Free companion page

Companion page: The 401(k) Plan Administrator

Free to print: Tool 2: The Form 5500 and schedules check-list ; The formulas, from The 401(k) Plan Administrator.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from The 401(k) Plan Administrator by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Tool 2: The Form 5500 and schedules check-list

This is the check-list as Lakefront uses it. Rules come from the 2024 Instructions for Form 5500, issued jointly by the IRS, the Department of Labor and the PBGC, read 22 October 2026. A later edition may exist, so the rules below are stated under the 2024 instructions only.

  1. Plan year and plan number.
  2. Participant counts at the beginning and at the end of the year, with account balances.
  3. Filing category and the 80 to 120 election.
  4. Schedules for a large plan: Schedule H, plus service provider and other schedules as the instructions require.
  5. The independent qualified public accountant's report, for a large plan.
  6. Late deposits reported.
  7. Fidelity bond.
  8. Corrective distributions.
  9. Signatures.
  10. Electronic filing.
  11. Extension on Form 5558, if needed.

Rules behind the list, under the 2024 instructions:

Point Rule
Due date The last day of the 7th calendar month after the plan year; one extension of up to 2 and a half months with Form 5558 filed on or before the normal due date
Small plan Generally fewer than 100 participants at the beginning of the plan year; the count for a defined contribution plan comes from line 6g(1), participants with account balances at the start of the year
First return The plan uses line 6g(2), participants with account balances at the end of the plan year
80 to 120 If the count is between 80 and 120 and a return was filed for the prior year, the plan may file in the same category as the prior year
Large plan Schedule H, and generally an independent qualified public accountant's report attached
Form 5500-SF Available to a small plan if eligible; conditions include no employer securities and not being a multiemployer plan
Penalties The Department of Labor may assess up to $2,670 a day for a late or incomplete report (indexed, check the agency's site); the IRS $250 a day up to $150,000; a delinquent filer voluntary compliance program offers reduced penalties

Case example. For 2025, 98 participants had balances on 1 January 2025: small plan, Form 5500-SF, due 31 July 2026, filed 24 July 2026, no audit. For 2026, 127 participants on 1 January 2026 is above 120, so the 80 to 120 rule cannot keep the small-plan category. The plan is large: Form 5500 with Schedule H and the accountant's report. Had the count been 112, the plan could have elected to file again as a small plan, since the prior year's filing was small. The audit engagement letter was signed on 14 October 2026 with Brandt and Osei CPAs.

Check: count the line 6g(1) figure from the recordkeeper's own report on the first day of the year, and write the source on the file. Chapter 11 holds the full method.

The formulas

The IRS pages set out three traditional safe harbor formulas. According to the overview page read on 22 October 2026, the employer gives one of these:

Formula Contribution Who receives it
Nonelective 3 percent of compensation each NHCE, deferring or not
Basic match 100 percent of deferrals up to 3 percent of pay, plus 50 percent of deferrals above 3 percent up to 5 percent NHCEs who defer
Enhanced match at least as favorable as the basic match NHCEs who defer

The enhanced match has three conditions on the same page: its rate cannot rise as the deferral rate rises, it cannot match deferrals above 6 percent of compensation, and HCEs cannot receive a higher rate than NHCEs. The enhanced design costed in the case matches 100 percent of deferrals up to 4 percent of pay. At every deferral rate it gives at least what the basic match gives: at 3 percent it gives 3 percent against 3, at 4 percent it gives 4 against 3.5, and from 5 percent up it gives 4 against 4. It does not rise with the deferral rate and stops well below 6 percent, so the case treats it as meeting the conditions.

The key difference between the formulas is who gets money. The nonelective goes to every eligible NHCE whether or not the employee defers. The matches go only to employees who defer, and only in proportion to what they defer. That difference drives the cost comparison in the next section.

Two other rules from the same page shape the choice. Traditional safe harbor contributions are fully vested at once: an employee who leaves keeps them. And the formulas set the minimum for NHCEs. An employer may give HCEs the same contribution, as the case design does, but the safe harbor rules are written to protect NHCEs.