This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from The Captive Insurance Handbook by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
Appendix A: The Captive Toolkit: 12 Checklists
These twelve checklists turn the chapters into working tools. Each one is a set of questions or checks that a risk manager, a captive manager or a first-year analyst can carry into a meeting. They are general and undated: they do not replace the advice of an independent actuary, outside counsel, the tax advisers or the domicile regulator's staff. Where an item names a layer of the Northvale case, it does so only as an example of the kind of layer the question is about. Use the lists as a starting point, cross out what does not apply, and add the questions your own program raises.
1. Loss data for a feasibility study
- Do we have at least five years of loss runs for every line the captive might retain, valued at the same date?
- Does each loss run show paid losses, case reserves and claim counts separately, by accident year?
- Are the large losses listed one by one, with the cause, the date and the amount, so the actuary can decide how to treat them?
- Have deductibles and self-insured retentions been added back, so the data shows the whole loss and not only the part the insurer paid?
- Do we have exposure data for each year, such as payroll, revenue, vehicle counts, property values and units sold, so losses can be put on a common basis?
- Which sites, subsidiaries or acquired businesses are in the data, and which have joined or left during the period?
- Are the loss runs from the insurer, the third-party administrator and the broker consistent with each other?
- Who inside the company confirmed that open claims are complete and that nothing is missing from the files?
- Do we know which policy terms changed during the period, such as limits, exclusions and deductibles, that make older years harder to compare?
2. Questions for the actuary
- What data did you receive, what did you leave out, and what did you adjust before projecting?
- Which loss development method did you use for each line, and why that one?
- How did you choose the trend, and what happens to expected losses if the trend is higher or lower?
- What is the range around expected losses, and what does the range say about the worst year in the study?
- How did you treat large losses: capped, excluded or kept in full?
- How long is the payment pattern for each line, and how sure are you of the tail?
- Which assumptions would you most like to test with more data?
- What would you need from us each year to update the projection and to sign the actuarial opinion?
- Where does your work stop, and which parts of the pro forma statements are our assumptions and not yours?
3. Comparing domiciles
- Which domiciles allow the type of captive we are considering, and which allow the lines we want to write?
- What is the minimum capital and surplus, and does it have to be paid in cash or can part of it be a letter of credit?
- What are the premium tax rules, the minimums and the maximums, and how do they apply to reinsurance and to direct premium?
- What are the investment rules: which assets count toward surplus and which do not?
- How long does the regulator usually take to review an application, and who in the office is the point of contact?
- What does the regulator require each year: annual statement, audited accounts, actuarial opinion, examination?
- Which changes need prior approval, such as a dividend, a new line of business or a change of owner?
- Is there a local presence requirement, such as a registered office, a resident director or an annual board meeting?
- How easy is it to travel to the domicile, find service providers there and bring the regulator's staff into early conversations?
- How would we leave the domicile if we ever had to move or close the captive?
4. Choosing a structure
- Does the company want to insure only itself and its affiliates, or to share risk with unrelated owners?
- Is the volume of premium large enough to carry the fixed costs of a stand-alone company, or would a cell or a group structure spread them better?
- How much control over claims, investments and governance do we want, and how much are we willing to give up?
- Is the liability line eligible for a risk retention group, and do we meet the ownership and purpose tests of the federal risk retention law?
- Does a sponsor or a group have a track record, financial strength and rules we have read in full?
- What happens to our cell or our share if another participant has a bad year?
- What are the exit terms, and how do we get capital back?
- Who owns the data and the claims files in each structure?
- Which structure is the easiest to explain to the board, the lenders and the auditor?
5. The fronting term sheet
- Which lines does the fronting insurer issue, and does the term sheet cover each of them by name?
- What is the fronting fee, how is it computed, and does it move if premium moves?
- What premium taxes, assessments and other charges are passed through to the parent?
- What collateral does the fronting insurer ask for, how is it sized, when is it reset and how is it released?
- Who handles claims, under what authority, and what must be reported to the captive and when?
- What are the reporting dates for premium, loss and reserve data, and what are the consequences of late reports?
- Under what conditions can the fronting insurer cancel, not renew or change the terms?
- What happens to open claims and to collateral if the arrangement ends?
- Does the fronting insurer's rating or licensing status matter to our customers, lenders or contracts, and have we checked?
6. Reviewing the stop-loss
- Is the attachment point stated as a percentage of expected losses, a fixed amount or both, and which losses count toward it?
- What is the limit, and does it reset or is it a single aggregate for the year?
- Are there exclusions, sublimits or conditions that would surprise us after a bad year?
