This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Form 990 by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Form 990
A reader rarely gets as much time with a return as they would like. Sometimes there are two minutes before a board meeting; sometimes there are two hours before a grant memo is due. The forty questions in this chapter work for both. In two minutes, a reader can run down the questions and stop at the first one that raises an eyebrow. In two hours, a reader can answer every one and turn the answers into a short list of things to ask the filer.
The questions follow the order in which a return is usually read: the envelope first, then the mission, governance, pay, revenue, expenses, the balance sheet, and finally related parties and status. Each question is followed by one short sentence that says where to look and what Brambleton's Year 5 return shows, using the filled extracts written for this book. The rules behind each question live in the chapter named beside it; this chapter only points to them.
A reader should treat every answer as a prompt, not a verdict. A question that turns up something unusual is a reason to ask, and the filer often has a good explanation.
Before opening the return: which form, which year, which copy
Before reading a single figure, a reader confirms that the document in hand is the right one. A good analysis of the wrong year or an incomplete copy is wasted work.
- Is this the full Form 990, or a shorter or different return (Chapter 1)? Look at the form number on the first page: Brambleton files the full Form 990.
- Which tax year does the return cover, and how old are its figures (Chapter 1)? Look at the heading: the case reads Brambleton's Year 5 return in Year 6.
- Is the copy complete, with every schedule that Part IV calls for (Chapter 3)? Check the Part IV answers against the schedules attached: Brambleton's carries Schedules A, J, L and O, among others.
- Is the filer a public charity or a private foundation (Chapters 1 and 10)? Look at Schedule A: Brambleton reports as a public charity.
- Did the governing body see the final return before it was filed (Chapter 4)? Look at Part VI line 11a and Schedule O: Brambleton answers yes, and the finance committee reviewed a draft.
Mission and programs
Next, a reader asks what the organization exists to do and whether the money follows that purpose.
- Does the stated mission describe the work the return reports (Chapter 2)? Look at Part I line 1: Brambleton's mission is literacy for children and families in Larkhaven.
- How large is the organization in people as well as dollars (Chapter 2)? Look at Part I: Brambleton reports 212 employees and 640 volunteers.
- How much of revenue do programs earn, compared with what donors give (Chapters 2 and 6)? Compare Part I lines 9 and 8: Brambleton shows $2,660,000 of program service revenue against $10,780,000 of contributions and grants.
- Does the organization pass money on as grants to others (Chapter 2)? Look at Part I line 13: Brambleton reports $420,000 of grants.
- Do the program expenses in Part III agree with the program column of Part IX (Chapters 2 and 7)? Tie Part III to Part IX column (B): Brambleton's program column gives a reported program ratio of 77.54 percent.
Governance and policies
Governance questions tell a reader who is watching the organization and how.
- How many voting members does the governing body have, and how many are independent (Chapter 4)? Look at Part VI and Part I: Brambleton reports 15 voting members, 12 of them independent.
- Who is not independent, and why (Chapters 4 and 9)? Read Part VI with Schedule L: the three are the executive director, the director whose family owns Thornquist Print Works and the director who received a loan.
- Does the organization have a written conflict of interest policy that is disclosed annually and monitored (Chapter 4)? Look at Part VI: Brambleton answers yes to all three.
- Does it have whistleblower and document retention policies (Chapter 4)? Look at Part VI: Brambleton has a whistleblower policy but answers no on document retention and destruction.
- Are minutes kept of board and committee meetings (Chapter 4)? Look at Part VI: Brambleton answers yes.
- How can the public obtain the governing documents, the conflict policy and the financial statements (Chapter 4)? Look at Part VI and Schedule O: at Brambleton they are available only on request.
Pay
Pay questions read Part VII and Schedule J together, and always ask about the process as well as the amount.
- Who is the highest paid person, and what is the total (Chapter 5)? Look at Part VII: Brambleton's executive director has $412,000 of reportable and $58,000 of other compensation, $470,000 in total.
- What makes up the other compensation (Chapter 5)? Look at Part VII and Schedule J: $41,000 of employer retirement contributions and $17,000 of nontaxable health benefits.
- Who else is listed as a key employee or highly compensated employee (Chapter 5)? Look at Part VII: the chief financial officer at $228,000, the director of programs at $171,000, and two others at $118,000 and $104,000.
- Was pay set by a documented process, and does the same process cover every officer (Chapters 4, 5 and 9)? Look at Part VI and Schedule J: yes for the executive director, no for the other officers and key employees.
- Are there any special pay features, and are directors paid (Chapter 5)? Look at Schedule J and Part VII: no first-class travel, no severance or change-of-control payment, no revenue-contingent pay, and directors are unpaid.
