the matching part of the form completed (Chapter 5).
- For an active NFFE, do the income and asset facts support the label? A good answer notes the year the test looks back to and any fact the bank holds about the business that would contradict the box checked in Part XXV (Chapter 5).
- For a passive NFFE, are substantial US owners listed, and does the list reach every holder of more than 10 percent? A good answer finds each owner's name, address and TIN in Part XXIX, checks the holding in the file against the more than 10 percent threshold, or finds box 40b checked if there are none (Chapter 5).
- Does the ownership shown fit what the file already knows about the entity? A good answer finds the owners on the form, the account documents and any structure chart in agreement (Chapter 5).
Treaty claims
- Is the treaty country the same as the country of residence on the form? A good answer shows one country in both places, with the permanent residence address behind it (Chapter 6).
- Which limitation on benefits box is checked, and do the owner and activity facts in the file support it? A good answer links the box to specific facts about ownership or business, not to the label (Chapter 6).
- Does the explanation of the special rate and conditions fit the payment? A good answer makes the explanation specific to the kind of income and the stake held (Chapter 6).
- Does the rate claimed match the IRS treaty table for this country and this kind of income? A good answer reads the rate from the table and treats every condition behind it as a point to document (Chapter 6).
- Is the entity itself the one that derives the income for treaty purposes? A good answer says why the entity, rather than its owners, can claim the rate (Chapter 3).
- Is a foreign tax identifying number given when the claim needs one, or is its absence explained? A good answer shows the number, or shows that the country does not issue one (Chapter 2).
Signature, validity and changes
- Is the form signed and dated by a person who can sign for the entity? A good answer shows the signer's role and a date that falls where it should (Chapter 7).
- Is the form inside its validity period under the three-year rule? A good answer states the date of signature and the last day of the period the form covers (Chapter 7).
- Has anything changed since the signature, and did the payee report it and furnish a new form within 30 days, as the rules require? A good answer records the change, or states that none was known, with the date of the check (Chapter 7).
- Is the expiry date in a diary that someone owns? A good answer shows a diary entry, a named owner and a reminder before the end of the period (Chapter 12).
Reason to know and the wrong form
- Does any address in the file point outside the country the form claims? A good answer finds the address and either explains it or obtains a document that settles it (Chapter 8).
- Do the other documents in the account file agree with the form? A good answer notes each document that was checked and the result (Chapter 8).
- Is documentary evidence needed, and is it in the file? A good answer lists the document, its date and what fact it supports (Chapter 8).
- Should the payee have given a Form W-8IMY with a withholding statement and owner forms instead? A good answer says why the form received is or is not the one the facts call for (Chapter 9).
Reporting and failures
- Will the codes and rate on the Form 1042-S follow from the certificate in the file? A good answer traces each code and rate back to a line on the form (Chapter 10).
- If the form was invalid when a payment was made, was the presumption applied, and was 30 percent withheld where it should have been? A good answer shows what was withheld and why, payment by payment (Chapter 11).
- If a late certificate arrives with an affidavit, what does the file need before anyone relies on it? A good answer lists the dates, the evidence and the open questions, and says plainly what the case leaves undecided (Chapter 11).