Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Development Consent Order

Free to print: Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist, from How to Read a Development Consent Order.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Development Consent Order by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist

Use this list the first time you open a development consent order, and again before any financing, purchase or land negotiation. Each question points to the chapter that explains the rule, so the list works as an index as well as a checklist. The answers come from the order and its certified documents, never from this book.

Architecture and documents

  1. Which statutory instrument are you reading, and what does its title say it covers? A consent order can be amended or corrected, so you must be sure you hold the current version. (Chapter 1)
  2. Where do the articles end and the schedules begin, and which schedules carry the real detail? Articles give the powers, while the schedules usually decide how far those powers reach. (Chapter 1)
  3. Which documents does the order certify, and have you read every one of them? The order refers to them for plans, limits and commitments, so an unread certified document is an unread part of the order. (Chapter 1)
  4. Does the explanatory memorandum say where each article came from, and why any departure was made? A departure from an earlier order shows where the drafter chose a different balance of risk. (Chapter 1)
  5. Who is the undertaker, and what does the order say about who holds the benefit? Every power belongs to someone, and a lender or buyer needs to know exactly who that is. (Chapter 1)
  6. Is the project within the English regime, and does anything in it depend on another nation's consent? This book covers England and English waters only, so a Welsh or Scottish element needs its own check under the rules that apply there. (Chapter 1)

Schedule 1 and the envelope

  1. Does Schedule 1 describe the authorised development as numbered works, and does each work appear on the works plans? A work that is described but not plotted is hard to build and hard to finance. (Chapter 2)
  2. Which works are listed as ancillary works, and which are associated development? The label changes how closely the work is tied to the main project and how it is described. (Chapter 2)
  3. Which design parameters cap the project, such as numbers, heights and sizes, and where are they fixed? A limit in a requirement binds differently from a limit in a schedule, and you need to know which one controls. (Chapter 2)
  4. What limits of deviation apply, sideways and vertically, and do the order limits on the works plans match them? These limits decide how far the final design can move, and how much land is exposed. (Chapter 2)
  5. Does the design in your model sit inside the envelope with room to spare? Equipment moves on during a long programme, and a design that already touches a limit has no room left. (Chapter 2)

Requirements and time limits

  1. Which requirements must be discharged before first works, and which authority discharges each one? A list of pre-commencement requirements is a list of approvals that sit on the critical path. (Chapter 3)
  2. What is the time limit to begin the project, and what counts as beginning it? A consent that lapses is worth nothing, so the definition of the start matters as much as the date. (Chapter 3)
  3. What decision period does each approval carry, and what restarts it? A request for more information can reset the clock, which moves the whole programme. (Chapter 3)
  4. Does any requirement let the authority approve changes or add detail beyond the original approval? An open power of this kind can widen the order, and a lender will want to know its limits. (Chapter 3)
  5. If the authority refuses or stays silent, what remedy does the order give? Without an appeal or a deemed outcome, delay has no fixed end. (Chapter 3)
  6. Which environmental commitments bind the undertaker, and do they sit in the order itself or in a certified plan? A commitment that is only a statement of intent carries less weight than one the order enforces. (Chapter 8)

Land powers and compensation

  1. Which compulsory acquisition powers does the order grant, over which land and for which works? The powers are the most intrusive part of the order, and each must be tied to a purpose. (Chapter 4)
  2. Is there a time limit to start using those powers, and does it differ from the time limit to begin the project? Two clocks can run to different dates, and the shorter one can end land powers first. (Chapter 4)
  3. Does the book of reference list every plot with its owners, tenants and rights, and does it match the land plans? The book is the record on which notices and compensation claims depend. (Chapter 4)
  4. Where is the case for taking land set out, and is there a statement on funding to match it? Land can be taken only on a justified case, and the funding statement shows that the project can pay for it. (Chapter 4)
  5. Which plots need only new rights, rather than outright ownership, and what rights are they? A cable route often needs a strip right, which leaves the landowner farming above it. (Chapter 4)
  6. Which heads of compensation apply, and who would be the claimant on each plot? A freeholder, a tenant and an occupier may each have a separate claim, including statutory loss payments. (Chapter 4)
  7. Does the order allow temporary possession, over which land, on what notice and for how long? Temporary use of land avoids a full acquisition, but it still disturbs the person in occupation. (Chapter 5)
  8. What does the order say about nuisance, and what is left to compensation? A statutory defence may protect the undertaker, which moves the remedy from an injunction to a claim for payment. (Chapter 5)

Protective provisions and marine licences

  1. Which statutory undertakers have apparatus on or near the route, and does each have its own protective provisions? A crossing without protection can stop work, so each party's terms should be found early. (Chapter 6)
  2. What approvals must be obtained before work near apparatus, and who bears the costs and the risk? Prior approval of plans, indemnities and cost terms usually shape the programme. (Chapter 6)
  3. How are disputes with a protected party resolved? A route to arbitration or to the Secretary of State keeps a disagreement from freezing a crossing. (Chapter 6)
  4. Which marine licences does the order treat as granted, for which assets, and do the conditions stand apart? Separate licences can carry separate obligations and separate holders. (Chapter 7)
  5. Which pre-construction plans need approval from the Marine Management Organisation, and how long does it have to decide? Offshore plans often fall on the critical path, so the decision period and the submission date must fit together. (Chapter 7)
  6. What offences follow if the order's terms are not met, and who can enforce them? The criminal sanction is part of what gives the conditions their force, but a breach of a deemed marine licence condition falls under the marine regime, not section 161. (Chapter 7)

Transfer, funding and change

  1. To whom can the benefit of the order be transferred, and with whose consent or notice? A sale of the transmission assets or a change of owner depends on this article. (Chapter 9)
  2. When the benefit is transferred in part, which powers stay with the original undertaker? Reserved land powers can leave a buyer with a project it cannot fully build or maintain. (Chapter 9)
  3. What security must be in place before land powers are used, who can enforce it, and for how long? This is the funding article, and it usually becomes a condition for lenders. (Chapter 9)
  4. Does your planned change fit inside the existing order, or does it need an amendment, and is that amendment material? The route chosen decides the cost, the time and the risk of challenge. (Chapter 11)
  5. Does your plan rely on a change procedure that Parliament has passed but not yet brought into force? A rule that is not in force cannot be relied on, and the plan needs a fallback. (Chapter 11)

Examination and challenge

  1. What do the examination record and the recommendation report show about the issues that were contested? The history of the examination explains why the order says what it says. (Chapter 10)
  2. Was the decision made in line with the national policy statement, and which findings does your project rely on? A finding that your case rests on is an asset only while the decision stands. (Chapter 10)
  3. Has the challenge window closed with no claim, and who has confirmed it? A lender will usually want this confirmed before it relies on the order. (Chapter 10)
  4. Which of the answers above are conditions for funding, and in what order do they fall due? Reading the order in this sequence turns the checklist into a programme, as the worked case shows. (Chapter 12)