Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Distribution Agreement

Free to print: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Distribution Agreement, from How to Read a Distribution Agreement.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Distribution Agreement by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Distribution Agreement

Picture the reader at a desk with a signed copy of a distribution agreement, a pencil and forty questions. The reason for the questions is one number from the case. When Quarrington Instruments, Inc. ended its agreement with Kestermoor Supply Co., the exit cost Kestermoor $257,500: a restocking fee of $118,000, a loss of $121,500 on stock excluded from the buyback and $18,000 of forfeited market development funds. Every one of those amounts was written into the agreement years earlier, in clauses that a careful reader could have priced at signing.

This chapter turns the book into a list. The forty questions follow the order of the chapters, and each comes with one line on why it matters. They work for a manufacturer's channel manager, a distributor's controller, an analyst reviewing a target's contracts or counsel on either side. They do not tell anyone what to sign; they show where to look.

Parties, appointment and territory

These questions come mainly from Chapters 1 and 2; the one on assignment applies to any commercial contract.

  1. What kind of relationship is this: a buy-sell distributorship, a sales agency, a reseller arrangement or a supply agreement? Why it matters: title, credit risk and who sets the resale price all follow from the structure.
  2. Who exactly are the parties, and can either assign the agreement or change control without consent? Why it matters: a sale of either business can hand the contract to someone else.
  3. Which products are covered, and can the manufacturer add or withdraw product lines? Why it matters: a line withdrawn from the schedule shrinks the business without any termination.
  4. How is the territory defined, by geography, by customer type or both, and where is the exhibit that lists it? Why it matters: every sales restriction and every exclusivity promise is measured against that definition.
  5. Is the appointment exclusive, sole or non-exclusive, and what does each word mean in this document? Why it matters: the labels are not used the same way in every agreement, and the definition controls.
  6. Which accounts does the manufacturer reserve as house accounts, and does the distributor earn anything on them? Why it matters: reserved accounts can be the largest customers in the territory.
  7. Can the manufacturer sell directly, online or through other channels inside the territory? Why it matters: an exclusive appointment with a wide direct sales carve-out may be exclusive in name only.

Minimums and exclusivity

These questions come from Chapter 3.

  1. What are the minimum purchases for each year, and are they measured on net purchases or gross? Why it matters: returns, credits and discounts can move the measure across a threshold.
  2. What happens at each level of shortfall: conversion to non-exclusive, termination, or something else? Why it matters: each threshold is a separate trigger with its own notice period.
  3. Which unshipped or allocated orders count toward the minimum? Why it matters: the words describing excused orders can decide on which side of a threshold the distributor lands.
  4. Does a missed minimum let the manufacturer appoint other distributors, and where? Why it matters: a second distributor changes prices, customers and margins at once.
  5. Do the minimums stop applying once exclusivity ends? Why it matters: a distributor should not carry exclusive-level targets after losing exclusivity.
  6. Is any non-compete tied to exclusivity, and does it end when exclusivity ends? Why it matters: a distributor that loses exclusivity may need to add a competing line quickly.

Prices, rebates and funds

These questions come from Chapter 4.

  1. How is the distributor's price set: a discount off list, a price list, or a formula? Why it matters: the base decides the distributor's gross margin on every sale.
  2. How much notice must the manufacturer give before changing list prices or discounts? Why it matters: a price change without notice can catch the distributor with stock or quotes at the old price.
  3. How are rebates calculated, and is each tier a cliff or graduated? Why it matters: a single threshold can turn a small shortfall into the loss of the whole rebate.
  4. When are rebates paid, and can they be offset against amounts the distributor owes? Why it matters: timing and offset decide whether the rebate is cash or only a credit.
  5. What do market development funds accrue on, what activities do they pay for, and what approvals are needed? Why it matters: funds are conditional money, and each condition is a way to lose them.
  6. What is the claim deadline for funds, and what happens to unused balances at year end and at termination? Why it matters: forfeited funds were one of the three parts of the case exit cost.
  7. Are other distributors' prices, discounts and programs available for comparison, and is there any stated basis for differences? Why it matters: competing distributors on different terms raise questions covered in Chapter 9.

