Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Corporate Charter and Bylaws

Free to print: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Charter and Set of Bylaws, from How to Read a Corporate Charter and Bylaws.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Corporate Charter and Bylaws by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Charter and Set of Bylaws

Forty questions stand between a reader and a decision. Before investing in a listed company, advising its board, joining it as a director or running it as an officer, these are the last things to ask of its charter and bylaws. Each one points back to the chapter that explains the mechanics, and each comes with one sentence on why it matters.

The questions follow the order of the book. They do not tell anyone what to buy, how to vote or what to adopt. They tell a reader where control sits, what it would take to move it, and who pays when things go wrong. Chapter 11 runs Kilbride Robotics, Inc. through most of them; the same questions work on any Delaware company. Read them with the two documents open side by side, the latest restated versions filed on EDGAR, and any later amendments.

A good answer to each question has three parts: the clause that answers it, the vote or threshold that applies, and the date on which that answer could change. A question that the documents leave unanswered is still answered, by the statute's default rule, and that default is worth writing down too. Some answers will favor the founder or the board, others the outside stockholders; the list does not score them. Its job is to make sure nothing is missed before a reader forms a view, and to let two companies be compared clause by clause on the same grid.

Hierarchy and capital (questions 1 to 7)

The first seven questions set the frame: which documents govern, where the company lives, and how much stock the board can issue without asking stockholders. Chapters 1 and 2 cover them.

  1. Which state is the company incorporated in, and is that state's statute the one you have read? The rest of this list is read against that state's statute, and a Texas entity and a Delaware corporation can answer it differently (Chapter 1).
  2. Are you reading the latest restated charter and bylaws, plus every amendment filed since? A single later amendment can change a vote, a threshold or a forum (Chapter 1).
  3. Where the charter and bylaws touch the same subject, do they agree? The charter prevails over the bylaws, and both must fit the statute, so a conflict is read in that order (Chapter 1).
  4. Does any stockholder agreement sit beside the charter and bylaws and grant rights they do not show? Board designation or consent rights in a separate agreement can matter as much as the charter itself (Chapter 1).
  5. How many shares of each class are authorized, and how many are outstanding? The gap is what the board can issue without a stockholder vote on the charter (Chapter 2).
  6. Is there undesignated preferred stock the board may issue with terms it sets? Blank-check preferred lets the board create a new series quickly, including for a rights plan (Chapter 2).
  7. What vote is needed to increase or decrease the authorized shares, and does any class vote separately on it? The answer decides whether one class can block new capital (Chapter 2).

Voting classes (8 to 12)

These five questions measure the distance between economic ownership and voting power. Chapter 3 holds the mechanics.

  1. How many classes of common stock are there, and how many votes does each share carry? A high-vote class can give its holder control with a minority of the economics (Chapter 3).
  2. What is the controlling holder's share of the economics and of the votes today? The gap between the two numbers is the measure of the structure (Chapter 3).
  3. When does a high-vote share convert, on transfer and to whom? Broad permitted transferees keep control within a circle; narrow ones let it leak away with each sale (Chapter 3).
  4. Is there a sunset, and is it triggered by a percentage, a date, an event or several? The sunset is the one clause that ends dual-class control, so its trigger matters more than its wording (Chapter 3).
  5. Which matters require a separate class vote? A class vote can give a small class a veto that a combined vote would not (Chapters 2 and 3).

The board (13 to 18)

Six questions on the board decide how fast an outsider could change it. Chapter 4 explains each.

  1. How is the size of the board set, and who can change it? A board that alone sets its own size can add seats or leave them empty (Chapter 4).
  2. Is the board classified, and into how many classes? A classified board means that only part of it stands for election each year (Chapter 4).
  3. Does the classification end at a date or event, or is it permanent? A board that declassifies on schedule reads very differently from one that never does (Chapter 4).
  4. Can directors be removed without cause, or only for cause? Removal only for cause closes the route of replacing directors between meetings (Chapter 4).
  5. Who fills a vacancy or a newly created seat? If the board fills them, stockholders cannot change the board through vacancies (Chapter 4).
  6. Does the controlling holder or any investor have a contractual right to designate directors? Designation rights sit outside the board article and can outlast a sunset (Chapter 1).

