Free companion page
Free to print: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Executive Employment Agreement, from How to Read an Executive Employment Agreement.
This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read an Executive Employment Agreement by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
Forty questions are the last thing to read before signing, approving or underwriting an executive contract. They are written for three readers at once: the executive deciding whether to sign, the compensation committee and its consultant deciding whether to approve, and the lender, buyer or insurer deciding what the contract will cost them later. Each question can be answered from the document set: the contract or offer letter, the equity plan and award agreements, any severance or change in control plan, the recovery policy, the charter and bylaws.
The questions follow the order of the book. Each one points to the chapter that explains it, and each comes with one sentence on why it matters. The Tamsworth Dynamics Inc. case is the test bench: a reader who can answer all forty for the Tamsworth contract can answer them for any other.
A question with no answer in the documents is itself an answer. A silent contract usually means the equity plan, a separate policy or the default rules decide, and the reader should find out which before relying on it.
These eight questions fix the job and the cash. They come first because almost every later definition, from good reason to the severance multiple, is built on them (Chapters 2 and 3).
What is the exact title, and to whom does the executive report?
The reporting line is often the first thing a buyer changes, and a change to it can become good reason (Chapters 2 and 5).
What duties and authority does the contract describe, and can the company change them alone?
A material reduction in duties is a common good reason event only if the starting duties are written down (Chapter 2).
What is the term, and does it renew automatically?
A fixed term with automatic renewal can affect what is owed if the company gives notice of non-renewal (Chapter 2).
Where is the principal place of work, and can it be moved?
A forced relocation is a common good reason trigger, and the place of work can also matter for which state's law applies (Chapters 2 and 9).
What is the base salary, and can it be reduced?
Salary is the base of the severance multiple and of most bonus targets, so any reduction clause changes several numbers at once (Chapter 3).
What is the target bonus, how is it measured, and who decides the payout?
The target sets the severance multiple in many contracts, while the actual payout depends on measures that a later restatement can reopen (Chapters 3 and 8).
Is there a sign-on or make-whole award, and when must it be repaid?
A repayment condition tied to the reason for leaving can turn an early departure into a debt (Chapter 3).
Which benefits, perquisites and expense rules does the contract promise rather than leave to company policy?
A benefit promised in the contract survives a change of policy; a benefit left to policy does not (Chapter 6 covers health benefits after departure).
The contract usually points to the equity plan and the award agreements rather than repeating them. These questions check what the contract itself changes (Chapter 4).
Which grants does the contract promise, with what number of units or value, and on what date?
A promise of value rather than units leaves the share price at grant to decide the number of shares (Chapter 4).
What are the vesting schedules, and which awards depend on performance rather than service alone?
The difference decides treatment at termination and, after a change in control, how much counts under Section 280G (Chapters 4 and 7).
What happens to each award on each reason for leaving?
Forfeiture, proration, continued vesting and acceleration can differ award by award, and the contract can override the plan (Chapter 4).
At what level are performance awards settled on termination or after a change in control: target, actual results or the greater of the two?
That choice can move the value of a performance award as much as the vesting itself (Chapters 4 and 7).
Does the contract promise future annual grants, or leave them to the committee?
A deferred or skipped annual grant will not be in the package that later protection reaches (Chapter 4).
These definitions decide which row of the severance table applies. They are the most negotiated words in the contract (Chapter 5).
How is cause defined, and is the list closed or open?
An open or vague list lets the company move a departure from the paid rows to the unpaid ones (Chapter 5).
Does cause require notice and a chance to cure, and who decides that cause exists?
A cure right and a board vote are the main procedural protections for the executive (Chapter 5).
How is good reason defined, item by item?
Each item is a door to severance after a voluntary resignation, and a missing item is a closed door (Chapter 5).
What notice, cure period and deadline to resign apply to good reason?
A resignation that skips a step in the notice and cure sequence can lose its good reason status (Chapters 5 and 11).
How are disability and death defined and treated?
These rows often pay a prorated bonus and accelerate some equity, which a reader can miss by reading only the termination clause (Chapter 5).
What happens on non-renewal of the term by either side?
Unless the contract says otherwise, the company's non-renewal may pay nothing even though the executive did not choose to leave (Chapters 2 and 5).
