Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Form 1120-S

Free to print: Appendix B: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Form 1120-S, from How to Read a Form 1120-S.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Form 1120-S by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Appendix B: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Form 1120-S

Work through the questions in order. Each gives the question, then the reason it matters, then the chapter that explains it. The checklist is a reading aid, not a filing guide and not advice.

The Election and the Shareholders

  1. Is the filed Form 2553 in the election file, and does it show the effective date the company relies on? Every later year rests on that election, so a missing or unclear form is the first gap to close. (Chapter 1)
  2. Do the consents on the election form cover everyone who must consent: each person holding stock on the day the election was made and, for an election filed on or after its effective date, each person who held stock at any time between that date and the day of filing? A missing consent is the kind of defect that puts the election itself in question. (Chapter 1)
  3. Does the stock ledger list only holders who are allowed to own S corporation stock? One holder of the wrong kind can end the election, so the ledger is read before the tax numbers. (Chapter 1)
  4. Do all shares carry identical rights to distributions and liquidation proceeds under the shareholders' agreement and the governing documents? The one class of stock rule looks at those rights, so the agreement is read beside the ledger. (Chapter 1)
  5. Did the company ever file as a C corporation, and when did that period end? Old C corporation years can leave behind earnings and built-in gains that later chapters test. (Chapter 1)

Page 1 and Officer Pay

  1. Do the gross receipts on page 1 tie to the general ledger and the year-end trial balance? Every other number on the page starts from that top line. (Chapter 2)
  2. Does cost of goods sold on page 1 agree with the supporting Form 1125-A? A cost figure without its attachment is a gap that a lender or a buyer will want closed. (Chapter 2)
  3. Is Form 1125-E attached when officers are paid, and does its total match the officer line? The attachment and the line are two views of one number. (Chapter 2)
  4. Does the officer pay on the return agree with the Form W-2 wages issued to the same officers? Pay to an officer for services is wages, and the two reports should say the same thing. (Chapter 3)
  5. Is an officer who also owns stock paid wages that fit the work done, before any distribution is counted? Distributions that stand in for pay invite a reasonable compensation question. (Chapter 3)
  6. Does each large deduction on page 1 have support in the preparer's working papers? A line that cannot be traced to the ledger is hard to rely on, however plausible it looks. (Chapter 2)

Schedule K and the Pro Rata Share

  1. Does the ordinary business income on page 1 equal line 1 of Schedule K? That line is how the page 1 result reaches the shareholders. (Chapter 4)
  2. Which items are separately stated on Schedule K instead of sitting inside ordinary business income? Items that a shareholder taxes differently, such as interest income or charitable contributions, must stay visible. (Chapter 4)
  3. Do the separately stated items on Schedule K add up to the totals of the K-1s? Schedule K holds the whole and the K-1s hold the shares, so the two must agree. (Chapter 4)
  4. Was each item shared by share and by day, and did the share count change during the year? The default method spreads each item over the days of the year and the shares outstanding each day. (Chapter 4)
  5. Do nondeductible expenses and distributions on Schedule K reconcile to the books? Neither is income, yet both change basis. (Chapter 4)

The K-1s

  1. Does each K-1 name a holder who appears on the stock ledger? A K-1 is only as sound as the ledger behind it. (Chapter 5)
  2. Do the box 1 amounts on all the K-1s add up to line 1 of Schedule K? A gap here means income was lost or counted twice. (Chapter 5)
  3. Do the other boxes agree with Schedule K, line by line? Each box is one shareholder's slice of a corporate total. (Chapter 5)
  4. Is each distribution reported in box 16 with the right code, and is any dividend part reported separately to the shareholder who received it? The coding drives the shareholder's basis work and the dividend reporting. (Chapter 5)
  5. If a shareholder's holding changed during the year, do the beginning and ending share counts on the K-1 show it? The counts tell the reader that the items must be allocated with care. (Chapter 5)

Basis and Form 7203

  1. Is there a basis history for each shareholder, and is Form 7203 prepared whenever a loss, a nondividend distribution, a disposal of stock or a loan repayment calls for it? The form is where the shareholder's limits are tested. (Chapter 6)
  2. Does stock basis start the year at the amount the prior year ended with? A starting error carries into every later year. (Chapter 6)
  3. Where a shareholder claims a loss, is it limited to stock basis and debt basis, and what has been suspended? A loss that exceeds basis waits for a year in which basis allows it. (Chapter 6)
  4. Is a shareholder loan a genuine debt, owed directly to that shareholder and documented? A guarantee of the corporation's bank loan does not create debt basis. (Chapter 6)
  5. When the corporation repays a shareholder loan, was debt basis restored before the repayment was treated as a return of capital, and is any gain recognized? Only a net increase restores debt basis, so the year's items decide the result. (Chapter 6)

Distributions and Schedule M-2

  1. Do the distributions on Schedule K agree with the stock ledger and the bank statements? The cash that left the company must match the cash that was reported. (Chapter 7)
  2. Were distributions made in proportion to ownership? Uneven payments do not by themselves create a second class of stock when the governing documents give identical rights, but they need an explanation and their proper tax effect. (Chapters 7 and 10)
  3. Does the accumulated adjustments account on Schedule M-2 roll forward from the prior year with the right additions and reductions? The account decides how much of a distribution is tax free. (Chapter 7)
  4. Does the company hold accumulated earnings and profits from C corporation years, and did any distribution go beyond the accumulated adjustments account? That excess is where a dividend can arise. (Chapter 7)
  5. Was an election made to take earnings and profits first, and do the consents of all affected shareholders support it? Without that support the default order applies. (Chapter 7)

Entity-Level Taxes and the Other Schedules

  1. If the company sold an asset it held as a C corporation, was the built-in gains tax figured in Part III of Schedule D, and is the recognition period still running? The tax is a corporate-level cost on an otherwise pass-through company. (Chapter 8)
  2. Does the company have passive investment income and old earnings and profits at the same time? The excess net passive income tax needs that combination at year end. (Chapter 8)
  3. Do the Schedule B answers match the facts in the file, and do they show whether Schedules L and M-1 must be completed? The answers steer what else the return must contain. (Chapter 9)
  4. Are sales of business property and rental activity reported on the right forms, such as Form 4797, Form 8825 and Schedule D? Misplaced items change the character of what reaches Schedule K. (Chapter 9)

Broken Elections, Lenders and Buyers

  1. Has any event occurred that could have ended the election, such as a transfer to an ineligible holder or a second class of stock? The election can end on the day of the event, which affects every later year. (Chapter 10)
  2. If the election was filed late or may have ended by accident, does the file show a relief route and who must agree to it? Relief depends on facts that are easier to document close to the event. (Chapter 10)
  3. If the election was revoked, was it done with the consent that the rules require? A revocation without the right consent is open to challenge. (Chapter 10)
  4. Does the lender's review join the business and its owners, including the distributions that fund the owners' own tax? A bank judges repayment capacity from both sides of the pass-through. (Chapter 11)
  5. For a buyer, do the election history, the basis history and the planned structure fit together, whether by F reorganization, section 338(h)(10) election or section 336(e) election? The structure decides what the buyer gets and what the sellers report. (Chapter 11)