This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Form 5500 by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Form 5500
Before Brisbourne Retirement Consulting's lead consultant signs off on a reading memo, the filing gets one last pass: forty questions, asked in the same order every time. The questions are not new rules. Each one points back to a chapter of this book, and each one exists because a reader somewhere relied on a filing without asking it.
This chapter sets out the forty questions in eight groups, following the order of the earlier chapters. Each question comes with one sentence on why it matters. The questions work on any plan's filing, large or small, retirement or welfare, and the Callowdale case shows each group at work. They are a reading tool, not a filing guide: they tell a reader what to look for, never how to fill in a line.
Filing, dates and parties (questions 1 to 6)
The first group fixes what the reader is holding. At Callowdale, the consultant starts every memo with the plan year, the due date, the extension and the date the filing was submitted, because a filing is history and the reader needs to know how old that history is.
- Which plan year does the filing describe, and is it a full year or a short one? Every figure in the filing belongs to that year and no other (Chapter 2).
- Which form was filed: the full form, the short form or the form for one-participant plans? The form decides which schedules the reader can expect (Chapter 1).
- When was the filing due, and was an extension requested before the due date? A late or unextended filing changes how the reader treats the rest of the record (Chapter 2).
- When was the filing actually submitted, and is it an original or an amended return? An amended return may replace figures the reader has already copied (Chapter 2).
- Who are the plan sponsor and the plan administrator, and do their names match the plan documents? A mismatch often signals a corporate change the reader should understand (Chapter 3).
- Which plan characteristic codes are entered? The codes tell the reader what kind of plan this is before any number is read (Chapter 3).
Counts and plan size (7 to 11)
The second group reads the participant counts, which decide the plan's size and therefore its schedules and its audit. At Callowdale, the counts make the main plan a large plan, while the subsidiary's plan may keep filing as a small plan under the rule Chapter 3 explains.
- How many participants are counted at the beginning of the year, and how many at the end? The change over the year frames everything else the reader sees (Chapter 3).
- How many participants have account balances at the beginning and at the end of the year? For a defined contribution plan, that count drives plan size (Chapter 3).
- Does the plan's size, as the counts set it, match the form and schedules filed? A large plan filed as small, or the reverse, needs an explanation (Chapter 3).
- If the plan sits near the size threshold, did it use the election that lets it keep its prior year size? The election explains a filing that might otherwise look wrong (Chapter 3).
- How many eligible employees have no account balance? That group tells the reader something about participation that the balances alone do not (Chapter 3).
Schedule H statements (12 to 18)
The third group reads the balance sheet and the statement of changes. At Callowdale, the consultant checks that the year's net income equals the change in net assets before reading any fee, because a tie is the first sign that the two parts of the schedule agree.
- What were net assets at the beginning and at the end of the year? Those two figures are the base for every rate the reader later builds (Chapter 4).
- Does net income for the year equal the change in net assets? If it does not, the reader asks why before going further (Chapter 4).
- How are contributions split between employer, participants and rollovers? The split shows who is funding the plan (Chapter 4).
- What were benefit payments, and how do they compare with contributions over the year? The comparison shows whether money is mostly coming in or going out (Chapter 4).
- What was the net investment result, and does it sit with the plan's investment menu? An unexpected result is a question for the investment records, not a conclusion (Chapter 4).
- What were administrative expenses, and how are they split by category? Those are the fees paid from plan assets that the filing shows directly (Chapter 4).
- Which assets carry the largest values, and do they tie to the schedule of assets held for investment? A tie confirms that the balance sheet and the attachment describe the same holdings (Chapter 4).
Compliance answers (19 to 25)
The fourth group reads the yes or no questions of Schedule H, Part IV. At Callowdale, the late contribution answer is Yes, with three late deposits found during the audit and corrected within the year, and the memo reports exactly that without adding a judgment.
- Is the late contribution question answered Yes, and with what amount? A Yes is a fact to explain, not a verdict on the sponsor (Chapter 5).
- If there were late contributions, does the filing or the sponsor show that they were corrected and lost earnings paid? The correction is what turns a problem into a closed item (Chapter 5).
- What caused the late contributions? A named cause, such as a change of payroll provider, points to the process that needs watching (Chapter 5).
- Is the plan a named insured under a fidelity bond? The answer tells the reader whether the people handling plan money are covered (Chapter 5).
- Are the other compliance questions answered No, or are details attached? Any Yes needs to be read with its attachment (Chapter 5).
