Starting, Buying and Running an Independent Coffee Shop: Cost per Cup, Menu Prices and the Average Ticket, Labor and Tips, Rent and Equipment, Delivery Apps and Roasting, Break-Even, Cash Flow, a Drive-Thru Second Site and Valuation
A coffee shop looks simple, and its margin is decided by numbers nobody sees on the menu board: what each cup costs to make, how many items sit on the average ticket, how many tickets the morning rush can serve, how many hours are on the schedule and what the lease costs in tickets a day. This guide works through those numbers, from the cost of one latte to the sale of the cafe.
One fictional cafe runs through every chapter: Tilbury Lane Coffee Co., a neighborhood shop of 1,800 square feet with 32 seats, run by its owner as general manager. In 2026 it served 340 tickets a day at an average of $7.25, took in $886,957 and earned adjusted EBITDA of $109,173 (12.3%) after a market salary for the manager’s job. The book follows its recipe costs, its schedule and tips, its lease, its quiet winter months, a drive-thru kiosk and two offers for the cafe.
What is inside:
16 chapters in five parts: the cafe and its numbers, people, place and machines, beyond the counter, profit and cash, starting, buying and selling
Recipe costs: a 16 oz latte at $1.01 against a price of $5.25, a drip at $0.77, a cold brew at $1.17; the average ticket built from the item mix
A price rise of $0.25 per drink tested in tickets: it pays as long as fewer than 18 tickets a day are lost
Labor, wages and tips as read in the federal rules: tip pools, managers and tips, Form 8027, the deduction for qualified tips; a four-hour shift that must bring 16 tickets
Delivery apps, catering boxes and retail beans priced against the counter; roasting in-house that only breaks even at today’s 7,815 pounds a year
Break-even at 278 tickets a day, four stress tests, cash through the year, a drive-thru kiosk, a start-up budget of $445,697 and two offers for the cafe; check-lists and a glossary
Free: the coffee shop model in Excel
The Tilbury Lane model from the book, simplified, with live formulas: recipe costs of every item, the menu mix and the average ticket, labor, occupancy and other costs, the P&L with adjusted EBITDA and SDE, the break-even in tickets per day, three stress factors and two offers for the cafe. No macros, nothing locked.
Minimum wages, tip rules and tip reporting, food safety codes and permits, menu labeling, tax rules on equipment and build-outs, and SBA lending rules change, and many differ by state, county and city. This page will note material changes that affect the book.
Also by Julian R. Sterling
Related titles. The full list is on the author page.