Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Contract for Difference

Free to print: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any CfD, from How to Read a Contract for Difference.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Contract for Difference by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any CfD

A new CfD lands on the desk. It is not Wrayholt's: it belongs to a different generator, a different technology and perhaps a different allocation round. Next to it sits the full set of standard terms, a long document of Conditions, definitions and annexes. The reader has a day, perhaps two, to say what the contract does and where its risks sit.

The temptation is to start on page one and read to the end. That is the slowest way to understand a CfD, because the contract is not written in the order in which its questions matter. The short CfD Agreement holds the project's own figures; the standard terms hold the rules that apply to every project; the statutory notices of the round hold the parameters. A reader who knows which question to ask first, and where its answer lives, can build a picture of the contract in hours rather than days.

This chapter gives forty questions in four groups of ten. The order is deliberate. The first group fixes who and what the contract is about. The second fixes the price. The third fixes the timetable and the capacity. The fourth turns to money and risk, where the earlier answers are put to work. Each question is followed by the chapter of this book that explains it, so the checklist doubles as an index.

The questions are short on purpose. Each one should have an answer that fits on a line of a working note, with the place in the contract where the answer was found. Where a question cannot be answered from the documents on the desk, that gap is itself a finding, and it belongs at the top of the note rather than at the bottom.

The questions are written to be asked of any CfD on the version 8 terms. Where an example helps, the Wrayholt case supplies the names: Wrayholt Offshore Wind Limited as generator, Tavistane Renewables plc as sponsor, Quenmere Power Trading Limited as buyer of the power, the senior lenders through their security trustee, and the Low Carbon Contracts Company as counterparty.

Ten questions on the agreement and the parties

The first group places the contract in its world. Before reading a single price, the reader needs to know who signed, under what statute, on which version of the standard terms, and in which allocation round. Those answers decide which notices apply and therefore which parameters fill the blanks of the agreement. A CfD read against the wrong round's notices will give wrong answers to every later question, however careful the arithmetic.

These questions also identify the people outside the contract who matter to it. In the Wrayholt case, the contract is signed by Wrayholt Offshore Wind Limited and the Low Carbon Contracts Company, but Tavistane Renewables plc, Quenmere Power Trading Limited and the lenders all depend on it. The reader should know, from the start, who each of them is and which document links them to the CfD.

  1. Who is the generator, and is it a project company with a sponsor standing behind it? (Chapter 1)
  2. Is the counterparty the Low Carbon Contracts Company, and under which statute was the contract made? (Chapter 1)
  3. Which version of the standard terms applies, and does the agreement modify or switch off any Condition? (Chapter 1)
  4. What is the Agreement Date, and where in the agreement is it recorded? (Chapter 1)
  5. Which facility, technology and phase does the agreement describe? (Chapter 1)
  6. In which allocation round was the contract awarded, and in which pot did the technology compete? (Chapter 10)
  7. What administrative strike price applied to the technology in that round, and in what price base? (Chapter 10)
  8. Did a separate clearing price apply because of where the project connects? (Chapter 10)
  9. Does the contract include a Clean Industry Bonus, and where are its rules? (Chapter 10)
  10. Who buys the power under the separate route-to-market contract, and on what reference? (Chapters 1 and 3)

Ten questions on price: strike, index, reference price, difference

The second group fixes the price the generator will actually receive. A strike price on its own says little. The reader has to know its base year, how it moves with the Consumer Prices Index, which reference price it is compared with, and how the difference amount is worked out hour by hour, including in the hours when the market price falls below zero.

For an intermittent technology such as offshore wind, the reference price and the negative pricing rule carry as much weight as the strike itself. For a baseload technology, the reference price works on a different basis, as the Ardlethen Geothermal Limited example shows in Chapter 3. A reader who confuses the two will misread the contract's whole revenue line.

