Articles

What does a compensating balance do to the effective cost of a loan?

The rate in the term sheet is the cost of the money drawn. Fees on the unused line and balances the borrower must leave idle are paid on top, and spread over fewer usable dollars.

A manufacturer has a $20.0m revolver priced at 8.50%, with a 0.40% fee on the undrawn amount and a compensating balance of 8% of the commitment. Drawing an average of $12.0m, it pays $1,020,000 of interest and $32,000 of fees, earns $14,000 of credit on idle balances and has $11,300,000 of usable funds. The effective cost is 9.19%, 0.69 points above the quoted rate.

The assumptions

Illustrative revolving credit facility, invented figures
ItemValue
Commitment$20,000,000
Average drawn balance$12,000,000
Interest rate on drawings8.50%
Fee on the undrawn amount0.40%
Compensating balance, share of the commitment8.0%
Balance the company would keep at the bank anyway$900,000
Earnings credit rate on balances2.00%

The compensating balance is 8.0% × $20.0m = $1,600,000. Only the part above the $900,000 the company would hold for payments anyway is a real cost: $700,000 of money that is borrowed but cannot be spent.

Step 1: what the company pays

Interest = 12,000,000 × 8.50% = $1,020,000

Undrawn fee = (20,000,000 − 12,000,000) × 0.40% = $32,000

Earnings credit on the idle balance = 700,000 × 2.00% = $14,000, which offsets part of the cost

Net cost = 1,020,000 + 32,000 − 14,000 = $1,038,000

Step 2: what the company can actually use

Usable funds = drawn − idle balance = 12,000,000 − 700,000 = $11,300,000

Effective cost = 1,038,000 ÷ 11,300,000 = 9.19%

Excel: =(12000000*8.5%+8000000*0.4%-700000*2%)/(12000000-700000)

The quoted rate and what it becomes
MeasureCost a yearRate
Quoted rate on drawings$1,020,0008.50%
With the undrawn fee$1,052,0008.77%
With the compensating balance and its credit$1,038,0009.19%

The undrawn fee adds 0.27 points. The idle balance adds a further 0.42 points because it removes $700,000 from the funds the borrower can use while the interest is still charged on all $12.0m.

What if: a higher credit, a smaller draw

Effective cost when one input changes
CaseEffective cost
Base case9.19%
Earnings credit rate of 4.00%9.06%
Average drawn balance of $6.0m10.42%
No operating balance needed otherwise, so $1.6m is idle9.81%
No compensating balance, fees only8.77%

The cost is most sensitive to how much of the line is used. At a $6.0m average draw the same fees and idle balance are spread over fewer dollars and the effective cost reaches 10.42%. A company that rarely uses its revolver is paying for the commitment, not for credit.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How does a compensating balance change the cost of a loan?

It removes money from the funds the borrower can use while interest is still charged on the full amount. Here it takes the effective rate from 8.77% to 9.19%.

Which part of a compensating balance is a real cost?

Only the part above the balance the company would hold anyway. In this example $700,000 of the $1,600,000 required, less the earnings credit it receives.

Why does a low drawn balance raise the effective cost?

The undrawn fee and the idle balance are largely fixed, so they are spread over fewer dollars. At a $6.0m average draw the effective cost is 10.42%.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Commercial Banker rebuild a fictional middle-market acquisition financing, its covenants, collateral and relationship economics with live formulas. The revolver in this article is invented and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 11 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on banking, credit and payments, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: regulation, compliance and banking → · All 1908 articles →