This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Business Rates Valuation by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist
The forty questions below follow the order of the book. Each one says where to look and which chapter explains the point. Keep the online valuation, the valuation summary, the latest bill, any check notice and decision notice, and the lease to hand.
The list entry and the online valuation (questions 1 to 5)
- Does the description and the local council reference on the online valuation match the property named in your lease, title or bill? Look at the top of the entry (chapters 1 and 2).
- Which rating list is the entry in, and are the current and previous valuations shown with their periods? Look at the table of valuations (chapter 2).
- What effective date sits beside the current value, and does it explain where the previous valuation stops? Look at the dates in the same table (chapters 2 and 4).
- What do the valuation scheme reference, the base rate and the measurement method say about how the property was priced? Look at the lines under the description (chapters 2 and 3).
- Do the transitional relief certificate line and the special category code agree with the bill and with the use you know? Remember the entry shows neither owner, rent nor bill (chapters 2 and 6).
The valuation summary (questions 6 to 10)
- Is every floor area line described in words you recognise, and does each area times its price give the value shown? Look at the table of areas on the summary (chapter 3).
- Is the property measured on the basis the entry names, net or gross internal area, and does that suit its type? Look at the measurement method line and the summary heading (chapter 3).
- For a zoned shop, do the zone lines follow the pattern the summary sets from the base rate, and is any remainder priced separately? Look at the zone lines (chapter 3).
- Which additions or allowances sit below the area lines, and does each correspond to something at the property? Look at the items after the areas (chapter 3).
- How does the total value turn into the rateable value, and is the rounding visible on the page? Look at the last two lines of the summary (chapter 3).
The rating hypothesis and the valuation date (questions 11 to 14)
- Which date is used for values, and is it kept apart from the date at which physical details are taken? Look at the summary and any notice that gives dates (chapter 4).
- What physical state does the summary assume, and does anything at the property differ, such as an area, a layout or an item of plant? Compare the summary with plans (chapters 4 and 8).
- Does the use recorded match the mode or category of occupation actually carried on? Look at the description and your own occupation records (chapter 4).
- If something changed at or near the property after the list began, which material day and effective date would apply? Look at the check notice or the decision notice (chapters 4 and 8).
Multipliers and the bill (questions 15 to 19)
- Which multiplier does the bill apply, and does it fit the type and value of the property? Look at the demand notice and the table of multipliers in the book (chapter 5).
- Does the bill use the rateable value now on the online valuation, or an earlier one? Compare the two documents by date (chapters 2 and 5).
- Where the value changed after a bill was issued, has the council sent a revised bill, and does it change the instalments? Look at the bill history (chapters 5 and 9).
- Does the bill show a supplement, and is it described as the explanatory notes sent with the bill describe it? Look at the lines before reliefs (chapters 5 and 6).
- Can you rebuild the charge from rateable value and multiplier line by line on your own working? Look at the bill and your working side by side (chapter 5).
Reliefs (questions 20 to 24)
- Does the bill show transitional relief, and can you rebuild it from the base liability, the notional amount and the cap? Read the certificate line on the entry separately: in the case it reads no, yet the warehouse bill is capped (chapters 2 and 6).
- Given what else the occupier occupies, could small business rate relief apply? Look at the occupier's list of properties and the bill (chapter 6).
- Was any relief in place before the new list, and does the bill say whether supporting small business relief applies? Look at the council's records of earlier bills (chapter 6).
- Does any charitable, rural or local relief appear, and which body granted it? Look at the relief lines of the bill (chapter 6).
- For each relief shown, does the council or the Valuation Office hold the record, and whom would you ask? Look at the bill and the contact lines (chapters 1 and 6).
Who pays and empty property (questions 25 to 28)
- Who is named as ratepayer on the bill, and does that person occupy the property on the days charged? Look at the bill and the occupation records (chapter 7).
- If part of a property is empty, has the bill taken that into account? Look at the bill and any council correspondence on the split (chapter 7).
- For an empty property, which free period or exemption has the council applied, and from what day is the owner liable? Look at the council's empty property account (chapter 7).
- Do the lease and the occupation record agree with who the council treats as occupier and owner? Look at the rates clause of the lease (chapters 7 and 11).
The check (questions 29 to 31)
- Do the details the Valuation Office holds agree with plans, measurements and use? Look at what the business rates valuation account returns (chapter 8).
- Does the confirmation carry a date of receipt, and does it state whether the proposer is a smaller proposer? Look at the acknowledgement (chapter 8).
- Does the check notice list each alteration, with the new value and the day it starts? Look at the check notice (chapter 8).
Challenge and appeal (questions 32 to 36)
- Which ground does the challenge rely on, and does the evidence fit that ground? Look at the challenge statement (chapter 9).
- Do the dates of the check, the challenge and the decision sit inside the time limits the book sets out? Look at the notices and the calendar in Appendix B (chapters 8 and 9).
- Does the challenge give a proposed value, a start date and, for a let property, the rent details? Look at the challenge statement (chapters 9 and 11).
- Does the decision notice give the decision, the reasons and the evidence used? Look at the decision notice (chapter 9).
- What does the decision notice say about appeal, and which dates and fee does that route involve? Treat it as a choice still open, and note the dates (chapter 9).
Evidence and methods (questions 37 to 38)
- Is each rent used as evidence analysed to the statutory terms, with the adjustments written down? Look at the evidence schedule that supports the challenge (chapter 10).
- Which valuation method sits behind the figure, and does it suit the kind of property? Look at the summary and the decision notice reasons (chapter 10).
The lease and due diligence (questions 39 to 40)
- Who bears the rates under the lease, and how does the rates cost sit beside the rent? Look at the rates and outgoings clauses and the latest bill (chapter 11).
- What does the rating history show, and which windows or empty property charges are still open? Look at the list entries, the notices and the bill for every unit in a sale (chapters 11 and 12).
How to use the list
Work through the questions in order for a first reading of any property, and write the answer beside each number. A blank answer is itself a finding: it shows a document you have not yet seen. Where two documents disagree, note the dates of both before drawing any conclusion. The list teaches reading; it does not say what any ratepayer should do about a real valuation. Chapter 12 follows one complete case from start to finish.