This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Deferred Prosecution Agreement by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
Appendix B: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions and a Comparison Grid
This checklist follows the order of the book. Each of the forty questions is one line, followed by a sentence on why it matters and the chapter where the answer is explained. The case figures are those of Ostwick Industrial Holdings, Inc. (Ostwick). The questions are for reading a document, not for deciding what to sign. A reader can work through them in order with a pencil, writing the page and paragraph of each answer next to the number, and the gaps that remain are the first points to understand before going further. After the questions, a comparison grid sets three types of agreement side by side.
Form and Parties
- What is the form of the resolution: deferred prosecution agreement (DPA), non-prosecution agreement (NPA), plea or declination? The form decides whether a court is involved and whether a conviction exists. Chapter 1.
- Is a criminal information filed in federal court, and who signs for the company and for the government? A DPA is filed with a court, while an NPA is a letter agreement that is not. In the case, the information is filed at Month 0. Chapter 1.
- Which prosecuting offices are parties? In the case these are the Fraud Section of the Criminal Division and one United States Attorney's Office, and the text should say whether the agreement binds anyone else. Chapter 1.
- Which part of the 2026 policy does the case seem to fall in? With no voluntary self-disclosure but full cooperation and remediation, the case sits in Part III, and anything that depends on the date the policy applies is stated in the conditional. Chapter 1.
- Does the agreement say that it does not bind other agencies, such as the SEC or a foreign authority? Parallel resolutions are separate documents, and the case has two of them. Chapter 10.
- When did the board approve, and who is authorized to sign? In the case the board resolution comes 2 days before signing, and an authorized officer signs for the company. Chapter 8.
Facts and Admissions
- Does the company admit responsibility for the acts of its officers, employees and agents? The admission is what later statements are measured against. Chapter 2.
- Are the facts specific enough to check? In the case the statement gives 6 contracts, $61,000,000 of revenue and $1,200,000 passed to utility officials. Chapter 2.
- Are people named by role, and does the statement say who knew? In the case the regional sales vice president knew of the arrangement with Sablemere Trading. Chapter 2.
- Is every fact one the company can defend? A fact the company cannot stand behind becomes a problem when someone speaks about the case later. Chapter 2.
- Does a clause forbid contradicting the statement of facts? That clause links the admissions to the public-statement rules and to breach. Chapter 11.
- Which period and which conduct does the statement cover? In the case the conduct runs through Years 1 to 3, and the scope of the admissions sets the scope of everything else. Chapter 2.
Term and Dismissal
- How long is the term, and what starts the clock? In the case the term is 36 months, from Month 0 to Month 36. Chapter 3.
- Who may extend the term, for how long, and on what notice? In the case the maximum extension is 12 months, which would move the end to Month 48. Chapter 3.
- Does the agreement toll the speedy trial clock and the limitations period? Deferral only works if the government does not lose time while it waits. Chapters 3 and 9.
- What does the government promise at the end, and by when? In the case the prosecutors seek dismissal with prejudice within 6 months after expiry, by Month 42. Chapter 3.
- Does a monitor change the clock? In the monitor illustration, a term counted from the later of filing or retention ends at Month 40 instead of Month 36. Chapter 3.
- Which obligations stop at expiry and which continue? A reader should list them, since the certifications fall at the end of the term. Chapter 3.
Penalty and Credits
- Which culpability score is stated, and how is it built? In the case the score is 7: base 5, plus 4, minus 2. Chapter 4.
- What is the fine range? In the case it runs from $25,760,000 to $51,520,000, built on a base fine of $18,400,000. Chapter 4.
- Where does the penalty sit in the range, and why? In the case it is 30 percent off the low end, which gives $18,032,000. Chapter 4.
- Is any foreign penalty credited, and how is it described? In the case $4,500,000 paid abroad for the same conduct is credited, leaving $13,532,000 for the US Treasury. Chapter 4.
- How is the payment scheduled, and does interest run? In the case there are two installments of $6,766,000, at Month 0 and Month 12, with no interest. Chapter 4.
- Does the agreement order forfeiture, restitution or disgorgement? In the case the DPA orders no separate forfeiture, because disgorgement sits in the SEC resolution. Chapter 10.
- What do all the payments add to across authorities? In the case the total is $38,582,000, and a reader should compare it with any provision the company has booked. Chapter 10.
