Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read an Environmental Permit

Free to print: Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist, from How to Read an Environmental Permit.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read an Environmental Permit by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist

This checklist walks a reader through an environmental permit in eight groups. Each question takes one line, is followed by one sentence on why it matters, and points to the chapter that explains it. It is a reading aid for a document, not advice on any real site.

Architecture and document (questions 1 to 5)

  1. Is the activity a regulated facility, and in which class? The class decides which rules attach to the operator and which kind of permit applies, so every later answer depends on it. (Chapter 1.)
  2. Is this a bespoke permit or a standard rules permit? A bespoke permit is written for one site, while a standard rules permit adopts a published rule set, and the room for later change differs between them. (Chapter 1.)
  3. Is the document a consolidated permit, and which variations feed into it? A reader needs to know whether the text in hand is the whole current permit or only one step in its history. (Chapters 1 and 2.)
  4. What does the introductory note say, and what is it not part of? The note helps with orientation, but the legal duties sit in the conditions and schedules, so the two must not be confused. (Chapter 2.)
  5. What do the status log, the decision document and the public register add? Together they show how the permit reached its present form and why the regulator set its conditions as it did. (Chapter 2.)

Operator and competence (questions 6 to 10)

  1. Who is named as the operator, and is that legal entity the one in control? A permit binds the named operator, and a trading name or a group of people cannot hold it. (Chapter 3.)
  2. Does anyone other than the named operator, such as a parent or a contractor, control the site in practice? Control in practice can point away from the name on the permit and may call for a transfer. (Chapter 3.)
  3. Which approved competence scheme applies, and is the evidence of competence current? The technically competent manager is a condition of the permit, and a lapse in certification is a gap in the operator's position. (Chapter 3.)
  4. What attendance does the technically competent manager owe, and what can change it? Attendance is a share of operating time set by points, and a poor compliance quarter can move it back to a higher level. (Chapter 3.)
  5. Is there a written management system, and does it cover the risks that matter on this site? The system is the first thing the regulator looks to when it finds the root cause of a breach. (Chapter 3.)

Activities, waste and site (questions 11 to 15)

  1. Which activities does the permit list, and do they match what happens on the ground? An activity outside the table is outside the permit, however natural it may seem to the site team. (Chapter 4.)
  2. What is the annual waste input limit, and how does waste received compare with it? A limit is a ceiling in the permit, and a year above it is a breach that a score and a charge will later reflect. (Chapter 4.)
  3. Which waste types and quantities are permitted? The table of waste types is the list of what may come through the gate, and waste outside it should not be accepted. (Chapter 4.)
  4. Where does the site plan draw the edge, and do activities and storage stay inside it? The permit covers only the land shown on the plan, which is also what a later partial surrender would cut down. (Chapters 4 and 10.)
  5. If the site is a materials facility, have the notification and sampling duties been met? These duties tie the operator's records to its suppliers, so gaps in them show up in the paperwork. (Chapter 4.)

Emissions and monitoring (questions 16 to 20)

  1. Which point source emissions are listed, and what limit applies to each? A limit is the line between compliance and breach, so the reader must know the parameter, the unit and the type of sample. (Chapter 5.)
  2. Which emissions are controlled by general conditions rather than by limits? Dust, flies, vermin, mud and litter are managed by duties and plans, and they still count when the site is assessed. (Chapters 5 and 6.)
  3. What monitoring does the permit require, how often, and to what standard? Monitoring is how the operator proves compliance, and the permit expects approved methods and certified equipment unless the regulator agrees otherwise. (Chapter 5.)
  4. Were monitoring results reported on time, and how did each result compare with its limit? Each limit is judged on its own, so one poor result can score even when the others are fine. (Chapters 5 and 7.)
  5. Does the permit allow any point source emission that is not listed? A release from an unlisted point is outside the permit, and the absence of a listing is itself a finding. (Chapter 5.)

Amenity and fire (questions 21 to 25)

  1. What does the odour condition require, and what triggers an odour management plan? Many odour conditions work through a plan the regulator can call for, and the guidance already expects one at a transfer station, so the reader asks for the approved version. (Chapter 6.)
  2. What does the permit say about noise and vibration? The condition is usually framed around effects outside the site boundary, and any plan it requires belongs in the file. (Chapter 6.)
  3. How are dust, pests and litter dealt with? These are controlled by duties and plans, and a long-running problem can be scored as a serious breach. (Chapters 5 and 6.)
  4. Is there an approved fire prevention plan, and does it set pile sizes, separation, a quarantine area and a water supply? The plan is the working fire standard for the site, and the stored waste has to fit it. (Chapter 6.)
  5. Is the plan reviewed and resubmitted when storage or layout changes? A change to storage can alter the plan itself, and may bring a variation with it. (Chapters 6 and 10.)

Records and notifications (questions 26 to 29)

  1. Which records must be kept, in what form, and for how long? Records are the evidence on which every other answer rests, and a gap in them is hard to repair afterwards. (Chapter 7.)
  2. Were the periodic waste returns and monitoring returns sent within their deadlines? A late return is a small breach on its face, but it is scored and it appears in the file. (Chapter 7.)
  3. Which events need immediate notice, and what written confirmation follows? Incident and breach notices have their own clocks, and a reader should be able to find them in the permit schedule. (Chapter 7.)
  4. Which company events must be notified, and what does the permit say about false statements? Changes of name or address and steps towards insolvency are reportable, and inaccurate records are an offence in their own right. (Chapter 7.)

Compliance, charges and enforcement (questions 30 to 35)

  1. What compliance assessment reports exist, and what category and points did each breach receive? The reports are public register documents, and they hold the history that a buyer or lender will read first. (Chapter 8.)
  2. Which compliance band applied in each compliance year? The band is a letter drawn from the year's points, and it moves the charge and the regulator's attention. (Chapter 8.)
  3. What is the annual subsistence charge, and how did the band change it? The charge is the activity charge adjusted by the earlier year's band, so a bad year costs money in the year after. (Chapter 8.)
  4. Has any enforcement notice, suspension notice or revocation notice been served, and are the steps complete? An open notice can follow the permit into a transfer and sits in the lender's conditions. (Chapter 9.)
  5. Has the operator faced a variable monetary penalty, given an enforcement undertaking or been prosecuted? These show how the regulator has responded in the past and what the operator has been willing to accept. (Chapter 9.)
  6. Which appeal periods have run, and was an appeal made? A notice that was not appealed in time is in practice settled, and the date is easy to check. (Chapter 9.)

Change, transfer, surrender and diligence (questions 36 to 40)

  1. Which variations have been made, and of what kind? The type of variation shows how much assessment the change needed, what it cost and how long it took. (Chapter 10.)
  2. Would a planned transaction need a transfer of the permit, or does the operator stay the same? A sale of shares leaves the operator unchanged, while a move of the business into a new company calls for a transfer. (Chapters 10 and 11.)
  3. What is the surrender position, and what does the site condition report record? The baseline in the report is the yardstick for any later surrender, whole or partial. (Chapter 10.)
  4. What would a buyer or a lender ask to see about the permit? A short list of documents, plans and confirmations usually sits in the conditions of a financing, and the permit supplies most of them. (Chapter 11.)
  5. Does the story told by the permit, the register, the reports and the operator's own records hang together? Where the sources disagree, the difference is the finding, and the worked case shows how one site reads from start to finish. (Chapters 11 and 12.)