Free companion page
Companion page: How to Read a China VIE Structure
Free to print: Appendix B: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions and the Contract Grid ; How the fee is set: discretion, formulas, all of net income, from How to Read a China VIE Structure.
This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a China VIE Structure by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
Appendix B: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions and the Contract Grid
Use this appendix with an annual report on Form 20-F open beside it. The grid comes first and shows the six documents in one view. The forty questions follow, in six groups, and each one points to the chapter that explains it. The case company, Lanyuan Mobility Holdings Ltd., is used for examples only. Nothing here is legal, investment, tax or accounting advice.
The Contract Grid
In the case, all six documents were signed together in week 1 of Year 1, are governed by PRC law, and send disputes to arbitration in Beijing.
| Document |
Who signs |
What it gives the listed company |
| Exclusive business cooperation agreement |
The WFOE and the VIE |
A right to the VIE's profit through service fees, and a say over their price |
| Exclusive option agreement |
The WFOE, the VIE and each shareholder |
A call on the VIE's equity, to be bought by the WFOE or its designee |
| Equity pledge agreement |
The WFOE and each shareholder |
Security over the VIE's equity for the obligations in the other documents |
| Power of attorney |
Each shareholder, in favor of the WFOE |
The voting rights and other shareholder rights, exercised by the WFOE |
| Loan agreement |
The WFOE and each shareholder |
A link between the shareholders' paid-in capital and the WFOE, repayable by transfer |
| Spousal consent letter |
The spouse of each shareholder |
A promise not to claim the equity and to accept the other five documents |
Here the WFOE is Lanyuan Information Technology (Beijing) Co., Ltd., the VIE is Beijing Lanyuan Network Co., Ltd., and the shareholders are the founder and chief executive officer and the co-founder and chief technology officer.
Structure and Exhibits (Questions 1 to 6)
- Does the exhibit list in the annual report show all six kinds of document for each VIE? Why: a missing document leaves a gap in control or in security that the narrative may not mention. See Chapter 2.
- Does each exhibit name the same WFOE, VIE and shareholders as the organizational chart in Item 4? Why: a change of name or of holder between chart and exhibit is the first sign of a re-papered structure. See Chapter 2.
- Which license does the VIE hold, and which activity needs it? Why: the license is the reason for the whole structure, and in the case the internet content provider license stays in Beijing Lanyuan Network Co., Ltd. See Chapter 1.
- Are the documents dated, and were they signed together or one by one? Why: signing dates show whether control existed from the start, and in the case all six were signed in week 1 of Year 1. See Chapter 2.
- Were any documents amended and restated, and does the list say which version is current? Why: the latest version, not the first, governs what the company says it controls today. See Chapter 2.
- Does the text of Item 4 describe the contracts the way the exhibits read? Why: a gap between the narrative and the exhibit is a reason to read the exhibit in full. See Chapter 2.
Service Fees and Cash (Questions 7 to 13)
- Who sets the service fee, and can the setting party change it? Why: a fee set by one side is a pricing right, not a market price. See Chapter 3.
- Is the fee tied to profit, to revenue, to hours or to nothing? Why: the basis shows how much of the VIE's result the WFOE can take. In the case it was 95 percent of the VIE's profit before the fee. See Chapter 3.
- What did the fee come to in the first full year, and what is left in the VIE? Why: the VIE still has to pay staff and meet its license duties. In the case, the Year 2 fee was RMB 68,400,000. See Chapter 3.
- How and when is the fee paid, and may the WFOE set off other debts? Why: payment terms and set-off decide how fast cash leaves the VIE. See Chapter 3.
- Who owns the intellectual property and data the VIE creates? Why: if the VIE owns them, they can be lost with the license; if the WFOE owns them, they sit in the group. See Chapter 3.
- What VAT applies to the fee, and who bears it? Why: the tax is a cost on the route of the cash. In the case, VAT at 6 percent on the Year 2 fee was RMB 4,104,000. See Chapter 8.
- What route does cash follow from the VIE to the listed company, and which steps need a tax or foreign exchange process? Why: each step on the route can slow or reduce the cash that reaches the holding company. See Chapter 8.
Option and Pledge (Questions 14 to 21)
- Who holds the option, and who may the WFOE name as designee? Why: the designee decides who could end up with the equity. In the case, Lanyuan's chief financial officer was the designee. See Chapter 4.
- What share of the VIE does the option cover, and can it be used in parts? Why: a partial call can move control one shareholder at a time. In the case, the option was used over the co-founder's 30 percent. See Chapter 4.
- What is the exercise price, and does the contract link it to a legal minimum? Why: a price at the legal minimum keeps the call cheap, but the minimum can change with the law. See Chapter 4.
- What notice or conditions does exercise need? Why: conditions that cannot be met make the call hard to use in practice. See Chapter 4.
- Is the price paid in cash or set off against the loan? Why: a set-off moves no cash and may leave the nominee with nothing. In the case, RMB 3,000,000 against RMB 3,000,000. See Chapters 4 and 6.
- Which obligations does the pledge secure? Why: a pledge secures only what it names, so a narrow list leaves some duties unsecured. See Chapter 5.
- Is the pledge registered, where, and when? Why: registration with the market regulation authority is what a reader can check against the signing date. See Chapter 5.
- How is the pledge released, and is a new one made when equity moves? Why: a release followed by a new pledge should leave no gap in security. See Chapter 5.
