Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a CT600

Free to print: Appendix B: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any CT600, from How to Read a CT600.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a CT600 by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Appendix B: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any CT600

Use these questions in order when you review a return prepared by someone else, or when you read the returns of a target company. Each question points to the chapter that explains the rule and the case example. The list is a reading aid, not a filing procedure and not advice.

The pack and the periods

  1. Does the pack contain the return form, the supplementary pages that the company needs, the accounts and the computations, and does each part belong to the same period? See Chapter 1.
  2. Are the accounts and the computations in the structured electronic format that the filing route expects, and can you open both and read them? See Chapter 1.
  3. Does every supplementary page that is attached correspond to something in the accounts, and is there an expected page that is missing? See Chapter 1.
  4. Do the start and end dates of the return match the period shown in the accounts, and do they match the dates on the notice to deliver? See Chapter 2.
  5. If the period of account is longer than an accounting period may be, has it been split into two returns, and has trading profit been shared between them by days? See Chapters 2 and 3.

From accounts to trading profit

  1. Does the profit before tax in the computation start from the same figure as the signed accounts? See Chapter 3.
  2. Is depreciation added back in full, and is it replaced by capital allowances rather than left in the profit? See Chapter 3.
  3. Has client entertaining been added back, and has it been looked for across every ledger code, not only the one labelled entertaining? See Chapter 3.
  4. Are donations and other items that are not trading expenses added back in the computation, and relieved elsewhere on the return if they qualify? See Chapter 3.
  5. Is an accounting profit on a disposal reversed, with the disposal value dealt with in the capital allowance pools, is bank interest taken out of trading profit and carried to box 170, and is the turnover in the form split between periods in the same way as the profit? See Chapters 3 and 4.

Capital allowances

  1. Does the computation list each asset bought in the period with its date, cost and the allowance claimed, and do the dates match the invoices? See Chapter 4.
  2. If full expensing is claimed, is the asset new and of a kind that qualifies, and is the claim kept apart from the pools? See Chapter 4.
  3. Where the annual investment allowance is used, is it within the limit for the length of the period, and is any group sharing of the limit considered? See Chapter 4.
  4. Are the main pool and the special rate pool carried forward correctly from the previous computation, with disposal values deducted? See Chapter 4.
  5. Do the allowance boxes on the form add up to the total in the computation, and are the writing-down allowances reduced when the period is short? See Chapter 4.

Other income and donations

  1. Is every income line in the computation, such as interest, carried to the right box on the form? See Chapter 5.
  2. Are dividends received identified as exempt or taxable, and does the reason for the treatment appear in the file? See Chapter 5.
  3. Is any exempt distribution added to the profits to reach the augmented profits that the rates need? See Chapter 5.
  4. Is each qualifying donation paid in the period, evidenced, and deducted in the box intended for it rather than in the profit? See Chapter 5.
  5. Does the total of the profits before losses on the form equal the sum of the trading profit and the other income? See Chapter 5.

Losses and group relief

  1. Is a loss carried forward traced to the return in which it arose, and is the amount used no more than the amount available? See Chapter 6.
  2. Has the company considered whether the restriction on the use of carried-forward losses applies, and who in the group holds the deductions allowance? See Chapter 6.
  3. Is any group relief supported by a notice of consent from the surrendering company, and do the periods of the two companies overlap? See Chapter 6.
  4. Does the amount claimed on the supplementary page agree to the amount shown in the main form, and is it no larger than the profit that absorbs it? See Chapter 6.
  5. Does the surrendering company show the matching surrender in its own return, and does the loss remaining there agree to its computation? See Chapter 6.

Rates and associated companies

  1. How many associated companies does the group list show, and does that number agree to the structure chart and the registers? See Chapter 7.
  2. Have the limits been divided by the right number, and reduced for a period shorter than a full year? See Chapter 7.
  3. Are the augmented profits above, below or between the limits, and does the rate applied follow from that position? See Chapter 7.
  4. Where marginal relief applies, can you rebuild it from the formula using the profits, the augmented profits and the limits? See Chapter 7.
  5. If the period spans two financial years, are the tax lines shown separately for each, and do they add up to the total? See Chapter 7.

Loans to participators and R&D

  1. Is the company a close company, and what in the shareholdings or the control makes it so? See Chapter 9.
  2. Does the file list every loan, advance or benefit made to a participator or an associate of one, with its date and amount? See Chapter 9.
  3. Has the charge on a loan been computed at the rate for the tax year in which the loan was made, and not at a later rate? See Chapter 9.
  4. Are repayments dated and evidenced, and do they fall within the time that the rules allow before the tax is due? See Chapter 9.
  5. If R&D relief is claimed, is it claimed under the merged scheme or the intensive support route, and is the supporting notification or additional information in the pack? See Chapter 8.

Payment, enquiries and changes

  1. Is the company large for the purposes of instalments, and if it is not, has the single payment date been identified for each return? See Chapter 10.
  2. Does the amount paid agree to the self-assessment of tax shown in the return, including any tax on a loan to a participator? See Chapter 10.
  3. Was the return delivered by the filing date, and if it was late, which penalties have been charged and which could still arise? See Chapter 2.
  4. Until when can the tax authority open an enquiry into each return, and until when can the company amend it? See Chapter 11.
  5. Having read all of the above, can you trace each box of the first and second returns back to a document, and say what has changed or is announced but not yet in force? See Chapter 12.

Work through the groups in order, because each one depends on the one before it: a wrong period in the first group spoils every figure after it. Write the answer to each question in a margin note or a working paper, with the page of the computation or the document that supports it, so that another reader can follow your path.

A question you cannot answer is a finding in itself. It may mean that a document is missing from the pack, that the preparer made a judgement that is not recorded, or simply that you need to ask. Keep those questions in a separate list, and send them to the finance director or the group's external accountant before you rely on the return.

Finally, remember the limits of the list. It tells you what to look at and where the explanation sits in this book. It does not tell any company how to complete a return, which claim to make or what to pay, and it cannot replace advice from an adviser who knows the facts of the company concerned.