Does the contract say that it does not change at-will employment?
Most US executives are employed at will, and the contract decides what is paid when employment ends, not whether it can end (Chapter 5).
Severance turns a definition into money. These questions check the amount, the form and the conditions (Chapter 6).
What is the severance multiple, and of what: salary alone, or salary plus target bonus?
The base of the multiple changes the result as much as the multiple itself (Chapter 6).
Is severance paid in a lump sum or in installments, and over what period?
Installments can be tied to compliance with covenants and have their own Section 409A timing (Chapters 6 and 9).
What bonus is paid for the year of departure: none, prorated at target or prorated on actual results?
Proration on actual results delays the payment and exposes it to the year's outcome (Chapter 6).
How many months of COBRA or other health premiums are paid?
A modest line in total but often the most immediate need for a departing executive (Chapter 6).
Is severance conditioned on a release of claims, and by when must it be signed and become irrevocable?
The release deadline drives the start of payments and, for a specified employee, the Section 409A analysis (Chapter 6).
Does the contract contain a six-month delay clause for a specified employee, and how is any catch-up payment made?
A key employee of a listed company is a specified employee, and some deferred compensation cannot be paid in the first six months after separation (Chapter 6).
These questions apply once a sale is possible, which for a listed company means at any time (Chapter 7).
How is change in control defined, and does it fire on signing, shareholder approval or closing?
The definition decides whether the protection is triggered at all, and when (Chapter 7).
Is the protection single trigger or double trigger, and how long is the protection period?
Under a double trigger, a qualifying departure outside the protection period falls back to regular severance (Chapters 7 and 11).
What does the change in control severance pay, line by line, compared with regular severance?
The difference between the two rows is often the largest number in the contract (Chapters 6 and 7).
What is the executive's Section 280G base amount, and how close are the expected payments to three times that amount?
An executive with a short or thin base period reaches the threshold sooner (Chapter 7).
Does the contract provide a gross-up, a cutback or a best-net clause?
Each answer shifts the cost of the excise tax and the lost deduction between the executive and the company (Chapter 7).
Who runs the Section 280G calculation, on what assumptions, and in what order are payments reduced if a cutback applies?
Different assumptions can flip a best-net result, and the order of reduction decides which payments survive (Chapter 7).
The last eight questions cover what follows the executive after departure (Chapters 8, 9 and 10).
Which recovery policy applies, and does the contract bind the executive to future versions of it?
The policy, not the contract, holds most of the detail, and a clause accepting future versions lets it grow (Chapter 8).
Does any clawback in the contract reach beyond the federal rule: misconduct, covenant breach, time-vested equity, severance?
Each extension adds exposure that the rule alone would not create (Chapter 8).
Does any clause, side letter or arrangement promise to make the executive whole for a recovery?
A listed company may not indemnify an executive officer against recovery under the rule (Chapter 8).
What do the confidentiality, non-solicitation and non-compete covenants cover, and for how long?
Three covenants with three durations protect three different interests and are judged separately (Chapter 9).
Which states could claim to apply their law to the covenants?
With no federal rule banning non-competes, state law decides enforceability, and the reader's state may differ from the one the contract names (Chapter 9).
Does indemnification cover acts as an officer after departure, and is advancement of legal fees mandatory?
Exposure for a former officer often begins after departure, and advancement decides who funds the defense meanwhile (Chapter 10).
How long does directors and officers insurance cover the executive after departure, and on what terms?
Claims-made policies need an express commitment to keep a former officer covered (Chapter 10).
What governing law, forum and fee rules apply to a dispute about the contract?
Arbitration, carve-outs for injunctions and fee shifting decide what it costs to enforce every other answer on this list (Chapter 10).
Key Takeaway: Forty questions, in six groups, cover the whole contract: position and pay (1 to 8), equity (9 to 13), termination definitions (14 to 20), severance and release (21 to 26), change in control and Section 280G (27 to 32), and what follows the executive after departure (33 to 40). For Tamsworth Dynamics Inc. and Haverstock Group, as for any listed company and buyer, the answers to questions 1, 17 and 28 alone can decide whether a resignation after a sale pays regular severance or the change in control package. Read the list before signing, approving or underwriting, and treat every blank answer as a question still open.