This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from The FIRPTA Handbook by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
Tool 5: Tax diligence checklist for a foreign investor
Use this list when an investor joins, when an investor changes its structure and before any new investment. The questions are general, with the groups on income, elections and debt drawn from the rules on nonresident aliens and on portfolio interest.
Residence and entity
- Who is the beneficial owner, and what is its status for federal tax?
- Is any entity in the chain disregarded for federal tax? In the case, the single-member limited liability company that holds Building B is disregarded, and its owner is the taxpayer.
- Is the investor a nonresident alien individual? A nonresident alien present in the United States 183 days or more in a taxable year is taxed at 30 percent on net US-source capital gains. In the case for 2027, the private investor is not present for 183 days.
- Does the investor claim a special status, such as foreign government or qualified foreign pension fund? Ask for the supporting documents.
Income and elections
- What does the investor receive: rents, dividends, interest or gains? A nonresident alien is taxed at 30 percent on the gross amount of US-source fixed or periodic income, such as interest, dividends and rents, that is not effectively connected with a US trade or business. Effectively connected income is taxed at the graduated rates.
- Has the investor made the election to treat real property income as effectively connected? A nonresident alien with income from US real property held for the production of income may elect to treat all such income, including gains from its sale, as effectively connected. The election continues for later years unless the IRS consents to revoke it, and after a revocation a new election generally waits until the fifth taxable year.
- In the case, the private investor made the election for 2019, so Building B's income is taxed on a net basis.
Debt terms
- Is the debt in registered form, and is there a statement that the beneficial owner is not a US person? Both are needed for portfolio interest by a nonresident alien.
- Is the lender a 10-percent shareholder of the borrower? For a corporation, that means a holder of 10 percent or more of the total combined voting power, with attribution rules. Interest to such a holder is not portfolio interest.
- Is any interest contingent, that is, determined by the debtor's receipts, sales, cash flow, income, profits, property values or distributions? Contingent interest is not portfolio interest.
- Does an investor propose to turn equity into a shareholder loan? In the case, Kestrel proposed this on 14 September 2023, and Bayline declined after a portfolio interest analysis. The mezzanine notes of Halvard Mutual Insurance are the case's example of debt that works.
Treaties
The 2016 United States Model Income Tax Convention is a model, not a treaty in force with any country. In the model, income from real property and gains from alienating real property, which for the United States includes a US real property interest, may be taxed where the property is. The reduced dividend rate for a US REIT dividend applies only to holders who meet size limits set in the model. Each real treaty differs. The case applies no treaty, and a team that wants treaty benefits asks tax counsel which treaty applies, if any.
Forms
- Does the investor have a US identifying number? Without one, no stamped copy of Form 8288-A is issued until the number is supplied.
- Which forms does the investor give the payer: Form W-8BEN-E for an entity's status, Form W-8EXP for a government or a qualified holder, or Form W-9 for a US person?
- Which return does the investor file for credit, Form 1040-NR or Form 1120-F?
- Who signs, and which adviser files? In the case, the private investor's US tax adviser files Form 8288-B, and Bayline reviews each investor's position with that investor's advisers and never decides it.