- Does the cover respond to losses by accident year or by policy year, and does that match how the captive books losses?
- How are claims on the stop-loss reported, how fast, and what proof does the reinsurer ask for?
- How strong is the reinsurer, and is any collateral or security requested from either side?
- Which scenarios from the feasibility study would trigger a recovery, and which would not?
- How is the premium set, and what would change it at renewal?
- Who in the captive decides to renew, change or drop the cover, and is that decision recorded in the board minutes?
7. The license application file
- Is the business plan complete: purpose, owners, lines, structure, premium projections and the five-year pro forma statements?
- Does the file include the feasibility study and the actuary's report or a summary of it?
- Are the owners, directors and officers identified, with the biographical information the regulator asks for?
- Is the source of the initial capital described, and is the form of the capital allowed in the domicile?
- Are the fronting and reinsurance arrangements in draft form, and do they match the numbers in the business plan?
- Have the captive manager agreement and the service agreements been drafted?
- Are the policy forms, if any are written directly, ready for review?
- Who answers the regulator's questions, and how fast can they do it?
- Does the file match what outside counsel and the captive manager believe the rules of the domicile require today?
8. Capital and collateral plan
- How much capital is the captive required to hold, and how much do we choose to hold above that?
- How will the captive be funded: cash, letter of credit or both, and who bears the cost?
- How is the collateral for the fronting insurer computed, and when is it reset?
- What happens to the collateral requirement as reserves build up over the years?
- How does the captive plan to pay claims in cash, and how much liquidity does it need each year?
- What is the investment policy: assets allowed, limits, duration and who approves changes?
- Under what conditions would the captive ask the regulator to approve a dividend or a return of capital?
- What is the plan if losses are worse than expected and the captive needs more capital?
- Has the board seen all of this in one page, with the assumptions written down?
9. The captive's annual calendar
- Which dates are fixed by the policy year: renewals, collateral resets, premium installments?
- When are the quarterly and year-end data due from the fronting insurer and the third-party administrator?
- When does the actuary receive the data, and when is the draft report due?
- When are the annual statement, the audited accounts and the actuarial opinion due to the regulator?
- When is the annual board meeting, and who books the room, the travel and the regulator's calendar?
- When does the captive pay premium taxes and file the related returns?
- When do investment reviews, reinsurance renewals and the letter of credit renewal happen?
- Who on the parent's side needs the results, such as the chief financial officer, the auditor and the tax advisers, and by when?
- Which tasks depend on others, and what is the earliest date the whole chain can start?
10. The board meeting pack
- Is there a one-page summary with premium, losses, reserves, surplus and the main ratios against the plan?
- Does the pack show claims in detail: new, open, large, closed and any in dispute?
- Does it show the actuary's latest view of reserves and what changed since the previous one?
- Are the investment results and the compliance with the investment policy included?
- Does it list the regulator's requirements and the status of each one?
- Does it cover the fronting insurer, the reinsurer and the bank: renewals, collateral and any open points?
- Are there decisions for the board to take, clearly marked, with the options and the effect of each?
- Does it include the minutes of the last meeting and the open action items?
- Is the pack sent far enough ahead for directors to read it?
11. Questions for the tax advisers
These are questions only. They do not state or suggest a position, and the answers belong to the advisers and to the facts of each company.
- What facts about the arrangement matter for the question of insurance status, and what do you need from us to check them?
- How do you look at risk shifting and risk distribution for our structure, and what evidence would support your view?
- What would you want to see in the policies, the pricing and the claims practice?
- How do the rules on federal excise tax apply to the premium the captive receives, and where would it show up in our books?
- Do any of the current rules on reportable transactions, listed transactions or transactions of interest need to be reviewed for this arrangement?
- Which state and foreign tax questions arise from the domicile and the location of the parent's sites?
- What documents should we keep, and for how long?
- What would change your view of the structure, and how would we know?
- Who signs off inside your firm, and what does the sign-off cover?
12. Adding a new line of cover
- What is the risk, how is it priced in the market today, and why would the captive keep part of it?
- What data do we have on losses and exposures, and how good is it?
- Is the new line allowed under the captive's license, or does the business plan need to change?
- Who will write the policy: the captive directly or a fronting insurer, and why?
- What limit and retention would the captive take, and how much capital does that need?
- Which reinsurance or stop-loss cover would protect the captive if one loss used the full limit?
- Who adjusts the claims, and do they have the skills for this line?
- What would the premium be, how is it built and how does it compare with the market quote?
- What does the board need to approve, and what does the regulator need to approve before cover starts?
- How will we measure, a year later, whether the new line did what we expected?