Orders, title, returns and price protection

These questions come from Chapters 5 and 6.

  1. How are orders placed, accepted and rejected, and how long does the manufacturer have to accept? Why it matters: an order not yet accepted may bind no one.
  2. What forecasts must the distributor give, and do forecasts bind either party? Why it matters: forecasts can feed into allocation rules and into the count toward minimums.
  3. What happens in a shortage: who gets supply first, and how is it allocated? Why it matters: allocation can push the distributor below a minimum through no act of its own.
  4. When do title and risk of loss pass, and under which Incoterms rule or delivery term? Why it matters: the party holding risk bears the loss of damaged goods in transit.
  5. What are the payment terms, credit limits and the consequences of late payment? Why it matters: the distributor finances its stock, and a cut in credit can halt its orders.
  6. What stock rotation rights does the distributor have, and with what limits and fees? Why it matters: stock rotation, the right to swap slow-moving stock for other products, protects the distributor from dead inventory.
  7. Does price protection credit the distributor's stock when the manufacturer lowers the distributor price, and how is that stock counted? Why it matters: without it, a price cut writes down the distributor's inventory directly.

Marketing, online sales and warranty

These questions come from Chapters 7 and 8.

  1. What does the trademark license allow, where, in what form, and how long after termination may the marks still be used? Why it matters: signs, catalogs and web pages do not change overnight.
  2. Can the distributor sell online, on its own site and on third-party marketplaces, and to whom? Why it matters: a web page reaches everywhere, while the territory clause does not.
  3. Is there a minimum advertised price policy, is it a unilateral policy or an agreed term, and what does "advertise" cover? Why it matters: the definition decides how far the policy reaches, and its legal status is a question for counsel.
  4. What restrictions apply to resale outside the authorized channel, and how is diversion traced? Why it matters: gray market sales affect service, warranty and pricing in other territories.
  5. What does the manufacturer's warranty cover, how long does it last, when does each clock start and does it pass through to end users? Why it matters: stock that sits on the shelf can use up warranty time before any sale.
  6. How is warranty labor paid, and is there any clause shortening the time to bring a claim? Why it matters: the distributor often does the repair, and a shortened period can cut off a claim early.
  7. Who decides a recall, who pays for product, freight and labor, and what indemnities and insurance stand behind each side? Why it matters: a recall or a product claim can cost more than a year's margin on the line.

Law, termination and the exit

These questions come from Chapters 9 to 11.

  1. Which law governs, which courts or arbitration apply, and could a dealer protection statute reach the relationship where the distributor operates? Why it matters: a statute can change what notice and cause mean, whatever the contract says.
  2. Do any terms on price, resale or exclusive dealing call for review by an antitrust lawyer? Why it matters: whether such terms are lawful depends on facts and markets that the contract does not show.
  3. What is the term, how does it renew, and what is the earliest date either party can end the agreement without cause? Why it matters: the earliest exit date, not the end of the term, is the date a distributor's investment has to survive.
  4. What are the grounds and notice periods for termination for cause, and is there a cure period? Why it matters: a short cure period can turn a dispute into a termination.
  5. What does the buyback cover, at what price, with what restocking fee, and what is excluded? Why it matters: in the case, the restocking fee and the loss on excluded stock made up most of the $257,500 exit cost.
  6. What happens during transition: the sell-off period, the open backlog, the customer list and open warranty claims? Why it matters: the last months decide who keeps the customers and who carries the remaining obligations.

On the reading desk

Key Takeaway: Forty questions cover a distribution agreement from appointment to exit, in the order of the chapters of this book. In the case, the answers to a handful of them, on the restocking fee, the excluded stock and forfeited funds, set Kestermoor's exit cost at $257,500 years before the notice came. The list does not say what to sign; it shows where the money and the risk sit.