- Is a schedule of assets held for investment attached when the filing says so? An answer without its attachment is an incomplete record (Chapter 5).
- Is there a reportable transaction, and what was it? A large sale or purchase usually has a business reason the reader can ask about (Chapter 5).
Service providers and fees (26 to 32)
The fifth group reads Schedule C and turns fees into dollars and basis points. At Callowdale, the recordkeeper's revenue sharing appears in its indirect pay, sits inside the fund expenses and is counted only once in Brisbourne's all-in cost.
- Which service providers are listed with direct compensation, and for what services? The list is the starting map of who is paid from the plan (Chapter 6).
- Which providers received indirect compensation, and from which sources? Indirect pay, such as revenue sharing, does not show up in Schedule H expenses (Chapter 6).
- Is any compensation reported as eligible indirect compensation without an amount? The reader then asks for the disclosure that describes it (Chapter 6).
- Does Part II of Schedule C name any provider that failed to give the required information? A named gap is a question to send to the sponsor (Chapter 6).
- Is anything reported on Part III of Schedule C? A blank part is itself an answer the reader notes, and Chapter 6 explains what that part covers (Chapter 6).
- What are the fees paid from plan assets in basis points of average net assets and in dollars per participant with a balance? Those two measures put a plan's fees on a common footing (Chapters 6 and 11).
- When building an all-in cost, where did the fund expense rate come from, and is any revenue sharing counted twice? The fund expense rate is not on the filing, and double counting overstates cost (Chapter 11).
Insurance contracts (33 to 35)
The sixth group reads Schedule A. At Callowdale, the stable value option sits in a group annuity contract, and the insurance agency paid on it does not appear in Schedule C's list of providers, so the reader adds it.
- Does every insurance contract on the investment menu or in the benefit booklet have a Schedule A? A missing schedule is a gap to ask about (Chapter 7).
- Which insurer holds each contract, by its code, and what was the contract worth at year end? The code identifies the insurer even when names are similar (Chapter 7).
- What fees and commissions were paid on each contract, and to whom? The persons paid on Schedule A belong on the reader's full list of providers (Chapter 7).
The audit (36 to 38)
The seventh group reads the accountant's report. At Callowdale, the opinion is unmodified in a limited scope audit, the trustee bank certified the investment information, and the same audit found the late deposits.
- Which opinion box is checked, and does it match the opinion paragraph in the report? The box and the report must tell the same story (Chapter 8).
- Is the audit a limited scope audit, and which institution certified the investment information? The opinion does not rest on testing the certified figures (Chapter 8).
- If no accountant's report is attached, is the plan small, and does it meet the conditions of the audit waiver? A missing report on a large plan is an incomplete filing (Chapter 8).
Defined benefit, multiemployer and welfare filings (39 and 40)
The last group widens the view to the sponsor's other filings. At Callowdale, the frozen Salaried plan carries a Schedule SB, the multiemployer fund lists Callowdale among its contributors, and the fully insured medical plan files with Schedule A and no Schedule H.
- For a defined benefit plan or a multiemployer fund, what funding measure and status does the actuarial schedule show, and who signed it? The reader reports the measure, the year and the signer, and never forecasts (Chapters 9 and 10).
- Which other filings does the same sponsor stand behind, and does each one exist where it should? Welfare plans and funds complete the sponsor's picture, and a missing filing is a question before it is a finding (Chapter 10).
Run in order, the forty questions take a reader from what the filing is to what it shows and then to what it leaves out. The last category is often the most useful one, because it turns into the letter of questions that Appendix B models.
On the reading desk
- Run all forty questions in order, even when the filing looks clean, and note the chapter behind each answer.
- Write every answer with its source: the schedule, the part and the plan year.
- Separate what the filing shows from what it leaves out, and send the second list to the sponsor in writing.
- Never turn an answer into a judgment on fees, funding or compliance: report it and leave decisions to the people who make them.
- Keep the completed checklist with the reading memo, so the next reader of the next year's filing can see what changed.
Key Takeaway: The forty questions are the last pass before anyone relies on a Form 5500, grouped in eight steps that follow the chapters of this book: filing and dates, counts, Schedule H, compliance answers, providers and fees, insurance contracts, the audit, and the sponsor's other filings. Each question points to the chapter that holds its rule. At Callowdale, the same questions turn one filing into a reading memo and a letter to the sponsor, and leave every decision to the investment committee.