This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read an Auditors Report by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Auditor's Report
The forty questions in this chapter are the last pass before you rely on an auditor's report. Not the first pass, when you read the report for the story, and not the deep dive, when you rebuild a note. The last pass, when the model is built, the credit memo is drafted or the audit committee pack is ready, and you want to know you have not missed a paragraph that changes the answer.
Each question fits on one line and comes with one sentence on why it matters. The chapter numbers point to where the rule or the method sits. The questions apply to Marlbeck Robotics, Inc. as much as to any real company: a reader who ran them on Marlbeck's Form 10-K for Year 1 would have found the going concern paragraph, both critical audit matters, the adverse opinion on internal control, the young engagement of Hythe Brayford LLP and, in Year 2, the change to Penwortham Strand LLP and the revision. None of the questions produces a verdict. Each produces either a check mark or a question for management, the audit committee chair or the auditor.
The report and its layout (questions 1 to 5)
Start with the page itself, before any single word of the opinion. Layout carries information, as Chapter 1 explains, and in Marlbeck's report two paragraphs sat between the opinion and the basis for opinion.
- Is the title the one used for a registered public accounting firm, or something else? Why: the title tells you which rulebook the report follows, PCAOB or another (Chapters 1 and 10).
- To whom is the report addressed? Why: the addressees tell you whose report it is, and a report addressed to someone other than shareholders and the board deserves a second look (Chapter 1).
- Which statements and which periods does the opinion cover? Why: a period outside the opinion is a period no one has opined on in that report (Chapter 1).
- What sits between the opinion and the basis for opinion? Why: going concern, internal control and other explanatory paragraphs live there, and readers miss them by jumping to the critical audit matters (Chapters 1 and 5).
- Who signed, in which city, and on what date? Why: the date sets the point to which the auditor looked for later events, and the signature names the firm you will check on Form AP (Chapters 1 and 6).
The opinion and its basis (6 to 10)
The opinion is one sentence long and decides everything after it. Marlbeck's was unqualified, and that word alone told the reader almost nothing about what came next.
- Is the opinion unqualified, qualified, adverse or a disclaimer? Why: each type means something different, and only the first is a clean opinion on fair presentation (Chapter 5).
- Which accounting framework does the opinion refer to? Why: an opinion on fair presentation is always an opinion under a stated framework, and a different framework changes what the numbers mean (Chapters 1 and 10).
- Does the basis for opinion state the standards followed and the auditor's independence? Why: these are the foundations of the opinion, and a gap here matters more than any later paragraph (Chapter 1).
- Is there any paragraph on consistency, a change in accounting principle or a correction of an error? Why: such a paragraph tells you the comparatives were not prepared on the same footing as the current year (Chapters 5 and 7).
- Is there an emphasis or other-matter paragraph, and what does it point to? Why: the auditor chose to draw attention to that note, and you should read it before the others (Chapter 5).
Critical audit matters (11 to 15)
Critical audit matters are where the auditor explains the hardest judgments. In Marlbeck's report, they pointed to revenue from bundled contracts and to the goodwill of one reporting unit.
- How many critical audit matters are there, and does the report say if there are none? Why: the count is less important than whether the section is there and what it covers (Chapter 2).
- What is the principal consideration in each one? Why: that sentence names the judgment the auditor found hardest, which is the judgment you should test (Chapter 2).
- Which note and which critical accounting estimate in the MD&A does each one point to? Why: the matter is a signpost, and the substance is in the note and the estimate (Chapters 2 and 11).
- Does the matter or the MD&A give any sensitivity or margin? Why: a matter without a sensitivity leaves you to find the margin elsewhere, as Marlbeck's goodwill matter did (Chapters 2 and 11).
- Is there a significant judgment in the statements that no critical audit matter covers? Why: a critical audit matter is what the auditor found most challenging, not a list of every risk a reader cares about (Chapter 2).
Going concern (16 to 21)
Going concern is the paragraph that credit analysts read twice. Marlbeck's sat immediately after the opinion with its own title, and the plans in its note did not close the gap.
- Is there a going concern paragraph, and where does it sit? Why: its presence is the auditor's signal of substantial doubt, and its position tells you how prominently it is presented (Chapter 3).
- Which note does it point to, and does the note describe conditions, plans and management's conclusion? Why: the note is where the company sets out the arithmetic and the plans that the paragraph only summarizes (Chapter 3).
- Over what horizon did the auditor and management each look? Why: the two horizons can differ, and a debt maturity that falls inside both cannot be argued away (Chapter 3).
- Which of management's plans are approved, signed or merely under discussion? Why: a plan with nothing signed is a hope, and a reader should weigh it as such (Chapters 3 and 11).
