Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Condominium Reserve Study

Free to print: Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist, from How to Read a Condominium Reserve Study.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Condominium Reserve Study by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist

Keep this list beside the study when it arrives. Each question is one line, followed by why it matters and the chapter that explains it. Work through the groups in order: the early answers shape how you read the later ones.

The report and its preparer (questions 1 to 5)

  1. Which kind of study is this: a full study, an update with a site visit, or an update without one? The kind tells you how much of the property the preparer actually looked at (chapter 1).
  2. Who prepared it, and what credential does the preparer hold? A named credential and a stated scope let you judge who stands behind the numbers (chapter 1).
  3. Who ordered the study and who supplied the records? Boards and managers shape the inputs, so the source of the inputs shapes the output (chapter 1).
  4. What does the report say it is not? A reserve study is a budgeting tool, not an engineering report or a guarantee, and a good one says so plainly (chapter 1).
  5. When was the property last visited, and how old is the data behind each page? Old inspection notes carry old assumptions into current numbers (chapter 1).

The component list (questions 6 to 11)

  1. Is every major common component on the list, and is each defined clearly enough to price? Anything missing from the list is missing from the plan (chapter 2).
  2. Does each component show a useful life, a remaining life and a replacement cost? Those three inputs drive every balance and every contribution that follows (chapter 2).
  3. Is the effective age consistent with the useful life and the remaining life? Effective age is simply useful life minus remaining life, so a mismatch points to a typing or logic error (chapter 2).
  4. Where a component carries no replacement reserve, does the report explain why? A blank can mean the item lasts beyond the study horizon or that its life cannot be set, and the reader should be told which (chapter 2).
  5. Are recurring repair cycles separated from one-time replacements? A cycle that repeats, such as concrete restoration, needs its own schedule instead of a single date (chapter 2).
  6. Are repair allowances for deferred maintenance labeled as such? An allowance is a budgeted placeholder, not a quote or a finding (chapter 2).

Fund strength (questions 12 to 16)

  1. What is the fully funded balance, and how is it built? It is the sum, component by component, of cost times effective age divided by useful life (chapter 3).
  2. What is the actual reserve balance, and does it match the books? A study that starts from the wrong balance gives a wrong picture of everything after it (chapter 3).
  3. What is the percent funded, and is it shown for the whole fund and for each pool? One overall number can hide a weak pool behind a strong one (chapter 3).
  4. Does the report treat the percent funded as a measure of strength rather than a grade? It describes how far the fund stands from its fully funded balance, and it does not predict whether a special assessment will come (chapter 3).
  5. Did earlier waivers or underfunding cause the shortfall, and does the report say so? Knowing the cause tells you whether the gap is a one-time catch-up or a habit (chapter 3).

The funding plan (questions 17 to 23)

  1. Which funding plan is the report recommending: baseline, threshold, full, or another? Each plan trades contribution size against risk differently (chapter 4).
  2. Is the recommended plan the one the board actually adopted? Reports often show several plans, and the budget may follow a different one (chapter 4).
  3. What is the stated goal of the plan, in plain words? A plan with no stated goal cannot be judged as a success or a failure (chapter 4).
  4. Does the plan use a straight-line method or a pooled method, and is that choice explained? The two methods spread the same cost across owners in very different patterns (chapter 4).
  5. What inflation and interest assumptions does the plan use? These two assumptions move every future year, so you should see them written out (chapter 4).
  6. In which years does the pool come closest to zero, and is the low point inside the table you were shown? A ten-year table can hide a low point that falls just after it (chapter 4).
  7. Does the plan show the year-by-year contribution, spending and ending balance for every pool? Without the full run of years you cannot test the plan yourself (chapter 4).

Florida's SIRS rules (questions 24 to 31)

  1. Does the association need a structural integrity reserve study, and by what deadline? The answer depends on the building and on the association's status (chapter 5).
  2. Who signed the SIRS, and does the signer hold the role the rules require? The signing role is a rule of the statute, not a courtesy (chapter 5).
  3. Is each required SIRS item covered, one by one? A missing item is a gap the report must close or explain (chapter 6).
  4. For each item, does the report give a remaining life and a replacement cost, or explain a blank? A blank with no reason is a question to put to the preparer (chapter 6).
  5. Does the report use the state form, and are its entries consistent with the main study? Two documents describing one building should agree (chapter 6).
  6. Is the SIRS kept apart from the non-SIRS components in the numbers? Mixing the two hides which money is subject to the stricter rules (chapter 6).
  7. Is the study current under the update rules? A stale study is a reporting problem even when its figures look reasonable (chapter 6).
  8. Is the milestone inspection used as an input, and is its source named? An inspection finding that does not reach the study leaves the study incomplete (chapter 9).

Funding choices and the budget (questions 32 to 36)

  1. Does the operating budget carry the reserve contribution the adopted plan calls for? A plan on paper and a budget line in a different amount are two different decisions (chapter 7).
  2. Is any waiver or reduction proposed, and does the law still allow it for the items concerned? Rules for SIRS items differ from rules for other reserves (chapter 7).
  3. Is the reserve money locked to its purpose, and does anything in the plan treat it as spendable? Reserve money has limits on what it may be used for (chapter 7).
  4. If a special assessment is needed, how large is it and how is it split across owners? The study and the budget should tell the same story about the gap (chapter 8).
  5. If the association borrows, who repays, over how long, and from which source? A loan moves the cost into future assessments, and the plan should show that (chapter 8).

The buyer and the lender (questions 37 to 40)

  1. What would a buyer learn from the percent funded, the plan and the special assessment history? Those three items tell a buyer what to ask the association (chapter 11).
  2. What does a lender look for in the reserve study and budget? A lender reads for adequacy of reserves and for signs of deferred work (chapter 11).
  3. Does the study differ from a form used in another state, and does the reader know which rules apply? Not every state asks for the same document, and Nevada's summary is one example (chapter 10).
  4. Is there a question this study cannot answer, and who can? The study cannot judge whether a building is sound, and that question belongs to licensed engineers (chapter 9).

How to use the list

Mark each question as answered, partly answered or open. An open question is not a fault in the study: it is a question to put to the preparer, the manager or the association's attorney before the board votes on the budget.

Expect some answers to sit in the cover pages, some in the component list and some only in the notes at the back. A study that makes you hunt for the answer to question 7 or question 22 has told you something about its design. Ask for a version that shows the inputs and the full run of years in one place.

Some questions apply to every association, and some apply only in Florida or only to a building of a given kind. If a question does not apply, write down why, so the next treasurer can see that the omission was deliberate.

Keep the filled-in list with the study in the association's records. When the next update arrives, answer the same forty questions again and compare. Changes between the two sets of answers show you where the plan, the building or the preparer's assumptions have moved. None of this is legal, engineering, financial or insurance advice: the list helps you read the study, and the professionals decide what the findings mean.