Free companion page
Free to print: Appendix A: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions, from How to Read a Collective Bargaining Agreement.
This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Collective Bargaining Agreement by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
Keep the agreement open beside this list and answer each question from its text. Where the text is silent, write down the silence, because silence is an answer too. Each question carries a one-sentence reason and points to the chapter that explains the rule. The list is a reading aid, not legal advice, and it takes no side between employer and union.
Who are the named parties, and does each signature block match the preamble? Why it matters: an agreement binds the entities that actually sign it, so a missing plant, parent company or employer association member changes who is covered (Chapter 2).
Which union, and which local, is recognized as the representative? Why it matters: recognition is the source of every other right in the document, and the exact name and local number show which body holds the bargaining rights (Chapter 2).
How is the bargaining unit described: by job titles, by department, by location, or by some mix of the three? Why it matters: the description decides whose wages, seniority and grievances the agreement governs, and a loose description is where later disputes about coverage begin (Chapter 2).
Which groups are excluded, and is the list of exclusions closed or open ended? Why it matters: supervisors, office staff and guards are commonly left out, and the wording shows whether a new kind of job falls inside or outside the unit by default (Chapter 2).
How does the agreement treat a new classification, department or location? Why it matters: plants change, and a clause that says nothing leaves both sides to argue about coverage each time work is reorganized (Chapter 2).
What else forms part of the bargain besides the main articles: wage schedules, side letters, memoranda, letters of understanding? Why it matters: appendices and side agreements are part of the bargain, and a reader who skips them can miss the sentence that settles the question (Chapter 1).
What kind of union security clause is used, and does the operative sentence require what the article heading suggests? Why it matters: labels such as union shop or maintenance of membership describe a family of clauses, and what an employee must actually do is set by the sentence beneath the label (Chapter 2).
How are dues collected and passed on: on what written authorization, from which paycheck, and by what date to the union? Why it matters: checkoff is a payroll process with its own timing and paperwork, and its terms affect both the union's cash flow and the employer's administrative work (Chapter 2).
What does the agreement say about employees who choose not to become full members? Why it matters: the answer shows how the clause is meant to operate within the limits the law places on what can be required, which Chapter 2 sets out.
Does the management rights clause list specific rights, state a general reservation, or do both? Why it matters: a list and a general reservation are read differently, and each side tends to read the choice of words in its own interest (Chapter 3).
Is there a zipper clause, and what does it say about subjects the agreement does not mention? Why it matters: it declares the written text the entire bargain and can close the door to claims based on earlier promises or unwritten habits, and some versions also waive bargaining during the term on covered subjects (Chapter 3 and Appendix B, clause 2).
Does the text keep, limit or end established practices and benefits that are not written in it? Why it matters: unwritten routines can matter as much as written ones, and a savings sentence or a zipper sentence changes how they are treated (Chapter 3).
Where is the wage schedule, and is pay set by classification, by step, by length of service, or by a combination? Why it matters: the schedule is the base of every cost calculation, and you need to know which employee sits on which line (Chapter 4).
What general increase applies in each year of the term, and on what date does each take effect? Why it matters: an increase effective midyear costs less in its first year than one effective on day one, so the dates drive the cost of the whole term (Chapter 4).
Is any increase paid as a lump sum instead of being added to the hourly rate? Why it matters: a lump sum leaves the base untouched unless the text says otherwise, which changes what overtime, benefits and later increases are built on (Chapter 4).
What premium pay exists: shift differential, call-in pay, holiday work, weekend work, report pay? Why it matters: premiums ride on top of the rate, depend on the schedule actually worked, and are easy to leave out of a cost estimate (Chapter 4).
Does any increase apply retroactively, and to which employees? Why it matters: retroactive pay creates a block of back pay at signing, and the text must say who receives it, including anyone who has since left the unit (Chapter 4).
How does the cost per hour worked differ from the wage rate on the schedule? Why it matters: the employer's cost includes benefit contributions and paid time not worked, and spreading them over hours actually worked gives a larger figure than the rate itself (Chapter 4).
Which items move automatically when wage rates move: overtime, vacation pay, holiday pay, contribution amounts? Why it matters: linked items multiply the cost of an increase, while unlinked items stay fixed as rates rise (Chapter 4).
