This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Cyber Liability Insurance Policy by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Cyber Policy
Before a cyber policy is bound or renewed, there is a last moment when every clause can still be read, questioned and, sometimes, changed. After that moment, the wording is what it is until the next renewal, and the first real test will usually arrive on a bad day. The forty questions in this chapter are meant for that last moment. They follow the order in which a loss moves through a policy: the schedule, the first-party covers, the third-party covers, the exclusions, the money mechanics, and finally the triggers, the application and the claims conditions.
Each question is one line, followed by one sentence on why it matters and the chapter where the clause is read in full. They are written for any cyber policy, not only for the one Ridgeline Freight Brokers bought, but the case is never far away: every question below would have changed at least one number in the year that Chapter 11 worked through. A reader who can answer all forty from the wording, with the page reference next to each answer, has read the policy. A reader who cannot answer one of them has found the next question for the broker.
Nothing here is advice on whether to buy a given policy or accept a given term. The questions are a reading method; the decisions belong to the chief financial officer, the general counsel, the risk manager and the chief information security officer, with the broker's help.
Schedule and structure (questions 1 to 7)
The schedule is the policy's summary page: insuring agreements bought, limits, sublimits, retentions and waiting periods. Start here, because every later answer refers back to it.
- Which insuring agreements does the schedule show as bought? A cover that does not appear on the schedule is not in the policy, however the insuring agreement reads (Chapter 2).
- What is the policy aggregate limit, and does every insuring agreement draw from it? The aggregate is the outer wall of the policy, and in the case one event used almost all of it (Chapter 8).
- Which sublimits apply, and to which covers? A sublimit caps a cover well below the aggregate, and the schedule is where it is first visible (Chapter 2).
- Is each sublimit part of the aggregate or in addition to it? The answer decides whether a sublimit is new money or a slice of money already promised (Chapter 8).
- What is the retention, and does it apply per event, per claim or per insuring agreement? The unit of the retention decides how many times the insured pays it in one bad year (Chapter 8).
- Which endorsements are attached, and which clauses do they change? Endorsements often carry the most important changes to the printed form, and they are easy to skip (Chapter 2).
- Which terms are defined, and where are the definitions? In a cyber policy, definitions such as computer system, event and claim do much of the work of the insuring agreements (Chapter 2).
First-party covers (8 to 16)
First-party covers pay the insured's own costs and lost income. They are usually triggered by discovery and notice within the policy period.
- Does breach response require panel vendors, and what happens if the insured uses its own? The panel clause can decide whether forensic and legal costs are paid in full, in part or not at all (Chapter 3).
- Which breach response costs need the insurer's prior consent? Costs incurred before consent are often at risk, and in a crisis they arrive in the first hours (Chapter 3).
- How long is the business interruption waiting period, and is it measured in hours or as a money amount? Every hour inside the waiting period is lost income the insured carries alone, however the rest of the cover reads (Chapter 4).
- How is lost income measured, and over what period of restoration? The basis of measurement and the end of the restoration period decide the size of the largest first-party line (Chapter 4).
- Does business interruption cover non-malicious system failure as well as attacks? Many outages have no attacker, and a cover limited to security events will not respond to them (Chapter 4).
- Does dependent business interruption cover the insured's cloud and software providers, and is it limited to named ones? For a business that runs on a provider such as Tessgrove Cloud, the definition of a dependent business comes before any figure (Chapter 4).
- What do extortion and ransomware cover, and what does the policy require before a payment? Consent, sanctions screening and notice to the authorities are usually conditions of the cover, not courtesies (Chapter 5).
- Does funds transfer fraud cover a payment the insured itself made after a deceptive instruction? Social-engineering loss is often covered only under a separate agreement or sublimit, and sometimes not at all (Chapter 5).
- Does data restoration pay only to restore, or also to replace software that can no longer be obtained? The betterment line decides who pays for the newer version when the old one is gone (Chapter 7).
Third-party covers (17 to 22)
Third-party covers pay defense and damages owed to others. They usually run on a claims-made-and-reported basis after a retroactive date.
- What counts as a claim under the liability covers? A complaint or a phone call may not be a claim, and the definition decides which policy period responds (Chapter 9).
- Does network security and privacy liability cover both data exposure and the transmission of malicious code to others? The two risks can be covered under one agreement or split between several, with different limits (Chapter 6).
- Do regulatory proceedings include investigations and inquiries, or only formal actions? An inquiry can run up defense costs long before any formal action, and a narrow definition leaves them with the insured (Chapter 6).
- Are fines and penalties covered, and only where insurable under the governing law? A cover that promises fines often subjects them to an insurability condition the policy does not resolve (Chapter 6).
- What does the PCI cover pay: assessments, fees, forensic costs, or all of them? Card-industry loss has its own vocabulary, and a cover that pays one kind of assessment may not pay another (Chapter 6).