Proxy, Loan and Consent (Questions 22 to 27)
- What rights does the power of attorney cover, and for how long? Why: the wider and longer the grant, the closer the WFOE is to full control of votes. See Chapter 6.
- Who is the agent, and can the WFOE replace that person? Why: control that depends on one named person can fail when the person leaves. See Chapter 6.
- Does the power of attorney bind a successor shareholder? Why: without that, a sale, a gift or an inheritance could remove the votes. See Chapter 6.
- Is the loan repayable only by transferring equity? Why: if cash repayment is possible, a shareholder could repay and keep the equity. See Chapter 6.
- Did the spouse of every shareholder sign a consent letter, and what does it cover? Why: a missing letter leaves a family claim open. See Chapter 6.
- What happens to the arrangements if a marriage ends or a shareholder dies? Why: these are the events that most often put equity in new hands. See Chapters 6 and 11.
Consolidation, Tax and Filings (Questions 28 to 34)
- On what grounds does the company say it is the primary beneficiary of the VIE? Why: consolidation rests on the company's judgment about power and benefit, and the grounds should match the contracts. See Chapter 7.
- How much of the group's revenue and assets does the company say sit in the VIE? Why: the larger the share, the more an investor depends on the contracts. See Chapter 7.
- How does the company describe the tax on service fees and on dividends? Why: tax on each step shapes how much cash reaches the holding company. See Chapter 8.
- Does the company discuss transfer pricing risk on the fee? Why: a fee that takes nearly all profit may be questioned by a tax authority. See Chapter 8.
- What does the company say about the statutory reserve and limits on moving cash out? Why: reserves and foreign exchange rules hold back part of the cash. See Chapter 8.
- Has the company described a filing with the CSRC, and when it was made? Why: the filing regime applies to companies that list abroad through this kind of structure. See Chapter 10.
- What does the company say about data and cybersecurity rules that affect the VIE? Why: these rules can apply to the VIE as the holder of user data. See Chapter 10.
Disputes and Exit Risks (Questions 35 to 40)
- Which law, forum and seat do the documents choose? Why: the forum decides where a dispute begins. In the case, PRC law and arbitration in Beijing. See Chapter 9.
- Which remedies do the documents name, and what does the company say about enforcing them? Why: a remedy on paper is worth only what the company says it can obtain. See Chapter 9.
- Does the company say the arrangements have been tested in a court? Why: a company that says they have not been tested is telling the reader that outcomes are uncertain. See Chapter 9.
- Who holds the seals, the license and the post of legal representative? Why: whoever holds these can act for the VIE even if a dispute is under way. See Chapter 11.
- What does the company say about the HFCAA and its auditor? Why: the auditor of a company with operations in mainland China is part of the risk the company declares. See Chapter 11.
- What does the company say would follow if a regulator found the arrangements did not comply, or a nominee stopped performing? Why: this is the company's own statement of its worst case, to be read as declared and not as a forecast. See Chapter 11.
How to Use the List
Work through the groups in order, and write the answer to each question next to the page of the filing where you found it. A question with no answer in the filing is a finding in its own right. Do not score the list or read a count of answered questions as a rating of the company: the aim is a complete reading of what the company says, and the chapters explain how to weigh each answer.
How the fee is set: discretion, formulas, all of net income
The fee clause is the most important sentence in the whole VIE structure for an equity investor. It decides how much of the VIE's profit moves to the WFOE and, through the WFOE and Hong Kong, toward the listed company.
Filings describe three broad approaches. The education company's 2026 annual report says its VIEs pay annual service fees in an amount at the WFOE's discretion. An e-commerce company's annual report for 2025, filed in 2026, says its VIEs pay service fees equal to all of their net income. The same e-commerce company adds that its WFOEs may adjust the fee at their sole discretion. A third approach is a formula, such as a percentage of revenue or of profit; the case uses one.
Each approach says something different to a reader.
A discretionary fee gives the WFOE a pricing right. It can set the fee high or low, year by year, to suit the group's needs. This flexibility is useful to the group, and it is also the reason a reader should look for any limit on the discretion: a cap, a reference to the services actually rendered, or a requirement that the VIE keep enough cash to operate.
A fee equal to all net income is a sweep. It aims to leave the VIE with nothing beyond what it needs to keep running. The reader should check how "net income" is defined, whether losses carried from earlier years count, and whether the clause speaks of the VIE's own accounts or of some adjusted figure.
A formula is the most transparent, but it can also be the least flexible. If the formula is a percentage of profit, the fee moves with the VIE's performance. If it is a percentage of revenue, the fee can exceed profit in a weak year.
In the case, the WFOE sets the Year 2 fee at 95 percent of the VIE's profit before the fee. The figures run as follows.
| Year 2 item |
RMB |
Note |
| VIE revenue |
800,000,000 |
Platform revenue |
| Operating costs before fee |
728,000,000 |
All VIE costs |
| Profit before the fee |
72,000,000 |
Base for the fee |
| Service fee (95 percent) |
68,400,000 |
Set by the WFOE |
Taxes on the fee are not the subject of this chapter: in the case, VAT at 6 percent on the fee comes to RMB 4,104,000, and Chapter 8 treats the tax side of the cash path.
An example clause written for this book shows how a pricing right can be drafted:
"For each financial year, the Company shall pay the Service Provider a service fee in an amount determined by the Service Provider, which may be up to the whole of the Company's profit before that fee. The Service Provider may adjust the fee at any time by written notice."
The reader's questions are simple. Who decides? On what base? How often? And can the VIE object? In most filings, and in this example, the answer to the last question is no.