Free companion page
Free to print: Appendix A: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Set of Proposals, from How to Read an Administrator's Proposals.
This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read an Administrator's Proposals by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
Keep this list beside you when a set of administration papers arrives. The questions follow the order in which the papers usually reach a creditor, and each ends with the chapter that explains how to answer it. They are prompts for your own reading, not a test and not advice. Chapter 12 takes the whole of the Harrowcliffe case through every one of these steps, day by day.
Which route put the company into administration: the court, the holder of a qualifying floating charge, or the company or its directors? Who signed the appointment, and who consented to it? (Chapter 1)
Which documents have reached me so far, such as the notice of appointment, the statement of affairs, the statement of proposals and any pre-pack statement, and which should I expect to receive next? (Chapter 1)
Did the statement of proposals arrive within the time the law allows? If it is late, does it say why, and is the explanation specific to this case? (Chapter 4)
Does the statement name the statutory purpose being pursued, and does it explain in plain words why a higher objective could not be reached? (Chapter 2)
Is the company's centre of main interests stated, and does anything suggest that Scottish or Northern Irish rules, which are separate, might apply instead of the English ones? (Chapter 1)
By what dates must I send my proof of debt, ask for a decision or put myself forward for a creditors' committee, and to whom in the administrators' firm do I address each request? (Chapter 10)
Does the statement of affairs show both a book value and an estimated to realise figure for every asset, split between assets under a fixed charge, assets under a floating charge and free assets? (Chapter 3)
Which classes of asset show the widest gap between book value and estimated to realise, and does the statement tell me why the gap is so wide? (Chapter 3)
Have the administrators commented on any directors' figures that they think are overstated? If so, does the estimated outcome statement follow the administrators' figures or the directors' ones? (Chapter 3)
Is the deficiency as regards creditors stated, and can I rebuild it from the total of the liabilities, the share capital and the total estimated to realise? (Chapter 3)
Is my own debt listed in the right category, whether secured, preferential or unsecured, and in the right amount? Who prepared the statement, and who has verified it? (Chapter 3)
Have the people asked to support the statement sent in their statements of concurrence? Is any information left out of the version that I can see, and is a reason given? (Chapter 3)
Was the business sold on the day of the appointment or soon after it, and does the statement explain why the sale could not wait for the creditors to see the proposals first? (Chapter 5)
Has a SIP 16 statement been sent, was it sent promptly, and does it appear again in the statement of proposals? If it is late, is the delay explained? (Chapter 5)
Does the statement describe the marketing: who was approached, by what means, over what period, and why the chosen offer was preferred to the others received? (Chapter 5)
Does each of the six marketing essentials receive a clear answer, and where the administrators departed from one, is the departure explained in terms that a creditor can test? (Chapter 5)
Who valued the assets? What independence and insurance did the valuer have, and are both the in situ value and the ex situ value of each main asset shown? (Chapter 5)
How is the price divided between assets under the fixed charge and assets under the floating charge, and is each allocation supported by a valuation rather than by an assertion? (Chapter 5)
How much of the price was paid on completion, how much is deferred consideration, when is each deferred instalment due, and what security stands behind the deferred part? (Chapter 5)
Is the buyer a connected person? If so, was a qualifying report obtained, from whom, with what opinion, and with what insurance? Did the buyer give a viability statement? (Chapter 6)
Which assets are subject to a fixed charge, and what is taken from their proceeds before the secured lender is paid? (Chapter 7)
Which costs and expenses of the administration are paid out of floating charge money ahead of the preferential creditors, and does the statement list them separately? (Chapter 7)
Which claims are ordinary preferential and which are secondary preferential? Does the statement place any claim of HMRC in the right class, and does it explain the split? (Chapter 7)
Is the net property stated, and is the prescribed part worked out from it in a way I can follow, including whether a cap applies to the charge in question? (Chapter 7)
Does the statement say whether the secured lender will share in the prescribed part for any shortfall on its debt? If the lender has agreed not to, is that written down? (Chapter 7)
Does the estimated outcome statement start from the same realisations as the statement of affairs, and where it differs, can I trace each difference to a comment by the administrators? (Chapter 8)
What dividend is estimated for each class of creditor, in pence in the pound, and what assumptions about costs and recoveries does each figure rest on? (Chapter 8)
Does the statement compare the likely result with what an immediate winding up would produce, and are the assumptions of that comparison set out clearly enough to be questioned? (Chapter 2)
On what basis do the administrators propose to be paid, whether time costs, a percentage or a fixed sum, and who is to fix that basis: a creditors' committee, the creditors or the secured lender? (Chapter 9)
Is a fees estimate given, with enough detail about the work, the grades of staff, the hourly rates and the hours for me to judge whether it is reasonable? (Chapter 9)
What expenses are expected, split by type, and are any category 2 expenses included? If so, is it clear how they are charged and who must approve them? (Chapter 9)
Were any costs incurred before the appointment? Who incurred them, what work did they cover, what has already been paid, and has anyone been asked to approve the balance separately? (Chapter 9)
Does the estimated outcome statement use the same fees, expenses and pre-administration costs as the fees estimate and the costs statement, or has a figure changed between pages? (Chapter 8)
If costs rise beyond the estimate, what does the statement say about asking for approval of more, and what route does a creditor have to challenge the fees? (Chapter 9)
Does the statement say that no decision is sought because unsecured creditors can receive only the prescribed part? What must a creditor do to ask for a decision anyway, and by when? (Chapter 10)
If a decision is sought, is the procedure deemed consent, an electronic vote or a meeting, and what exactly must I do if I want to object or to vote? (Chapter 10)
Is a creditors' committee proposed? What may it decide, what may it demand from the administrators, and which creditor types ought to be on it? (Chapter 10)
When will the first progress report arrive, and will it compare actual receipts and payments with the figures that the statement of affairs and the outcome statement gave? (Chapter 11)
What investigations are planned into the sale, into earlier payments to connected people and into the conduct of the directors, and what will be reported back to creditors? (Chapter 11)
How is the administration expected to end, by dissolution, by a move to creditors' voluntary liquidation or by an arrangement, and whose consent is needed if it must be extended? (Chapter 11)