- Do defense costs erode the limit? Where they do, a long defense reduces the money left for settlement and for every later event (Chapter 8).
Exclusions (23 to 29)
Exclusions take out of cover what the insuring agreements would otherwise pay. The ones below can remove an entire event rather than a sliver.
- What does the war exclusion remove beyond armed conflict with physical force? In the worked case, the gap between a broad and a narrow exclusion is almost the whole payment of the year (Chapter 7).
- Whose statement settles attribution, and who carries the burden of proof? A clause that names the government of the state where the affected system sits as a source of evidence reads very differently from one that is silent (Chapter 7).
- Does the war exclusion allow some state operations up to a limit written inside it? A limit hidden in an exclusion is a sublimit, and it belongs on the reader's copy of the schedule (Chapter 7).
- How far does the infrastructure exclusion reach, and does it touch the insured's own cloud providers? The line between public infrastructure and a contracted vendor decides whether a provider outage is a dependent loss or an excluded one (Chapter 7).
- Is there a failure-to-maintain-security exclusion, and is it tied to named controls or to a general standard? A general standard leaves room for argument after every loss (Chapter 7).
- Does the policy treat a neglected patch by exclusion, by coinsurance or by a lower sublimit? The answer decides whether a known, unfixed flaw costs the insured part of a loss or all of it (Chapter 8).
- Are there exclusions for prior known events, contractual liability or unlawful collection of data? Exclusions of this kind can reach the very claims a privacy cover is bought for, and need reading next to the insuring agreement (Chapter 6).
Limits, retentions and coinsurance (30 to 34)
These questions turn a covered loss into a payment. They should be read in the order they apply: retention, sublimit, coinsurance, aggregate.
- How does the related-events wording group losses into one event? A broad grouping saves retentions on a long attack, but can also fold several losses under one sublimit (Chapter 8).
- Does a coinsurance share apply, and which controls trigger it? A coinsurance share tied to one missing control can shift a large part of an event back to the insured (Chapter 8).
- Does the insured's coinsurance share erode the limits? If it does not, the aggregate lasts longer, which can change what a later event receives (Chapter 8).
- Are betterment costs inside a data recovery limit or on top of it? A buyer who expects a separate pot for upgrades may find the cost already counted against the restoration limit (Chapter 8).
- Can the aggregate be reinstated after a large event during the policy period? Without reinstatement, a large early event can leave little for every later one, as the worked case shows (Chapter 8).
Triggers, application and claims (35 to 40)
The last six questions decide which policy answers, whether the policy answers at all, and on what conditions.
- Which covers run on discovery and which on claims-made-and-reported? Each trigger leaves a different gap at the end of the policy period (Chapter 9).
- What is the retroactive date, and how does it compare with the earliest date an intrusion could have begun? A recent retroactive date can cut off a claim whose cause lies years back (Chapter 9).
- What must a notice of circumstances contain, and to whom must it go? A notice that meets the clause can tie a claim made years later to the current policy period (Chapter 9).
- What extended reporting or discovery period is offered, at what price, and who may elect it? A tail priced in advance tells the buyer the cost on day one, while one left to the insurer is negotiated at the weakest moment (Chapter 9).
- Can the insurer rescind for an inaccurate application answer, and whose knowledge counts? Rescission treats the policy as if it had never existed, which turns one wrong answer into a year without cover (Chapter 9).
- Which settlements, payments and costs need prior written consent, and is consent subject to a reasonableness standard? A settlement agreed without consent can fall outside the cover, whatever its merits (Chapter 10).
Using the forty questions
The questions work best as a table kept with the policy: question number, answer, page reference, and the name of the role responsible for the answer. Where the wording answers clearly, the line is closed. Where it is silent or unclear, the line becomes a question for the broker, ideally answered in writing before binding.
Most of the questions can be answered by one reader. A handful cannot. Questions on the application and controls (27, 28, 31 and 39) need the chief information security officer. Questions on consent and counsel (8, 9 and 40) need the general counsel. Questions on the aggregate and the order of payment (2, 4, 22, 30 to 34) need the chief financial officer and the risk manager, ideally with a worked example of one large event followed by one small one.
On the reading desk
- Copy the forty questions into a three-column table: question, answer with page reference, responsible role.
- Mark each answer as clear, unclear or silent, and send the unclear and silent ones to the broker in one list.
- Re-run the case of Chapter 11 on the policy's own figures, using questions 2, 4, 5, 31 and 34 as the steps.
- Before signing the application, have the chief information security officer confirm each control answer that questions 27, 28, 31 and 39 rely on.
Key Takeaway: Forty questions, read in the order a loss travels through the policy, turn a cyber policy from a limit on a schedule into a set of known answers. In the case, three of the forty, on the war exclusion (23), coinsurance (31) and rescission (39), each move a large part of the year's payment, and one of them moves all of it. A question the wording cannot answer is the next question for the broker, before the policy is bound.