What are the normal hours and the workweek, and at what point does overtime pay begin? Why it matters: the trigger may be daily, weekly or both, and it defines when the premium rate applies under the agreement (Chapter 5).
How is overtime offered: by seniority, by rotation, by volunteer list, or by equalization of charged hours? Why it matters: the method decides who gets the extra hours and the extra pay, and it is a frequent subject of grievances (Chapter 5).
How are refused or missed offers charged, and what spread between employees is tolerated? Why it matters: charging refused hours as if worked is a common design, and the tolerance shows how much imbalance the parties accept before catch-up offers begin (Chapter 5).
How is seniority defined: by plant, department or classification, counted from what date, and lost in what circumstances? Why it matters: the unit of seniority decides who is protected in a layoff, and the loss rules decide when that protection ends (Chapter 6).
In what order are layoffs made, and what bumping rights does a displaced employee have? Why it matters: the order and the bumping path decide how many people are affected beyond the positions that are cut (Chapter 6).
How long do recall rights last, and how must the employer notify a laid-off employee? Why it matters: recall language usually ends in a deadline, and a missed notice can end a person's rights (Chapter 6).
What standard governs discipline and discharge, and where in the agreement is it written? Why it matters: just cause may be stated in one short sentence or built across several articles, and it is the standard an arbitrator later applies (Chapter 7).
Does the agreement set steps of progressive discipline, and when may a step be skipped? Why it matters: steps tell both sides what to expect for a first offense, and the exceptions for serious misconduct show where the steps stop (Chapter 7).
How long do warnings and suspensions stay active on a record? Why it matters: a clause that lets old discipline expire limits what can be counted in a later case (Chapter 7).
What rights does an employee have to representation in a meeting that may lead to discipline? Why it matters: the agreement may add notice or timing rules, and that meeting is often where a later grievance takes shape (Chapter 7).
What counts as a grievance, who may file it, and where does the first step start? Why it matters: a narrow definition keeps some disputes out of the procedure, while a broad one brings in nearly every complaint (Chapter 8).
What are the time limits at each step, and what is the consequence if a side misses one? Why it matters: many agreements enforce limits as written, and the consequence of a missed deadline differs from one text to another (Chapter 8).
How is the arbitrator selected, who pays, does the text call the award final and binding, and is there an expedited track? Why it matters: selection and cost rules shape how often cases reach a hearing, and a quicker track changes the economics of small cases (Chapter 8).
Which benefits does the agreement itself set out, and which does it leave to plan documents? Why it matters: where the agreement refers to a plan document, the answer to a benefit question sits in a second text that must be read too (Chapter 9).
If a multiemployer fund provides a benefit, who sets the contribution rate and the base on which it is paid? Why it matters: the contribution base unit, such as an hour worked, drives the employer's cost and the fund's income (Chapter 9).
Which hours count toward contributions: straight time only, overtime as well, paid leave? Why it matters: the answer links the overtime and scheduling rules of Chapter 5 to the benefit cost described in Chapter 9.
What does the text say about leaving a fund, or about the employer's obligations if the plant closes or work moves? Why it matters: a multiemployer plan may attach a charge to an employer's exit, so the language on participation and exit deserves a slow read (Chapters 9 and 10).
What are the effective and expiration dates, and are there reopeners during the term? Why it matters: the dates frame the bargaining calendar, and a reopener lets named subjects be bargained before the agreement ends (Chapter 11).
Is there an evergreen clause, and what notices does it require? Why it matters: automatic renewal turns on notices given inside a stated window, and missing the window changes what the next term looks like (Chapter 11).
What does the text say about sale of the business, subcontracting and closing a plant? Why it matters: these clauses decide what commitments follow the work when it moves or changes hands (Chapter 10).
Which promises continue after expiration: the no-strike promise, grievance arbitration, checkoff, benefit contributions? Why it matters: some provisions end with the agreement and others are treated differently, and the text and the law together answer which is which (Chapters 10 and 11).
When all forty answers are written down, put them beside the wage schedule and the dates. Gaps in the answers show where the agreement is silent, and silence is where each side's reading begins to differ.