Articles

What can a funder pay for a $60m judgment when collection is uncertain?

A final judgment is not cash. A funder values it by weighting each way the enforcement can end, discounting the receipts at its target return and taking off the cost of getting there.

A funder that wants 15% should pay no more than $15.60m for a $60.0m judgment, 26.0% of face. Expected collections are $34.50m but worth $21.66m today, and enforcement costs take $6.06m of that.

The assumptions

Illustrative judgment against a foreign corporate defendant, invented figures
ItemValue
Judgment$60.0m, final and affirmed on appeal
Full collection40% probability, $60.0m received at the end of year 4
Negotiated settlement35% probability, 50% of face ($30.0m) received at the end of year 2
Nothing collected25% probability; enforcement is abandoned after year 4
Enforcement cost$2.5m a year at each year-end, borne by the funder, until the case ends
Funder target return15% a year

The purchase price is the most the funder can pay and still earn 15% on average. A settlement ends enforcement early, so its branch stops paying costs after year 2.

Step 1: the expected receipts, discounted

Expected collections: 0.40 × 60.0 + 0.35 × 30.0 = 24.00 + 10.50 = $34.50m, 57.5% of face

Full collection: 0.40 × 60.0 ÷ 1.154 = 24.00 ÷ 1.7490 = $13.722m

Settlement: 0.35 × 30.0 ÷ 1.152 = 10.50 ÷ 1.3225 = $7.940m

Present value of receipts: 13.722 + 7.940 = $21.662m

Step 2: the expected cost of enforcing

Years 1 and 2 are paid in every branch: 2.5 ÷ 1.15 + 2.5 ÷ 1.152 = 2.174 + 1.890 = $4.064m

Years 3 and 4 are paid only if there is no settlement, a 65% chance: 0.65 × (2.5 ÷ 1.153 + 2.5 ÷ 1.154) = 0.65 × (1.644 + 1.429) = $1.998m

Present value of costs: $6.062m, from $8.25m of expected undiscounted spend

Step 3: the most the funder can pay

Price = 21.662 − 6.062 = $15.600m, or 26.0% of the $60.0m face

At that price the funder earns exactly 15% on average, counting the enforcement spend as part of the investment

Excel: =0.4*60/1.15^4+0.35*30/1.15^2-2.5*(1/1.15+1/1.15^2+0.65/1.15^3+0.65/1.15^4)

The headline expected collection is 57.5% of face but the price is 26.0%, because the receipts arrive two to four years out and the funder pays costs on the way. Paying more than $15.60m lowers the expected return below 15%.

Price by probability of full collection (35% settlement, the rest nothing)
Full collectionNothing collectedExpected collections, $mFunder price, $m% of face
20%45%22.508.7414.6%
30%35%28.5012.1720.3%
40%25%34.5015.6026.0%
50%15%40.5019.0331.7%

Each extra 10 points of full-collection probability is worth $3.43m. A price of $10.0m needs a probability of 23.7%, so a funder that is offered the judgment at that price is betting on at least that.

What if: the terms are worse

Funder price under different assumptions
CaseExpected collections, $mPV of enforcement costs, $mFunder price, $m% of face
Base case34.506.0615.6026.0%
Target return 20%34.505.5413.3222.2%
Full collection takes 6 years34.507.5710.7417.9%
Enforcement costs $4.0m a year34.509.7011.9619.9%
Settlement at 35 cents on the dollar31.356.0613.2222.0%

The timing assumption matters most: if full payment takes six years the price falls by $4.86m, and a 20% target return takes off $2.28m. The model treats the three outcomes as fixed and independent of the price paid, and it ignores any court costs the defendant is ordered to pay.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What can a funder pay for a $60m judgment when collection is uncertain?

About $15.60m, 26.0% of face, under a 40% chance of full payment in year 4, 35% of a half settlement in year 2, 25% of nothing and $2.5m a year of enforcement cost at a 15% target return.

Why is the price so far below the expected collection of $34.50m?

Because the money arrives in years 2 and 4, which cuts it to $21.66m at 15%, and the funder pays $6.06m of discounted enforcement cost on the way.

How sensitive is the price to the chance of full collection?

Each 10 points is worth about $3.43m. At 20% full collection the price is $8.74m and at 50% it is $19.03m.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Litigation Finance Investor rebuild a fictional litigation finance fund: a single case, a portfolio facility and an award purchase, their waterfalls, multiples and IRRs, and the fund’s J-curve and net return. The judgment in this article uses invented terms and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 24 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on insurance and retirement, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: credit, private credit and distressed debt → · All 1908 articles →