Revenue
Revenue questions ask where the money comes from and how steady it is likely to be.
- How much total revenue came in, and what is the largest source (Chapter 6)? Look at Part I line 12 and line 8: $13,840,000 in total, of which $10,780,000 is contributions and grants.
- How dependent is the organization on government money (Chapter 6)? Read Part VIII: in the case, government grants and school district contracts are 45.2 percent of total revenue.
- What do investments and other sources add (Chapter 6)? Look at Part I lines 10 and 11: $185,000 of investment income and $215,000 of other revenue.
- Do noncash gifts lift both revenue and expenses (Chapters 6 and 7)? Read Part VIII with Part IX: Brambleton reports $210,000 of donated books in both.
- Does the organization run any unrelated business, and is it taxable (Chapter 6)? Look at Part I: $190,000 of unrelated business revenue and $40,000 of net unrelated business taxable income.
Expenses
Expense questions test the functional split before any ratio is quoted.
- What were total expenses, and how much does the return show for programs (Chapter 7)? Look at Part I line 18 and Part IX: $12,980,000 in total and a reported program ratio of 77.54 percent.
- Is there a joint cost on line 26, and how was it split (Chapter 7)? Look at Part IX line 26: a $600,000 mailing, $360,000 to program and $240,000 to fundraising, with the box checked.
- What does the program ratio look like without the joint cost program share and without donated goods (Chapter 7)? Recompute from Part IX: 74.77 percent and 77.17 percent.
- What does it cost to raise a private dollar (Chapter 7)? Divide line 16b by contributions other than government grants: $1,162,100 over $6,880,000 gives 0.17 dollars.
- Who are the largest independent contractors, and do they match the expense lines (Chapters 5 and 7)? Look at Part VII Section B: the direct mail fundraising firm at $260,000, matching line 16a, and Thornquist Print Works at $186,000.
Balance sheet and endowment
Balance sheet questions turn net assets into time and separate what is free from what is restricted.
- How large are assets, liabilities and net assets, and how heavy is the debt (Chapter 8)? Look at Part I lines 20 to 22: $16,983,000, $2,930,000 and $14,053,000, with liabilities at 17.3 percent of assets.
- How many months of cash does the organization hold (Chapter 8)? Read Part X with Part IX: $3,200,000 of cash and savings against $1,046,667 of monthly cash expenses gives 3.06 months.
- How much of the unrestricted net assets is board designated or tied up in buildings (Chapter 8)? Read Part X with Schedule D: of $6,153,000, $1,200,000 is quasi-endowment and $2,700,000 is buildings and equipment net of the mortgage.
- How many months do liquid unrestricted net assets cover (Chapter 8)? Compute from Part X: $2,253,000, or 2.15 months.
Related parties and status
The last questions cover insiders and the organization's standing as a public charity.
- Does Schedule L report any business transaction with an insider (Chapter 9)? Look at Schedule L Part IV: $186,000 paid to Thornquist Print Works, LLC, owned by a director's family, with no competitive bid.
- Has the organization tested that price against the market since (Chapter 9)? Ask the filer: in Year 6, Brambleton's audit committee found the lowest comparable bid at $171,000, a gap of $15,000 that the return itself does not judge.
- Does Schedule L report any loan to an insider (Chapter 9)? Look at Schedule L Part II with Part VI: Brambleton reports a loan to one director, which is one reason that director is not counted as independent.
- Which public charity test applies, and what percentage does it show (Chapter 10)? Look at Schedule A Part II: public support of $40,284,200 over total support of $47,605,000, or 84.62 percent.
- How concentrated is the support, and how much did the per-donor limit remove (Chapter 10)? Read Schedule A Part II: a limit of $952,100 per donor removed $5,745,800 from the founding family's trust and a regional bank.
On the reading desk
- In two minutes, run questions 1 to 5, then 11, 14, 28 and 36: they catch the wrong copy, the governance gaps, the joint cost and the insider deal.
- In two hours, answer all forty, and write each answer with the part and line it came from.
- Turn every unusual answer into a question for the chief financial officer, not into a conclusion.
- Keep the answers from one year's return and run the same list on the next, so changes stand out.
Key Takeaway: Forty questions, read in the order of the return, turn Brambleton's Year 5 filing into a short list of points: a reported program ratio of 77.54 percent that falls to 74.77 percent without the joint cost program share, 3.06 months of cash but only 2.15 months of liquid unrestricted net assets, no document retention policy, and a $186,000 insider printing contract with no bid. Public support of 84.62 percent and a documented pay process for a $470,000 executive director answer two other questions cleanly. Each answer is a prompt for the filer, not a verdict.