Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Conservation Easement Deed

Free to print: Appendix B: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Conservation Easement Deed, from How to Read a Conservation Easement Deed.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Conservation Easement Deed by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Appendix B: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Conservation Easement Deed

Use these questions with the deed open in front of you, in the order of the groups. Each has a one-line question, a sentence on why it matters, and the chapter that explains it. The list helps you read a deed. It is not tax, legal or appraisal advice, and it cannot tell you what to sign or claim. For the whole sequence applied to one farm, see Chapter 12. Work through the groups in order, because later answers often depend on earlier ones: the purposes shape what the reserved rights can be, and the title work shapes what the lender must sign. Mark each question as answered, open or not applicable, and keep a short note of the clause number that supports the answer. Where the deed is silent on a point, treat the silence itself as the finding and raise it with the people who negotiated the deed.

Parties and Form

  1. Who is named as grantor, and does every person who owns an interest in the land sign? A missing signer leaves part of the land outside the restriction (Chapter 1).

  2. Who is the holder, and does the deed show that it is an organization allowed to hold this kind of interest? The holder's status is a condition of the whole transaction, and the deed is the first place to look (Chapter 1).

  3. Does the deed cite the state's enabling statute? That statute is the legal source of the restriction, so the deed should say which one it relies on (Chapter 1).

  4. Is the restriction stated to last forever and to bind later owners? A restriction that can lapse or that binds only the first owner is not the instrument this book describes (Chapter 1).

  5. Are the legal description and map attached, and is the whole package recorded? The exhibits define exactly what is restricted, and unrecorded pages bind no one (Chapter 1).

Conservation Purposes

  1. Which conservation purposes does the deed state, and does each describe this land? A purpose that could fit any parcel proves little about this one (Chapter 2).

  2. Does a stated purpose point to a public plan or policy, and does that plan identify this land? Outside support makes a purpose easier to explain and defend (Chapter 2).

  3. If scenic views are claimed, who can see the land, and from where? Public visibility is part of the public benefit story (Chapter 2).

  4. Do the reserved rights and permitted activities fit the stated purposes? A deed that promises habitat but allows heavy building works against itself (Chapter 2).

The Baseline Documentation Report

  1. Does the deed name the baseline report and say where it is kept? A baseline nobody can find cannot settle a dispute (Chapter 3).

  2. Does the report cover the whole property, including the areas where rights are reserved? Gaps in coverage become gaps in proof (Chapter 3).

  3. Do the photographs, aerial image, scale map and inventories match what you see on the land? A stale or generic report is a warning sign (Chapter 3).

  4. Who signed the acknowledgment, and was it signed before recording? The signatures and their timing show that both sides accepted the same starting picture (Chapter 3).

Reserved Rights

  1. Where are the farmstead area and any building envelope drawn, and can the location move without the holder's approval? A movable envelope is a larger reserved right than it looks (Chapter 4).

  2. What new buildings may be built, and of what kind and size? Open-ended wording invites disagreement about what the deed allowed (Chapter 4).

  3. Is there a cap on impervious surfaces, and what counts toward it? A cap that excludes the farmstead or farm buildings caps less than it appears to (Chapter 4).

  4. Is subdivision barred, and what does the deed say about leases, boundary changes and conveying part of the land? Division is the oldest way to defeat a restriction (Chapter 4).

Prohibited Uses

  1. Which uses are prohibited by name, and is there a general catch-all for uses that harm the purposes? Lists miss things, and a catch-all fills the gap (Chapter 5).

  2. Who owns the minerals, and does the deed bar surface extraction whoever owns them? Mineral rights held apart from the land are a classic source of conflict (Chapter 5).

  3. How does the deed treat farm practices, timber harvest and other working-land activity? The line between working land and an inconsistent use should be readable in advance (Chapter 5).

  4. Are the development rights extinguished, or only left unused? Rights that survive can be revived, or in some deeds transferred elsewhere (Chapter 5).

Amendment and Extinguishment

  1. Can the deed be amended, who must approve, and what changes does it forbid? An amendment clause shows how firmly the restriction is meant to hold (Chapter 6).

  2. What events can end the easement, and who decides? A deed that lets the parties end it privately is a different instrument from one that requires a court (Chapter 6).

  3. If the easement ends, how are proceeds shared: a fixed ratio, or a formula that subtracts later improvements? The formula decides who bears the value of what the owners add later, and a formula that subtracts improvements can put the whole deduction at risk (Chapter 6).

  4. Where must the holder's share go, and does the deed address boundary line adjustments? Proceeds should return to conservation, and boundary changes need clear limits (Chapter 6).

Mortgages and Title

  1. Is there any mortgage or lien on the land, and has title been searched? An unsearched title can hide a claim that outranks the easement (Chapter 7).

  2. Has each lender signed a subordination, and is it recorded with the deed? A subordination in a drawer does not protect the easement against a foreclosure (Chapter 7).

  3. What does the subordination say about insurance money, condemnation money and foreclosure? These terms decide who is paid first when something goes wrong (Chapter 7).

  4. What other prior interests exist, such as leases, utility easements, water rights or mineral rights, and how does the deed deal with them? Each is a limit on what the restriction can control (Chapter 7).

Appraisal and Deduction

  1. Who prepared the appraisal, and is the appraiser qualified and independent? The appraisal is the foundation of any claimed value (Chapter 8).

  2. Does the appraisal state a highest and best use, and does the value after reflect the restrictions in this deed? The appraised loss can only be as sound as these two steps (Chapter 8).

  3. Does the appraisal account for any benefit to other land the owners hold nearby? An increase in value elsewhere can reduce the amount claimed (Chapter 8).

  4. Which forms, attachments and acknowledgments go with the return, and who has signed them? Missing papers are a common reason a claimed gift is challenged (Chapter 8).

Syndicated Easements

  1. Is the donor a partnership or company with outside investors, and when did they acquire their interests? Investor structures draw special rules and attention (Chapter 9).

  2. How does the claimed value compare with what the investors paid, and what do the promotional materials say? A large gap between the two is the pattern the rules are written to catch (Chapter 9).

Stewardship and Transfers

  1. What are the holder's rights to enter and inspect, and what notice must the owners give before using a reserved right? These clauses set the rhythm of the relationship for decades (Chapter 10).

  2. What remedies does the deed give if a violation occurs, and who pays for restoration and enforcement? Clear cost allocation avoids a second dispute after the first one (Chapter 10).

  3. What happens when the land is sold: notice, fee, first refusal and limits on the holder's own transfer? The deed must work for owners and holders who have not yet met (Chapter 10).

Purchase Programs

  1. If public money paid for part of the easement, does the program add its own terms, enforcement rights or approvals? A public funder often has rights that sit beside the holder's (Chapter 11).

  2. If the transaction is part sale and part gift, is the split documented and consistent with the appraisal? The two parts are treated differently, so the paper trail has to separate them (Chapter 11).

Using the List

A deed that answers all forty questions clearly is not necessarily a good deed for every party, and a deed that leaves some open is not necessarily a bad one. The list shows where to look and what to ask. Owners can use it with their own lawyer and tax adviser before a draft is final. Land trust staff can use it as a final read before signing. Lenders, appraisers and buyers of restricted land can use the groups that touch their own role. The answers belong to the deed in front of you, not to any other.