Cooperation, Compliance, Monitor and Reports
- How far does the duty to cooperate reach, and how is privilege treated? Cooperation reaches information, and the clause should say what stays protected. Chapter 5.
- Must the company report new evidence, and how fast? In the case a possible improper payment learned in Month 19 is reported in Month 20. Chapter 5.
- What does Attachment C require of the compliance program? It is the list against which the company is measured every year of the term. Chapter 6.
- Do the undertakings fit the conduct in the statement of facts? A program built for a different problem satisfies the text and misses the cause. Chapter 6.
- Is there a monitor, a consultant or neither? In the case the prosecutors choose no monitor, and the company reports for itself. Chapter 7.
- If there were a monitor, how would the person be chosen? In the illustration the company proposes three candidates within 20 business days, and selection is aimed at 60 days. Chapter 7.
- What is the reporting calendar? In the case there is a work plan within 60 days, then reports at Month 12, Month 24 and Month 33. Chapter 8.
- Who certifies what at expiry? In the case the chief executive officer and chief financial officer certify disclosure, and the chief executive officer and chief compliance officer certify compliance, each as a material statement. Chapter 8.
Breach, Collateral Consequences and Public Statements
- What counts as a breach, and who decides? In the case the decision is the prosecutors', not a court's. Chapter 9.
- What notice and answer period does the company get? In the illustration, written notice at Month 26 gives 30 days to respond in writing. Chapter 9.
- What happens to the limitations period? In the illustration it is kept from running until Month 48. Chapter 9.
- What exposure to suspension or debarment does the company have? In the case federal contracts are $103,500,000 a year, and the decision belongs to the contracting agency. Chapter 10.
- Who is bound if the company is sold or merged? A successor that is not bound can end the obligations by changing who owes them. Chapter 10.
- Are public statements cleared first, and is there a cure? In the case the 8-K and press release are cleared first, and a contradicting statement can be repudiated within 5 business days. Chapter 11.
- Does the filing match the agreement? In the case a $36,000,000 provision booked in Year 5 meets payments of $38,582,000, so an additional charge of $2,582,000 follows at resolution. Chapter 11.
Comparison Grid
The three tables below compare three types of agreement on the same six rows. They use case figures and the case's comparison route, and they show how the same facts read under different forms. Nothing here forecasts an outcome. The figures are teaching assumptions and not market figures, and a real agreement may differ on every row.
A deferred prosecution agreement with a monitor (illustration)
| Row |
Reading |
| Filed with a court |
Yes, with a criminal information |
| Term |
36 months, counted from the later of filing or retention; the monitor is retained in Month 4, so the term ends in Month 40 |
| Monitor or reports |
Monitor selected from three candidates proposed within 20 business days; oversight cost in the case $12,000,000 a year |
| Penalty basis |
Guidelines fine range, reduced from the low end at the prosecutors' discretion |
| Breach |
Written notice, answer period, decision by the prosecutors |
| Dismissal |
Dismissal with prejudice sought after the term ends |
A deferred prosecution agreement with self-reporting (the case)
| Row |
Reading |
| Filed with a court |
Yes, at Month 0 |
| Term |
36 months, to Month 36 |
| Monitor or reports |
No monitor; work plan within 60 days, reports at Month 12, Month 24 and Month 33, certifications at Month 36 |
| Penalty basis |
30 percent off the low end of $25,760,000, giving $18,032,000 |
| Breach |
Written notice, 30 days to answer, decision by the prosecutors |
| Dismissal |
Sought with prejudice within 6 months after expiry, by Month 42 |
A non-prosecution agreement (comparison route)
| Row |
Reading |
| Filed with a court |
No, it is a letter agreement |
| Term |
30 months |
| Monitor or reports |
No monitor; the comparison route does not set the reporting terms, which a real letter would state |
| Penalty basis |
60 percent off the low end of $25,760,000, giving $10,304,000 |
| Breach |
Set by the letter; the prosecutors decide |
| Dismissal |
No charge is pending, so nothing is dismissed |
In the comparison route Ostwick would pay $5,804,000 to the US Treasury after the same foreign credit, which is $7,728,000 less than the penalty under the DPA. The route assumes a good-faith report on day 170 of Year 4, after the 120-day window and before the subpoena, that could count as a near miss under Part II. Chapter 12 assembles the full case.