Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Chapter 11 Plan of Reorganization and Disclosure Statement

Free to print: Appendix B: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions, With a Comparison Grid, from How to Read a Chapter 11 Plan of Reorganization and Disclosure Statement.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Chapter 11 Plan of Reorganization and Disclosure Statement by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Appendix B: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions, With a Comparison Grid

Keep this list beside the plan and the disclosure statement on a first read. Each question is followed by one sentence on why it matters and the chapter that explains it. The answers belong to the document in your hands, so write them in the margin. The grid at the end lets you set three plans side by side.

The documents and the calendar

  1. Who filed the plan and the disclosure statement, and is this the latest version? Amended versions can move classes, amounts and releases, so a stale copy misleads (Chapter 1).
  2. Which entities are debtors, and does the plan treat them together or separately? A plan that merges estates for distribution changes who shares in which assets (Chapter 1).
  3. Has the court approved the disclosure statement, and on what date? That date starts the solicitation calendar for everything that follows (Chapter 1).
  4. What are the voting record date and the voting deadline? Only holders on the record date vote, and a ballot that arrives late may not be counted (Chapter 3).
  5. What has been left for the plan supplement, and when is it due? New governance, exit credit terms and the contract lists often sit there, so a vote can precede the details (Chapters 1 and 7).
  6. Is there a restructuring support agreement, who signed it, and what deadlines does it set? Its milestones drive the whole calendar and can end the deal if they are missed (Chapter 9).

Classes and treatment

  1. Which classes exist, and which are impaired and which unimpaired? Impairment decides who votes and who is presumed to accept (Chapter 2).
  2. In which class does each of your claims or interests sit, and why? Two claims of similar size can land in different classes with different recoveries (Chapter 2).
  3. What does each class receive: cash, new debt, shares, trust interests or nothing? The form of payment matters as much as the headline amount (Chapters 2 and 4).
  4. Which classes are deemed to reject or presumed to accept, and are they asked to vote? These classes do not return ballots, yet the confirmation tests still look at them (Chapter 2).
  5. What do secured lenders get in takeback debt, and on what rate, term and security? New debt is only worth what its terms and its borrower can support (Chapter 4).
  6. Is there a convenience class, and what are its threshold and election rights? Small holders trade a smaller payment for speed, and the line decides who qualifies (Chapter 2).
  7. How are intercompany claims, intercompany interests and subordinated claims treated? These classes are not solicited, but their treatment shapes the value passing up and down the group (Chapter 2).

Voting and confirmation

  1. Which classes vote, and what share of amount and of number does each need to accept? A class can fail on either measure, so read both (Chapter 3).
  2. How are disputed, assigned and temporarily allowed claims counted for voting? The count can change who carries a class (Chapter 3).
  3. How do holders of notes through brokers vote, and who prepares the master ballot? Beneficial holders vote through nominees, and a missed step can void a ballot (Chapter 3).
  4. What does the liquidation analysis assume, and do the figures look reasonable? It is the yardstick for the best interests test (Chapter 3).
  5. Does the plan ask to be confirmed over a rejecting class, and which tests does it invoke? Confirmation over a rejection is possible only if the plan meets additional conditions (Chapter 3).
  6. Does any class below a rejecting class receive or keep anything? That question tests the plan's treatment of junior classes (Chapters 3 and 5).
  7. Do similar claims receive different treatment, and how does the plan justify it? Differences between classes draw the objections that matter most (Chapter 3).

Value, recoveries and new money

  1. What range of enterprise value does the disclosure statement use, and what projections and multiples support it? Every recovery figure flows from this range (Chapter 5).
  2. How do recoveries change at the low and high ends of the range? A narrow-looking table can hide a wide swing for the class in the middle (Chapter 5).
  3. Which class is the fulcrum class? That class usually decides who ends up owning the company (Chapter 5).
  4. Is there a rights offering, who may subscribe, and at what price relative to plan equity value? The discount is a transfer of value to those who can take part (Chapter 5).
  5. Who backstops the offering, what is the premium, and is it paid in cash or shares? The premium is paid for taking risk, and it dilutes other holders if paid in shares (Chapter 5).
  6. How much funded debt remains at emergence, and what is it as a multiple of projected earnings? Leverage decides how much value the new equity actually holds (Chapters 4 and 5).
  7. How large is the management incentive plan, and do the recovery tables show results before and after it? Later grants of shares dilute every holder, including those who voted for the plan (Chapter 7).

Releases, exculpation and injunction

  1. Who releases whom: the debtors, the estates, or creditors giving releases directly? Each type has a different source of authority and a different reach (Chapter 6).
  2. Is the third-party release opt-in or opt-out, and how is the choice made? Does a vote to accept count as opting in, or only a checked box or a returned form? The form decides how many holders end up bound (Chapter 6).
  3. Who is a releasing party, and are abstaining holders included? Silence can mean consent under one form and nothing under another (Chapter 6).
  4. Who is covered by the exculpation clause, for which acts, and for what period? Its scope is usually narrower than a release and tied to conduct during the case, and how far it may reach is contested (Chapter 6).
  5. What does the injunction prohibit, and is it tied to the release? An injunction can make a release effective in practice (Chapter 6).
  6. What did the released parties pay or give in return? A release is easier to assess when the consideration is visible (Chapter 6).

Claims, effective date, tax and trusts

  1. Which claims sit outside the classes, and how are they paid? Administrative, priority tax and professional fee claims must be funded before the plan goes live (Chapter 8).
  2. How much cash is needed on the effective date, and do sources equal uses? A gap here is a gap in the whole plan (Chapter 9).
  3. What conditions must be met before the effective date, and who can waive them? A waiver right is a power to change the closing standard (Chapter 9).
  4. What is the disputed claims reserve, and how is leftover cash returned to holders? Reserve size sets what undisputed holders receive first (Chapter 8).
  5. What are the cure costs on assumed contracts, and what rejection damages follow for rejected leases? Both enter the cash needs and the general unsecured pool (Chapter 8).
  6. What does the tax section say about cancelled debt, lost tax attributes and the annual limit after an ownership change? These items affect what the reorganized company keeps (Chapter 10).
  7. What does the litigation trust hold, how is it funded, who controls it, and who benefits? Trust interests can be a large part of a recovery for unsecured creditors (Chapter 11).

The comparison grid

Copy the table below into a sheet and add one column for each plan you are comparing. Fill each cell with the page reference and a short note. Twelve rows are enough to see how three plans differ in structure.

Feature Where it sits in the plan or disclosure statement What to compare
Classes and voting groups Classification article; the voting summary Number of classes, which are impaired, which vote
Treatment of the senior secured class Treatment article; the summary table Form of payment, new debt terms, share of equity
Takeback debt and exit facility Plan supplement; sources and uses Amount, rate, maturity, leverage at emergence
Enterprise value range Valuation section of the disclosure statement Low, midpoint and high values, multiple, projections
Recovery by class Recovery table; liquidation analysis Percentages at each end of the range, versus liquidation
Rights offering and backstop Rights offering article; backstop terms Size, discount, premium, termination rights
Third-party release Release article; the ballot Opt-in or opt-out, releasing parties, carve-outs
Exculpation and injunction Release article; injunction article Covered persons, covered period, exceptions
New equity and governance Plan supplement; governance article Share count, board seats, incentive plan reserve
Claims outside the classes Article on unclassified claims; cash uses Amounts, timing, who funds them
Effective date conditions Conditions article; support agreement List of conditions, waivers, deadlines, outside date
Trust and reserve Trust agreement; disputed claims article Funding, assets held, reserve size, return of excess