Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read an Airline Capacity Purchase Agreement

Free to print: Appendix A: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions, from How to Read an Airline Capacity Purchase Agreement.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read an Airline Capacity Purchase Agreement by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Appendix A: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions

Keep this list beside the agreement while you read. Each question is answered by the contract itself, not by this book, so the answer belongs in your own notes next to the clause number. The sentence after each question says why the answer matters, and the chapter named at the end is where the topic is explained.

Parties, scope and aircraft

  1. Is the agreement a capacity purchase agreement or a prorate agreement, and who keeps the ticket revenue? The answer decides whether the regional carries fare and load factor risk or only its own cost risk. See Chapter 1.

  2. Whose brand and designator code appear on the flights, and who sells the seats to passengers? The branding and the code-sharing arrangement show which airline holds itself out to the public and which one is the contractor behind the flight. See Chapter 1.

  3. Which aircraft are the covered aircraft, and in which schedule or exhibit are they listed? A fleet that is described loosely can grow or shrink without anyone noticing, and every payment term depends on the count. See Chapter 2.

  4. How many spare aircraft does the agreement recognize, and who pays for the aircraft that are not scheduled? Spares keep the operation reliable, and the contract must say whether they are paid for like scheduled aircraft. See Chapter 2.

  5. Who holds operational control of each flight, and where does the agreement say so? Control of dispatch and crews sits with the operating carrier, and the clause shows whether the major's influence over the schedule stops there. See Chapter 2.

  6. Who decides the schedule, the fares and the seat inventory? The balance between the major's commercial control and the regional's operating duties explains why the regional is paid fixed rates. See Chapter 2.

  7. Who owns each covered aircraft, and does the major lease or sublease any of them to the regional? Ownership and sublease chains determine who can repossess, who pays rent and who is exposed when the contract ends. See Chapter 7.

  8. How does the agreement treat aircraft that enter service in phases, or that arrive late? A fleet plan with delivery dates tells you when full compensation starts and who bears the cost of a delay. See Chapter 2.

Compensation and escalation

  1. Which rate drivers set the compensation, and what does each one pay for? Rates per aircraft, per block hour and per departure each cover a different slice of the regional's cost base. See Chapter 3.

  2. Is there a separate rate for aircraft ownership, apart from the fixed monthly rate? A separate ownership rate tells you how much of the payment follows the lease on the aircraft, which matters for removal and for accounting. See Chapter 3.

  3. Is the regional's margin built into the rates, or shared under a margin-sharing clause? A margin that is shared or capped changes the regional's incentive to control costs. See Chapter 3.

  4. Which index escalates the rates, from which date, and is there a collar around the change? The collar limits both an unexpected cost spike and an unexpected windfall for the regional. See Chapter 3.

  5. Which rates are escalated and which are left fixed for the whole term? A rate that never escalates loses value in real terms, so the list of escalated rates shapes the regional's long-term economics. See Chapter 3.

  6. What happens to the rates if the term is extended? An extension at the old rates, at new rates or at rates to be negotiated gives one side leverage over the other. See Chapter 9.

  7. How does the agreement treat a cost increase that the regional cannot control, such as a change in pilot pay? If the rates do not move, the regional absorbs the increase, and the effect on margin can be large. See Chapter 3.

Pass-through costs and reconciliation

  1. Which costs are reimbursed at cost, and which does the major pay directly? The three families of cost (covered by the rates, reimbursed, paid directly) decide who holds each line of risk. See Chapter 4.

  2. Is a reimbursed cost paid with or without any margin? Reimbursement at cost keeps the regional whole but earns it nothing, which matters when the list of such costs is long. See Chapter 4.

  3. How are estimates invoiced, and how often is the actual cost reconciled against them? A monthly reconciliation turns an estimate into a settled number, and a late one lets errors pile up. See Chapter 4.

  4. Who bears a cost that is not on the reimbursed list, or that exceeds an agreed ceiling? A cost that falls outside the list lands on the regional by default, so the list deserves a line-by-line reading. See Chapter 4.

  5. What documents must the regional supply to support a reimbursed cost, and can the major dispute them? The proof requirements and the dispute process control how fast cash comes back. See Chapter 4.

Performance

  1. How is the controllable completion rate defined, and which cancellations count as controllable? The definition decides which operating failures cost the regional money. See Chapter 5.

  2. Where do weather and air traffic control cancellations fall? Cancellations outside the regional's control are normally carved out, and the carve-out must be read for gaps. See Chapter 5.

  3. What are the bonus range, the no-payment range and the penalty range, and over what period are they measured? The ranges turn a service level into money, and a quarterly test behaves differently from a monthly one. See Chapter 5.

  4. On which compensation are the bonus and the penalty calculated? A bonus or penalty set as a share of block hour and departure compensation is far smaller than one set on all revenue. See Chapter 5.

  5. How is a controllable on-time departure measured, and which data source records the times? Time records from a data link such as ACARS settle arguments, so the contract should name the source. See Chapter 5.

  6. Does a run of poor performance give the major a right to terminate, and at what level? A default range that triggers termination moves a service problem into a credit problem. See Chapter 5.

Scheduling and utilization

  1. Who sets the final monthly schedule, and how far ahead must it be delivered? The notice period limits how late the major can change the flying the regional has staffed. See Chapter 6.

  2. What minimum utilization does the major guarantee, and how is it measured? A guarantee measured as a monthly average per scheduled aircraft protects the regional differently from a daily test. See Chapter 6.

  3. What is paid when the major schedules below the minimum, and does the payment give credit for costs the regional avoids? Full-rate payment and net payment can differ widely for the same shortfall. See Chapter 6.

  4. Can the major cancel or reduce flying outside the minimum, and on what notice? A broad right to cut capacity can empty the aircraft of work while the lease rent continues. See Chapter 6.

Labor and scope

  1. Does the agreement refer to the major's scope clause with its own pilots, and who carries the risk of non-compliance? The covered aircraft must fit within that limit, or the whole fleet plan is at risk. See Chapter 8.

  2. How are payments treated during a labor strike at the regional, and for how long? The allocation of strike risk can leave the regional paying for aircraft that earn nothing. See Chapter 8.

  3. How does the contract allocate the effect of a pilot shortage or a pay settlement? A shortage shows up first as controllable cancellations and then as penalties. See Chapter 8.

Termination, removal and wind-down

  1. Can the major remove aircraft without cause, on what notice and for what removal fee? The fee measured against the rent still owed shows who pays for the major's choice. See Chapter 7.

  2. Who bears the lease rent on a removed aircraft, and what rights does the regional have to sublease it to another carrier? A removal leaves the regional with leases that no longer have work behind them. See Chapter 7.

  3. Which events let each side terminate, and what cure periods apply? Termination rights that are unequal show where the bargaining power sits. See Chapter 9.

  4. What wind-down schedule governs the return of aircraft and the end of flying, and who pays during it? An orderly exit protects crews, lessors and passengers, and the contract should set its pace. See Chapter 9.

Control, audit and accounting

  1. Does the regional agree to fly only for the major, or to give the major terms as good as any other partner receives, and what happens on a change of control? Exclusivity, the most favored nation clause and the change of control clause together fix who can leave and who can be replaced. See Chapter 10.

  2. What audit and set-off rights does the major hold, over which records and for how long? A right to set off an amount claimed against later payments gives the major a quiet remedy that does not need a dispute. See Chapter 10.

  3. How should the contract be read for accounting and credit, including embedded leases, revenue recognition and customer concentration? The same clauses that allocate risk also decide what appears on the regional's balance sheet and how dependent it is on one customer. See Chapter 11.