Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Fairness Opinion

Free to print: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Fairness Opinion, from How to Read a Fairness Opinion.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Fairness Opinion by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Fairness Opinion

Forty questions are the last pass before a reader relies on a fairness opinion and the summary behind it. A director uses them the night before the committee votes. A junior lawyer uses them on the last turn of the proxy. An arbitrage analyst uses them on the morning the definitive proxy appears on EDGAR, and a journalist uses them before writing a single line about the price.

The questions follow the order of the earlier chapters, and each one points back to the chapter that explains it. They carry no figures on purpose. The numbers change with every deal; the questions do not. Quarrendon, Mirefield and Halsted Rowe answered each of them in the worked case in Chapter 11, and a reader can test the list against that case before using it on a real filing.

Each question has one line and one sentence of why. None of them tells a reader whether an opinion is right. Together, they tell a reader whether the documents let anyone judge.

The documents (questions 1 to 5)

Start by knowing what is in front of you and where each piece sits. Chapter 1 maps the architecture.

  1. Which filing am I reading: a merger proxy, a tender offer response or a going private filing, or more than one together? Each filing type carries its own disclosure items, so the same opinion may be described in more than one place.
  2. Where is the opinion letter itself, and where is the summary of the analyses? The letter states the conclusion and its limits, while the summary shows the work, and a reader needs both.
  3. To whom is the letter addressed, and is that the body that approved the deal? An opinion speaks to its addressee, and a mismatch tells a reader who actually relied on it.
  4. What is the date of the letter, and what happened between that date and the vote? The letter speaks as of its date, so later events are outside it unless the bank says otherwise.
  5. Has any supplement amended the summary after the definitive proxy was mailed? A supplement can change what holders knew before voting, and it is easy to miss on a second reading.

The banker (6 to 11)

Read who the adviser is, how it is paid and whom else it works for before reading any analysis. Chapter 2 covers fees, relationships and the FINRA rule.

  1. Who hired the bank: the board, a special committee, or the buyer? The hiring body shapes whose interests the adviser was retained to serve.
  2. How much of the fee is payable whatever the opinion concludes, and how much only if the deal closes? A contingent fee is common practice, and its share is a fact holders weigh for themselves.
  3. Does the proxy disclose fees the bank received from the buyer, the target or their affiliates in the look-back period it uses? Past and current relationships are the main source of conflict a reader can see.
  4. Does the bank trade or hold the target's or the buyer's securities? Trading positions are often disclosed in a single sentence that is easy to skim past.
  5. Was the opinion approved by the bank's fairness committee, and does the proxy say so? A committee review is a stated step in the bank's process that the letter or summary usually reports.
  6. Did any other adviser, including the buyer's, give an opinion, and if not, does the proxy say so? Knowing which advisers did not opine tells a reader how much rests on the one opinion that exists.

The letter's limits (12 to 16)

The fine print sets the boundaries of the conclusion. Chapter 3 reads it line by line.

  1. To which holders is the price said to be fair? An opinion that names a group, such as holders other than the buyer, says nothing about anyone outside that group.
  2. Does the letter say it relied on information without independent checking? Reliance on supplied information is standard, and the reader then knows the opinion is only as good as that information.
  3. Does the letter disclaim an appraisal of assets or a solvency analysis? A disclaimer tells a reader which questions the opinion never asked.
  4. Does the letter say it is not a recommendation on how to vote, and does it exclude officers' pay? These exclusions keep the opinion narrow, and readers should not stretch it past them.
  5. Does the bank have any duty to update the opinion? Without one, the opinion does not follow the deal after its date.

Projections (17 to 22)

Every intrinsic value in the summary rests on management's numbers. Chapter 4 explains cases, revisions and the direction to use them.