  1. What is the Initial Strike Price, and in what base year's prices is it stated? (Chapter 2)
  2. How does the Strike Price move with the Consumer Prices Index, and on what dates? (Chapter 2)
  3. Which index values does the indexation use, and how is the result rounded? (Chapter 2)
  4. Is the technology intermittent or baseload under the notice for its round? (Chapter 3)
  5. Which market reference price applies, and from which market is it taken? (Chapter 3)
  6. For a baseload plant, over what season is the reference price set? (Chapter 3)
  7. How is the difference amount calculated for each period, and on which measure of output? (Chapter 4)
  8. What happens to the difference amount in a period with a negative reference price? (Chapter 4)
  9. Which loss factor or multiplier adjusts the metered output before payment? (Chapter 4)
  10. In which direction does the payment run when the reference price exceeds the strike? (Chapter 4)

Ten questions on time and capacity: milestone, window, longstop, term

The third group fixes the timetable and the size of the promise. A CfD is a contract with a series of deadlines, each tied to a consequence. Miss the milestone and the contract can end. Start late and the term shortens. Build less than the required capacity and the contract can end again. The reader's task is to put every date on one line and every capacity figure in one column.

These questions are best answered with a calendar open. In the Wrayholt case, the dates run from signature in Year 1 to expiry in Year 27, and each one appears in a specific part of the agreement or the standard terms. Appendix B sets the case calendar out in full; a reader of a new contract will want to build the same calendar before turning to money.

  1. What is the Milestone Delivery Date, and how is it counted from the Agreement Date? (Chapter 5)
  2. How is the Milestone Requirement met, and which spending test or alternative applies? (Chapter 5)
  3. What must the Milestone Requirement Notice and its directors' certificate contain? (Chapter 5)
  4. What is the Initial Installed Capacity Estimate, and how far may it be reduced? (Chapter 5)
  5. What is the Required Installed Capacity, and what follows if the final figure falls short? (Chapter 5)
  6. What Final Installed Capacity is deemed if no notice is given in time? (Chapter 5)
  7. When do the Target Commissioning Window and the Target Commissioning Date fall? (Chapter 6)
  8. How long is the Longstop Period, and what is the resulting Longstop Date? (Chapter 6)
  9. From which date does the term run if the Start Date falls inside or after the window? (Chapter 6)
  10. What is the Specified Expiry Date, and how much supported output would a delay cost? (Chapter 6)

Ten questions on money and risk: billing, collateral, change in law, termination, lenders

The fourth group asks how the money moves and what could stop it. The earlier answers now become inputs: the price fixes the size of each difference amount, the timetable fixes when the payments start and stop, and the capacity fixes the volume at risk. The reader turns to billing and payment, to collateral, to the protection against changes in law and shutdowns, to termination, and finally to the way lenders read the whole.

This is the group a lender or investor will look at hardest. For Wrayholt's senior lenders and their security trustee, these questions decide how much reliance can be placed on the CfD revenue and what happens if things go wrong. For Tavistane Renewables plc as sponsor, they decide what contingent exposure sits behind the project company.

The order inside this group matters too. Billing and collateral come first because they describe the ordinary life of the contract, day after day. Change in law and shutdown come next because they describe how the contract reacts to events outside the generator's control. Termination comes last among the rules because it describes how the contract ends when the generator fails. The final question then steps back and asks what the lenders, and the direct agreement they sign with the counterparty, take from all of the answers before it.

  1. How long is the billing period, and how soon after it is the statement issued? (Chapter 7)
  2. What are the payment deadlines in each direction, and from which event does each run? (Chapter 7)
  3. Does a dispute suspend payment, and how is default interest calculated? (Chapter 7)
  4. After how many payment failures can collateral be required, and how is it sized? (Chapter 7)
  5. How is the counterparty funded, and what must it do if it expects a shortfall? (Chapter 7)
  6. Would a given change in law be discriminatory, specific or other, and was it foreseeable? (Chapter 8)
  7. What notice and certificate does a Qualifying Shutdown Event require? (Chapter 8)
  8. Which grounds allow termination before the Start Date, and does any payment follow? (Chapter 9)
  9. How is the Termination Amount built, and when would it be zero? (Chapter 9)
  10. What do the direct agreement and the lenders' model rely on, and what risks remain? (Chapter 11)

At the reading desk

Key Takeaway: A CfD reads fastest in a fixed order: first the parties, the statute, the version of the terms and the round; then the price, from the strike and its indexation to the reference price and the difference amount; then the timetable and the capacity; and only then money and risk. Forty questions in four groups of ten, each tied to a chapter, turn a long contract into a picture a reader can explain. For Wrayholt Offshore Wind Limited and its lenders, the same forty answers show where the revenue comes from and what could stop it.