What does a margin step-up do to an infrastructure loan's yield?
Infrastructure loans often raise the margin every few years to push the borrower to refinance. The step-up also changes what the lender earns, and in a way a flat margin cannot match once the upfront fee is counted.
A lender advances $100.0m at a 3.50% base rate plus a margin that steps from 1.75% to 2.25% in year 4 and 2.75% in year 6, with a 1.25% upfront fee. Its yield is 5.715% if repaid in year 3, 5.728% in year 5 and 5.857% in year 7. With a flat 1.75% margin it would fall to 5.470% in year 7.
The lender advances $100.0m and receives $98.75m of net cash. Interest is paid once a year and the principal comes back whenever the borrower refinances, at the end of year 3, 5 or 7.
Annual coupon by year
Year
Base rate
Margin
Coupon
1
3.50%
1.75%
5.25%
2
3.50%
1.75%
5.25%
3
3.50%
1.75%
5.25%
4
3.50%
2.25%
5.75%
5
3.50%
2.25%
5.75%
6
3.50%
2.75%
6.25%
7
3.50%
2.75%
6.25%
Step 1: the lender's cash flows
Repaid at the end of year 3: −98.75, then 5.25, 5.25 and 5.25 + 100.00
Repaid at the end of year 5: −98.75, then 5.25, 5.25, 5.25, 5.75 and 5.75 + 100.00
Repaid at the end of year 7: the same, then 6.25 and 6.25 + 100.00
Excel: =IRR(B2:B7) with the year-5 cash flows in B2:B7
Step 2: the yield by year of repayment
Lender's IRR, with the step-up and with a flat 1.75% margin
Repaid
With step-up
Flat 1.75% margin
Step-up adds
Year 3
5.715%
5.715%
0.0 bp
Year 5
5.728%
5.543%
18.5 bp
Year 7
5.857%
5.470%
38.7 bp
With a flat margin the yield falls the longer the loan runs, from 5.715% to 5.470%, because the 1.25% fee is spread over more years. The step-up more than offsets that fall. The yield stays near 5.72% to 5.86% whatever the repayment date, and rises slightly if the borrower stays the full seven years. The average margin over seven years is 2.179%, and a flat margin of 2.134% would earn the same yield for a seven-year hold.
What if: the borrower refinances faster or slower
Expected yield with different repayment probabilities (years 3, 5, 7)
Case
With step-up
Flat 1.75% margin
Base: 60% / 25% / 15%
5.740%
5.635%
Fast refinancing: 80% / 15% / 5%
5.724%
5.677%
Slow refinancing: 20% / 30% / 50%
5.790%
5.541%
Base probabilities with a 1.00% fee
5.662%
5.558%
The base weights give 5.740% with the step-up against 5.635% flat, 10.4 basis points more. The step-up is worth most when the borrower stays and least when it refinances early, which is also its purpose: it is a price for staying longer, and a reason for the borrower to take the exit.
The common mistakes
Quoting the opening margin as the yield. 1.75% is the margin for three years only. The year-7 yield is 5.857%.
Forgetting that a flat margin dilutes the fee. A 1.25% fee earns more per year over three years than over seven, so a flat-margin loan yields less the longer it runs.
Assuming the step-up is collected. A borrower that refinances in year 3 never pays the higher margin. Weight each case by its repayment probability.
Ignoring that the step-up changes behaviour. A higher margin makes refinancing more attractive, so the probability of year-3 repayment is higher than with a flat loan.
Takeaway
Yield = IRR of the net advance, the coupons and the principal, with the margin changing at each step.
Here the step-up holds the yield at 5.72% to 5.86%, while a flat 1.75% margin falls from 5.72% to 5.47%.
Weight the yield by the probability of each repayment date, and model faster refinancing as a separate case.
Questions readers ask
Why do infrastructure loans have margin step-ups?
To raise the cost of staying and so push the borrower to refinance. Here the margin rises from 1.75% to 2.75% over seven years.
How does a step-up change the lender's yield?
It keeps the yield level as the fee is spread over more years. The IRR is 5.715% in year 3 and 5.857% in year 7, against 5.470% flat.
What flat margin matches the step-up over seven years?
About 2.13%, against an average step-up margin of 2.18%, because the higher margins arrive in the later years and are worth less in an IRR than their simple average.
The workbooks behind this article
The free companion file for The Infrastructure Debt Investor is one workbook that rebuilds three infrastructure loans, sizes and stresses them with the signed debt held fixed and prices them after expected loss. The loan in this article is invented and is not in it. No account and no email address.
Not on Amazon: 36 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on how to read the documents, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →
Also on this site
How does a margin ratchet work in a leveraged loan?A margin ratchet sets the loan margin from a leverage grid, effective from delivery of each compliance certificate. On a €300 million loan with a grid from E + 475 to E + 375 and leverage falling from 5.20x to 3.40x, the borrower pays €26,531,250 of margin over two years versus €28,500,000 flat, saving €1,968,750; the 45-day certificate lag costs the borrower €281,250.
How do you calculate a refinancing gain on a PPP project?A PPP refinancing gain is the net present value, at the refinancing date and discounted at the base case equity IRR, of post-refinancing equity cash flows less pre-refinancing ones. On an illustrative 480.0 availability project refinanced in year 5 at 4.5 per cent, 134.1 of cash released is a gain of 87.7; a 50 per cent authority share is 43.8 and equity IRR moves from 13.54 to 16.61 per cent.
How do you calculate the all-in cost of a commercial mortgage?An illustrative 60,000,000 five-year interest-only loan at 5.75 per cent (3.50 per cent swap plus 2.25 per cent margin) with a 1 per cent arrangement fee, 250,000 of borrower-paid lender costs, a 30,000 annual agency fee and a 0.5 per cent exit fee has an all-in cost of 6.23 per cent, 48 basis points over the coupon; a rival offer at a 2.00 per cent margin with a 2.25 per cent fee is cheaper only if the loan runs at least four years.
How much does a sustainability-linked loan margin ratchet save?A sustainability-linked loan ratchet saves the loan amount times the margin step. On an illustrative 300 million term loan with three KPIs at 2.5 basis points each, meeting all three saves 225,000 a year, 168,750 after 25 per cent tax and 112,500 after 75,000 of deductible verification and reporting cost: a present value of 426,464 over five years. Meeting two of three earns nothing, and the loan must exceed 100 million for the ratchet to pay at all.
How do you calculate expected loss on a loan: PD x LGD x EAD?Expected loss = PD x LGD x EAD. For a €100.0m term loan plus a €30.0m revolver (€10.0m drawn, 75 per cent CCF), EAD is €125.0m; a default EV of 75.0 less 8 per cent costs, discounted 1.5 years at 10 per cent, gives LGD of 52.2 per cent; at a 2.5 per cent PD, EL is €1.63m, or 148 bp of the drawn balance.