  1. Which set of projections did the bank use, and who directed it to use them? A direction from the board or committee shifts the question from the bank's choice to the directors'.
  2. Were the projections revised during the deal process, and when? A revision after a buyer's approach is a point to read closely, whatever the reasons turn out to be.
  3. What reasons does management give for any revision, and are they specific? Specific, operational reasons let a reader test the revision against the business.
  4. Is there an earlier plan approved before any offer, and does the proxy compare it with the deal case? The gap between a plan made in calm conditions and one made during a deal is information in itself.
  5. Is there a second case, who asked for it, and did management adopt it? A case prepared at a committee's request often reflects a question the committee had.
  6. Are all cases shown in the same detail, cash flows included? A case shown only at the revenue and EBITDA level cannot be read the way the bank read it.

Market-based analyses (23 to 28)

Comparing the target with listed peers and past deals is where selection drives the result. Chapters 5 and 6 cover both analyses.

  1. How many peers and how many precedent deals were selected, and on what criteria? The selection is the analysis, so the criteria matter as much as the multiples.
  2. Does the summary give each peer's and each deal's multiple, or only a range and a median? Individual figures let a reader see clustering and outliers, and their absence is something to note.
  3. How does the bank's reference range sit inside the spread of observed multiples? A range that sits away from the median calls for a reason, which the summary may or may not give.
  4. Which earnings figure is the multiple applied to: a past year or a forecast year? Applying a past multiple to a forecast figure, or the reverse, changes the result.
  5. Is the offer's own implied multiple shown, and on the same basis as the analysis? A like-for-like comparison is the only one that says anything.
  6. Do the precedent deals include ones that differ in kind, such as cash versus stock or minority versus full control? Deals of different kinds carry different premiums, and mixing them blurs the range.

Discounted cash flow (29 to 33)

Two judgment calls move the answer more than any other input. Chapter 7 reads the grid cell by cell.

  1. Does the summary show the cash flows discounted, the discount rates, the growth rates and the terminal period cash flow? Those inputs let a reader follow the method instead of trusting the output.
  2. How does the summary explain the discount rate range? A stated basis, whether a model or professional judgment, turns two numbers into a reasoned choice.
  3. Which timing convention was used for discounting? A mid-year convention and an end-of-year convention give different values from the same cash flows.
  4. Was the terminal value based on perpetuity growth or an exit multiple, and is the implied cross-check shown? Each method can be translated into the other, and the translation tests the assumption.
  5. Where does the offer fall in the sensitivity grid, row by row, not only against the midpoint? The midpoint is one cell, and the shape of the grid tells a reader more.

References and the football field (34 to 36)

Some lines on the chart are shown for context, not relied on. Chapter 8 separates the two.

  1. Which lines are marked for reference only, and does the letter's description of the analyses match? The label tells a reader what the bank says it weighed.
  2. Do the trading range, the analyst targets and the premiums all stop at the unaffected date, and how was that date chosen? A date set too late lets the deal's own effect into the references.
  3. Is the leveraged buyout analysis built on stated inputs, and does it describe the actual buyer or a generic one? A generic financial buyer's capacity says nothing about the actual buyer's own model.

Process and disclosure (37 to 40)

The opinion sits inside a process that Delaware review and federal disclosure rules examine. Chapters 9 and 10 explain how.

  1. If a large holder is the buyer, does the proxy explain the committee's power, membership and independence? Those facts are what counsel sets beside the statute's tests, as Chapter 9 explains.
  2. Does the deal require a vote of holders unaffiliated with the buyer, and is that condition in the deal's terms as submitted to holders? The amended statute looks at the terms at that point, and counsel weighs whether the vote was informed.
  3. In a going private filing, does each filer state its own position on fairness with factors and their weight? A bare statement that the deal is fair is not the discussion the rules call for.
  4. Has a disclosure claim been filed, what did any supplement add, and was a fee or a release involved? The answer tells a reader what was disputed and what holders knew before voting.

On the reading desk

Key Takeaway: Forty questions in eight groups cover the documents, the banker, the letter's limits, the projections, the market-based analyses, the discounted cash flow, the references and the process. They carry no figures because every deal's numbers differ, while the questions stay the same. A reader who can answer all forty knows what the opinion says, what it rests on and what it leaves out, which is the whole purpose of reading it.