- Does any loan agreement make the paragraph itself an issue, and is there a waiver? Why: covenants sometimes refer to the audit report, and the waiver, if any, sits in the exhibits (Chapters 3 and 11).
- Does the MD&A liquidity section tell the same story as the note? Why: two descriptions of the same position should agree, and a difference is a question for management (Chapters 3 and 11).
Internal control (22 to 26)
The opinion on internal control can be adverse while the opinion on the statements is clean. That was Marlbeck's position at the end of Year 1.
- Is there an opinion on internal control, and is it in the same report or a separate one? Why: not every filer has one, and when it is separate you must find and read the second report (Chapter 4).
- Is the opinion on internal control adverse, and what material weakness does it describe? Why: the description tells you which systems and which accounts the weakness touches (Chapter 4).
- Does the report say how the weakness was considered in the audit of the statements? Why: that sentence connects the two opinions and explains why one can be clean while the other is adverse (Chapters 4 and 11).
- Does management's conclusion in Item 9A match the auditor's opinion? Why: management and auditor reach their conclusions separately, and a mismatch deserves a question (Chapter 4).
- Is there a remediation plan, and do later filings report progress on it? Why: a weakness is a fact at one date, and its remediation is what a reader follows through the next periods (Chapters 4 and 11).
Tenure, partner, Form AP and inspections (27 to 31)
The people and firms behind the report are not on its face, apart from the firm's name and its tenure. Marlbeck's engagement was young, its partner new to the client, and a large share of the hours sat with an affiliated firm.
- Since when has the firm served as auditor? Why: tenure tells you whether this is an early audit, when the firm is still learning the client, or a long relationship (Chapter 6).
- Who is the engagement partner, and for how long has that partner led the audit? Why: the partner's name is on Form AP, and a new partner on a young engagement is a fact worth knowing (Chapter 6).
- Which other firms took part in the audit, and with what share of hours? Why: Form AP shows who did the work, and a large share outside the signing firm tells you where to ask questions (Chapters 6 and 11).
- What does the most recent public inspection report on the firm say? Why: it describes the inspected sample of the firm's audits, not this audit, and should be read for what it is (Chapter 6).
- Was the report reissued or dual-dated, and does Form AP say so? Why: a dual date limits the auditor's later work to one item, and Form AP is the cross-check (Chapters 6 and 7).
Restatements and auditor changes (32 to 36)
Restatements and auditor changes arrive in Form 8-K filings, not in the auditor's report. Marlbeck's Year 2 brought both a change of auditor and a revision of its Year 1 figures.
- Has the company filed under Item 4.02 since its last annual report? Why: a non-reliance report means earlier statements should not be used until corrected (Chapter 7).
- Do the comparatives in the latest filing differ from those originally reported, and is there a revision note? Why: a revision, the little r of practice, often appears only in a note (Chapter 7).
- Has the company filed under Item 4.01, and does the disclosure cover each element Item 304 requires? Why: the disclosure tells you about past reports, disagreements and reportable events in one place (Chapter 8).
- What does the former auditor's letter agree with, and what does it decline to comment on? Why: the letter is the former auditor's only public word on the change, and its structure is as telling as its content (Chapter 8).
- How many auditor changes has the company had in recent years, and do tenure statements and change filings agree? Why: a pattern is a reason to ask, never proof of anything (Chapter 8).
Reports outside PCAOB standards (37 to 40)
Not every report a reader meets follows PCAOB standards. Marlbeck's European subsidiary had an international report, and the private integrator it looked at buying had a report under AICPA standards.
- Under which standards was the report prepared: PCAOB, AICPA or international? Why: each brings different sections and different labels, and absences mean different things (Chapters 9 and 10).
- If the report is international, is the entity listed, and does it contain key audit matters? Why: key audit matters depend on the entity's status, so their absence in an unlisted entity's report is not a finding (Chapter 9).
- If there is a going concern section in an international report, which note does it point to? Why: a material uncertainty section can lead straight back to a parent's own going concern position (Chapter 9).
- Is it an audit at all, or a review or a compilation? Why: only an audit ends in an opinion, and a buyer or lender who mistakes one for another relies on assurance that was never given (Chapter 10).
Before you rely on it
- Run all forty questions on the most recent report, not on last year's.
- Write each unanswered question down, with the person who should answer it: management, the audit committee chair or the auditor.
- Read every note that the report points to, in full, before reading any other note.
- Check the Form 8-K filings and Form AP since the report date, because the report itself cannot tell you what happened after it was signed.
Key Takeaway: Forty questions, in eight groups, take a reader from the layout of the report through the opinion, critical audit matters, going concern, internal control, tenure and Form AP, restatements and auditor changes, to reports outside PCAOB standards. On Marlbeck, they surface every finding of Chapter 11. None of them gives a verdict: each ends in a check mark or a question for the right person.