Stockholder action (19 to 25)

Seven questions on stockholder action decide how stockholders can move at all between annual meetings, and on what notice. Chapter 5 covers them, and Chapter 10 the information that often comes first.

  1. May stockholders act by written consent? Without it, every stockholder decision needs a meeting (Chapter 5).
  2. Who may call a special meeting, and at what threshold? The higher the threshold, the more holders an activist must assemble (Chapter 5).
  3. What is the advance notice window for nominations and proposals, and from which date is it counted? Missing the window defeats a nomination on procedure alone (Chapter 5).
  4. What information must a nominating stockholder provide, and about whom? Long disclosure lists add time and give the company grounds to reject a notice (Chapter 5).
  5. Do the bylaws refer to Rule 14a-19, and what do they require of a holder who relies on it? The bylaws may tie the company's own notice requirements to that federal rule (Chapter 5).
  6. Is there a proxy access bylaw, and on what ownership and holding terms? Proxy access lets qualifying holders put nominees in the company's own proxy materials (Chapter 5).
  7. What quorum do the charter and bylaws set, and does it differ from the statute's default? The statute never lets a quorum fall below one third of the shares entitled to vote, and a lower quorum makes it easier for a meeting to act (Chapter 5).

Amendments and votes (26 to 29)

Four questions on amendments and votes set the price of changing anything above. Chapter 6 runs the arithmetic.

  1. What vote amends each charter article, and is it measured against shares outstanding or shares voting? A threshold against shares outstanding counts every absent share as a no (Chapter 6).
  2. Can the board amend the bylaws alone, and what vote do stockholders need to amend them? Board power to amend bylaws, with a high stockholder threshold, tilts control to the board (Chapter 6).
  3. How many shares make a blocking stake, and who holds that many alone or together? A blocking stake tells you who can stop any change without winning any vote (Chapter 6).
  4. Which locks protect themselves, so that the amendment article needs the same supermajority to change? A lock that can be removed by a simple majority is no lock at all (Chapter 6).

Liability, indemnification and forum (30 to 34)

Five questions decide who pays and where disputes go. Chapters 7 and 8 explain them.

  1. Does the charter exculpate officers as well as directors, and how does it treat actions by or in the right of the corporation? Officer exculpation does not reach those actions, so the scope matters in a derivative suit (Chapter 7).
  2. Is indemnification of directors and officers mandatory, and for which tiers? A bylaw that says shall gives a right; one that says may gives the board a choice (Chapter 7).
  3. Is advancement mandatory, on what conditions and within what time? Advancement pays defense costs while a case runs, against an undertaking to repay (Chapter 7).
  4. Which courts does the forum clause name, for which claims, and who may consent to another forum? The clause decides where a dispute is heard before anyone knows what it is about (Chapter 8).
  5. Is there any fee-shifting or jury waiver language, and under which state's law is it written? Delaware forbids charter or bylaw fee shifting on internal claims, while Texas allows jury waivers for Texas entities (Chapter 8).

Takeover defenses and information (35 to 40)

The last six questions concern a bidder and a stockholder seeking records. Chapters 9 and 10 hold the detail.

  1. Has the company opted out of section 203, and if so, when did the opt-out take effect? A listed company's later opt-out takes effect only after a delay, so the date matters (Chapter 9).
  2. Does the charter rebuild a takeover freeze of its own, and on what terms? A tailor-made provision can treat insiders and outsiders differently from the statute (Chapter 9).
  3. Is a rights plan in force, and what are its trigger, purchase price and flip-in ratio? Those three terms fix how much a crossing of the line would cost a bidder (Chapter 9).
  4. How are acquiring person, beneficial ownership and acting in concert defined, and who is exempt? Broad definitions widen the plan's reach, and courts read them together (Chapter 9).
  5. When does the plan expire, and how can the board redeem it? Expiry and redemption tell you how long the defense lasts and who can switch it off (Chapter 9).
  6. What do the bylaws say about books and records demands, and how do they fit section 220 as amended? Procedure in the bylaws can shape a demand, but the right itself comes from the statute (Chapter 10).

On the reading desk

Key Takeaway: Forty questions, in seven groups, cover the whole of a charter and set of bylaws: hierarchy and capital, voting classes, the board, stockholder action, amendments, liability and forum, and takeover defenses and information. Each answer tells you who controls a decision and what it would take to change it. Asked in order, they turn two long documents into a short map of control.